kayg/infraternal
Watch
1
0
Fork
You've already forked infraternal
 0
Code Issues 356 Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Appearance presets: one transparency setting, preset carousel, Themes renamed Colors #323

New issue
Open
opened 2026-11-03 06:46:45 +00:00 by kayg · 121 comments
kayg commented 2026-11-03 06:46:45 +00:00
Owner
Copy link

Owner request, 2026-11-03. It amends D189 (card and window transparency) and the Settings → Appearance window (#304).

Owner, verbatim

I found this old mockup and I feel like it gave me the answer to the ghosting text.

we should make it simpler! not have options for cards and windows both and rather only have the windows options

in the settings → apperance section, we should have the 4 presets: actually we should just have 3: (the windows cards) solid tinted frosted

solid = 100% tint 0% blur
tinted = 75% tint 0% blur
frosted = 50% tint 100% blur

we shouldn't display px but should display rather a percentage where 0 px blur = 0% and 24 px is 100%.

so i am thinking the user should be able to create presets in appearance settings and let's make it very visual.

one horizontally scrollable strip of these cards where the last item is a dotted boundary with a large + icon to add more presets.

presets of course include: tint and blur, but also fonts, color schemes and UI size.

so top of the appearance window is just a carousel for cards where we have 3 presets for the user, which they modify to their liking with a "reset" button placed somewhere nicer. and they can add more presets. instead of themes, let's call them Colors.

The mockup he referred to is the D189 four-by-two grid. Its Windows row is the one he chose.

What this means (orchestrator's reading, marked as such)

  1. There is one transparency setting. The separate card and window levels go away.

  2. Three built-in presets:

    Preset Tint Blur
    Solid 100% 0%
    Tinted 75% 0%
    Frosted 50% 100%

    Clear is dropped.

  3. Blur is shown as a percentage: 0 px = 0% and 24 px = 100%. The UI never shows px.

  4. A preset bundles tint, blur, fonts, Colors and UI size.

  5. The top of the Appearance window is one horizontally scrollable strip of preset cards. The last card has a dotted border and a large +, which adds a preset.

  6. The person can change each of the three built-in presets. Reset restores a built-in preset's defaults, and the button is "placed somewhere nicer" than it is now.

  7. "Themes" is renamed Colors everywhere in the UI.

Open owner questions

  • a. Floating cards. Do popovers, the palette and the sidebar follow the chosen preset, or do they always use one shared overlay material (TASTE: one shared material, tuned once)?
    Orchestrator's default until he answers: they follow the preset.
  • b. Light mode. D189 used slightly higher tints in light mode. Do 100/75/50 apply to both modes, or does light mode keep its small offset?
    Default: the same numbers in both modes.
  • c. Default preset for a new person. D189 defaulted windows to Solid.
    Default: Solid.

Process

Mockup first, in mockups.html, built on the #304 Settings branch. Production code follows only after the owner approves the mockup.

Owner request, 2026-11-03. It amends D189 (card and window transparency) and the Settings → Appearance window (#304). ## Owner, verbatim > I found this old mockup and I feel like it gave me the answer to the ghosting text. > > we should make it simpler! not have options for cards and windows both and rather only have the windows options > > in the settings → apperance section, we should have the 4 presets: actually we should just have 3: (the windows cards) solid tinted frosted > > solid = 100% tint 0% blur > tinted = 75% tint 0% blur > frosted = 50% tint 100% blur > > we shouldn't display px but should display rather a percentage where 0 px blur = 0% and 24 px is 100%. > > so i am thinking the user should be able to create presets in appearance settings and let's make it very visual. > > one horizontally scrollable strip of these cards where the last item is a dotted boundary with a large + icon to add more presets. > > presets of course include: tint and blur, but also fonts, color schemes and UI size. > > so top of the appearance window is just a carousel for cards where we have 3 presets for the user, which they modify to their liking with a "reset" button placed somewhere nicer. and they can add more presets. instead of themes, let's call them Colors. The mockup he referred to is the D189 four-by-two grid. Its Windows row is the one he chose. ## What this means (orchestrator's reading, marked as such) 1. There is one transparency setting. The separate card and window levels go away. 2. Three built-in presets: | Preset | Tint | Blur | |---|---|---| | Solid | 100% | 0% | | Tinted | 75% | 0% | | Frosted | 50% | 100% | Clear is dropped. 3. Blur is shown as a percentage: 0 px = 0% and 24 px = 100%. The UI never shows px. 4. A preset bundles tint, blur, fonts, Colors and UI size. 5. The top of the Appearance window is one horizontally scrollable strip of preset cards. The last card has a dotted border and a large +, which adds a preset. 6. The person can change each of the three built-in presets. Reset restores a built-in preset's defaults, and the button is "placed somewhere nicer" than it is now. 7. "Themes" is renamed **Colors** everywhere in the UI. ## Open owner questions - **a. Floating cards.** Do popovers, the palette and the sidebar follow the chosen preset, or do they always use one shared overlay material (TASTE: one shared material, tuned once)? Orchestrator's default until he answers: they follow the preset. - **b. Light mode.** D189 used slightly higher tints in light mode. Do 100/75/50 apply to both modes, or does light mode keep its small offset? Default: the same numbers in both modes. - **c. Default preset** for a new person. D189 defaulted windows to Solid. Default: Solid. ## Process Mockup first, in mockups.html, built on the #304 Settings branch. Production code follows only after the owner approves the mockup.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 06:58:10 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J129 start: branch and plan

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, base c88619630 (head of settings-sections-mock-j92, the #304 Settings mockup). Worktree ~/Developer/Worktrees/infraternal-j129 on the control host. Mockup only: no production wiring, no push to dev/main.

Inputs read: BRIEF-COMMON, CLAUDE.md, TASTE.md, D322 (including the owner's answers of 2026-11-03), D189, D159, D275, D188.

The owner's answers (D322, now binding, replacing my defaults):

  1. Floating cards (popovers, palette, sidebar) follow the selected preset.
  2. One set of tint/blur values per preset, used in both modes. Each card's preview is split: the left half in the person's current mode, the right half in the opposite mode, both in that preset's Colors. The built-in numbers must pass the legibility and contrast checks in BOTH modes; if one fails I report it here with evidence and do not change the numbers.
  3. A new person starts on Tinted.

What exists today (found in the base): the Appearance component is four windows in settings-map/catalog.ts (Theme, Font, Size, Layout), each a slice of renderAppearance in packages/ui/src/settings-panels.ts through the only filter. Transparency is two capsule tabs (Card, Window) over CARD_LEVELS/WINDOW_LEVELS in packages/ui/src/themes.ts. Existing checks to reuse: transparency-contrast.spec.ts, glass-ghost.spec.ts, ghost-metric.ts.

Steps

  1. Preset model (mock only, ~45 min). mock/appearance-presets/model.ts: a preset = name, tint %, blur % (0% = 0 px, 100% = 24 px; px never shown), font, Colors id, UI size. Built-ins Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/0, Frosted 50/100; default Tinted; edited-state and reset for built-ins; add = copy of the selected one with an editable name.
  2. Preset strip (~2 h). One shared card component in packages/ui (extending the existing choice and capsule styles, not new basic UI): a horizontally scrollable scroll-snap strip of cards, then a dotted-border add card with a large +. Each card is a live preview over real terminal text (the D189 comparison content): name, "N% tint · N% blur", and the font, Colors and UI size drawn as marks (a type sample, a swatch pair, a size scale), split dark|light. Selecting applies. Touch, wheel and keyboard (arrows, Home/End) all scroll it; no page-level horizontal scroll; the strip uses overscroll-behavior-x: contain and touch-action: pan-x so one finger scrolls inside the window and two fingers still move the canvas rows (D275/D159).
  3. Editor below the strip (~1 h). Tint %, blur % (reusing the existing slider), font and Colors (the existing option lists, "Themes" renamed Colors in this window) and UI size (existing slider), all editing the selected preset. Card and window transparency tabs and Background stay out of the strip's way, in the existing groups.
  4. Reset (~30 min). Proposal: a small "reset" icon button with a warm tooltip, on the card's top-right corner, shown only on a built-in preset that differs from its defaults (an edited dot appears on the same card). Rationale: it sits on the thing it resets and nowhere else, per TASTE "icons over text" and "Every tap answers". I will show the changed state; the owner may prefer it in the editor header.
  5. Added state (~30 min). After +, the new card is selected, scrolled into view, and its name field is focused for editing.
  6. On demand, no budget growth (~30 min). All new code sits in the Settings on-demand chunk (settings-body.on-demand), and the mockup-only parts behind the preview flag. I will quote the three JavaScript transfer lines from the gate: baseline on this base is critical gzip=315010/327680, deferred gzip=61071/61440, onDemand largest chunk 16223/20480.
  7. Tests (~1.5 h). Playwright on dev-01 or dev-02: strip scroll by wheel, touch and keys; no page scroll-width overflow at 1440×900, 393×852 and 375×667; edges aligned to 0.5 px; contrast and ghost-text for Solid/Tinted/Frosted in dark AND light (pixel-measured over the real terminal text); one finger scrolls inside, two fingers move rows.
  8. Serve and screenshots (~1 h). Preview on a new port with its own entry on mockups.html (J92's entry untouched); production-build screenshots at DPR 2 (desktop) and 3 (phone): whole page in light and in dark, each preset selected, changed+Reset, just-added.
  9. Gate (~1 h of work, plus queue). scripts/verify fast, quoted verbatim with the head SHA.

Estimate: about 8 h of work. Wall clock will be longer: dev-02 is at load 43 on 10 cores (a bare uptime over ssh timed out), and compute01 has 4/4 slots busy with 6 jobs queued, so builds and the gate will wait for a slot. Per the leash, I stop and report if I pass 16 h.

Open items I will not decide myself: reset placement (a proposal, to be judged on the screenshot); the exact marks for font, Colors and UI size on the card; where Background and the old Card/Window transparency tabs go once presets exist (they are superseded by D322, so I remove them from the Appearance windows and say so).

Blocker so far: none. Note: the mockups.html source is not in the repo (it is served from dev-02, port 47650, from ~/preview-dev); I will add my entry there the way J92 did and keep the edit minimal.

## J129 start: branch and plan **Branch** `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, base `c88619630` (head of `settings-sections-mock-j92`, the #304 Settings mockup). Worktree `~/Developer/Worktrees/infraternal-j129` on the control host. Mockup only: no production wiring, no push to dev/main. **Inputs read:** BRIEF-COMMON, CLAUDE.md, TASTE.md, D322 (including the owner's answers of 2026-11-03), D189, D159, D275, D188. **The owner's answers (D322, now binding, replacing my defaults):** 1. Floating cards (popovers, palette, sidebar) follow the selected preset. 2. One set of tint/blur values per preset, used in both modes. Each card's preview is split: the left half in the person's current mode, the right half in the opposite mode, both in that preset's Colors. The built-in numbers must pass the legibility and contrast checks in BOTH modes; if one fails I report it here with evidence and do not change the numbers. 3. A new person starts on **Tinted**. **What exists today (found in the base):** the Appearance component is four windows in `settings-map/catalog.ts` (Theme, Font, Size, Layout), each a slice of `renderAppearance` in `packages/ui/src/settings-panels.ts` through the `only` filter. Transparency is two capsule tabs (Card, Window) over `CARD_LEVELS`/`WINDOW_LEVELS` in `packages/ui/src/themes.ts`. Existing checks to reuse: `transparency-contrast.spec.ts`, `glass-ghost.spec.ts`, `ghost-metric.ts`. **Steps** 1. **Preset model (mock only, ~45 min).** `mock/appearance-presets/model.ts`: a preset = name, tint %, blur % (0% = 0 px, 100% = 24 px; px never shown), font, Colors id, UI size. Built-ins Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/0, Frosted 50/100; default Tinted; edited-state and reset for built-ins; add = copy of the selected one with an editable name. 2. **Preset strip (~2 h).** One shared card component in `packages/ui` (extending the existing choice and capsule styles, not new basic UI): a horizontally scrollable scroll-snap strip of cards, then a dotted-border add card with a large +. Each card is a live preview over real terminal text (the D189 comparison content): name, "N% tint · N% blur", and the font, Colors and UI size drawn as marks (a type sample, a swatch pair, a size scale), split dark|light. Selecting applies. Touch, wheel and keyboard (arrows, Home/End) all scroll it; no page-level horizontal scroll; the strip uses `overscroll-behavior-x: contain` and `touch-action: pan-x` so one finger scrolls inside the window and two fingers still move the canvas rows (D275/D159). 3. **Editor below the strip (~1 h).** Tint %, blur % (reusing the existing slider), font and Colors (the existing option lists, "Themes" renamed Colors in this window) and UI size (existing slider), all editing the selected preset. Card and window transparency tabs and Background stay out of the strip's way, in the existing groups. 4. **Reset (~30 min).** Proposal: a small "reset" icon button with a warm tooltip, on the card's top-right corner, shown only on a built-in preset that differs from its defaults (an edited dot appears on the same card). Rationale: it sits on the thing it resets and nowhere else, per TASTE "icons over text" and "Every tap answers". I will show the changed state; the owner may prefer it in the editor header. 5. **Added state (~30 min).** After +, the new card is selected, scrolled into view, and its name field is focused for editing. 6. **On demand, no budget growth (~30 min).** All new code sits in the Settings on-demand chunk (`settings-body.on-demand`), and the mockup-only parts behind the preview flag. I will quote the three `JavaScript transfer` lines from the gate: baseline on this base is critical gzip=315010/327680, deferred gzip=61071/61440, onDemand largest chunk 16223/20480. 7. **Tests (~1.5 h).** Playwright on dev-01 or dev-02: strip scroll by wheel, touch and keys; no page scroll-width overflow at 1440×900, 393×852 and 375×667; edges aligned to 0.5 px; contrast and ghost-text for Solid/Tinted/Frosted in dark AND light (pixel-measured over the real terminal text); one finger scrolls inside, two fingers move rows. 8. **Serve and screenshots (~1 h).** Preview on a new port with its own entry on mockups.html (J92's entry untouched); production-build screenshots at DPR 2 (desktop) and 3 (phone): whole page in light and in dark, each preset selected, changed+Reset, just-added. 9. **Gate (~1 h of work, plus queue).** `scripts/verify fast`, quoted verbatim with the head SHA. **Estimate:** about 8 h of work. Wall clock will be longer: dev-02 is at load 43 on 10 cores (a bare `uptime` over ssh timed out), and compute01 has 4/4 slots busy with 6 jobs queued, so builds and the gate will wait for a slot. Per the leash, I stop and report if I pass 16 h. **Open items I will not decide myself:** reset placement (a proposal, to be judged on the screenshot); the exact marks for font, Colors and UI size on the card; where Background and the old Card/Window transparency tabs go once presets exist (they are superseded by D322, so I remove them from the Appearance windows and say so). Blocker so far: none. Note: the mockups.html source is not in the repo (it is served from dev-02, port 47650, from `~/preview-dev`); I will add my entry there the way J92 did and keep the edit minimal.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 07:01:32 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Correction to my plan comment (serving)

I wrote that mockups.html is served "from ~/preview-dev". That was a guess and it is wrong. ~/preview-dev on dev-02 is a dev release preview and has nothing to do with it. What I verified:

  • http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html is bun test/mock-server.ts (PID 1491229) running in /home/claude/worktrees/mockups/apps/tracer on infraternal-dev-02-std. That directory is a plain copy, not a git repo, and the file is hand-maintained there. It is no longer tracked on origin/dev (it was removed from the tree; git log --all -- apps/tracer/mockups.html still lists its history).
  • Each entry has its own origin: J92's #304 entry points to http://10.69.69.117:47660, which is bun test/mock-server.ts (PID 4044413) in /home/claude/worktrees/J92/apps/tracer, serving that job's production build.
  • So my entry is: my own production build in my own dev-02 worktree, my own mock-server on its own port, and one new { n: 323, ... } item in that shared mockups.html. I will back the file up first, make that one insertion, and not touch the other entries.

Also noted: dev-02 is at load 43 on 10 cores, and a simple ps over ssh takes more than 40 s there.

## Correction to my plan comment (serving) I wrote that mockups.html is served "from `~/preview-dev`". That was a guess and it is wrong. `~/preview-dev` on dev-02 is a dev release preview and has nothing to do with it. What I verified: - `http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html` is `bun test/mock-server.ts` (PID 1491229) running in `/home/claude/worktrees/mockups/apps/tracer` on infraternal-dev-02-std. That directory is a plain copy, not a git repo, and the file is hand-maintained there. It is no longer tracked on `origin/dev` (it was removed from the tree; `git log --all -- apps/tracer/mockups.html` still lists its history). - Each entry has its own `origin`: J92's #304 entry points to `http://10.69.69.117:47660`, which is `bun test/mock-server.ts` (PID 4044413) in `/home/claude/worktrees/J92/apps/tracer`, serving that job's production build. - So my entry is: my own production build in my own dev-02 worktree, my own mock-server on its own port, and one new `{ n: 323, ... }` item in that shared `mockups.html`. I will back the file up first, make that one insertion, and not touch the other entries. Also noted: dev-02 is at load 43 on 10 cores, and a simple `ps` over ssh takes more than 40 s there.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 07:18:51 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Progress 1: the mockup is built and pushed; the browser run is queued

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head 42aa9c907, base c88619630. Typecheck clean and unit tests pass on compute01 (15 pass: the 9 existing catalog tests and my 6 model tests). No browser run yet: compute01 has 4/4 slots busy and 6 jobs waiting, dev-02 is at load 43, so my Playwright job (build-slot, ~/j129-run1.log on compute01) is queued. Nothing below has been looked at in a browser; I will not call it done until it has.

What exists (each a separate commit, all pushed)

  • packages/ui/src/preset-strip.ts + styles: the strip. Solid, Tinted, Frosted, then a dotted-border add card with a 2.5rem plus. Each card is the same markup twice, clipped left and right: the left half in the preset's Colors, the right half in the opposite mode, with the same tint and blur. A card shows the material over real terminal text, "Aa" in the preset's font, the Colors as dots, the UI size as the sample's scale, the name and "N% tint · N% blur". Reset is a small icon button on the card's top-right corner, half outside it, only on a built-in preset that changed. A selected card has the accent edge and a tick on its top-left corner.
  • mock/appearance-presets/: the model (pure, tested), the editor (strip, then Name for a made preset, Tint, Blur, Font, Colors, UI size, all editing the selected preset; the existing sliders and the existing option lists), and the page-wide apply.
  • Switch: &presets=1 on the settings=sections URL. Without it the page is exactly the #304 mockup, so J92's entry and tests are untouched. With it, Appearance has three windows: Presets, Background (not part of a preset in D322, so it keeps a window), Layout.

Findings (with evidence)

  1. D275 conflicts with "the strip scrolls by wheel". gestures.ts (the comment above routeWheel): "Horizontal-dominant gestures (Shift+wheel arrives as one) and Ctrl/Cmd (zoom) are always the canvas's." So a sideways trackpad swipe over any horizontally scrolling thing moves between windows. I gave the strip the same rule vertical lists already have (it takes the swipe while it can scroll that way; a fresh swipe at its end moves on). It lives inside the strip component, not in gestures.ts, because that file is in the deferred chunk (369 B of room) and it amends D275. Owner question 1: amend D275 so any horizontally scrolling region takes the wheel while it can?
  2. Continuous tint and blur cannot use the product's level rules. themes.ts installLevelRules writes the four levels as literal rules because custom properties on the root restyled every element (its comment: 10 to 26 ms against about 1 ms with 1,800 elements). A preset's tint and blur are any percentage. The mockup writes two custom properties on the root (mock only) and the specs measure the cost; a production version must benchmark this again and may need to quantise the percentages into literal rules (TASTE §3: make the expensive look fast, never cheaper).
  3. Only three Colors have a light or dark twin (Ink/Paper, Mocha/Latte, Rosé Pine/Dawn). Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox and Dracula are dark only, so the card's right half falls back to the default of the other mode (Latte for a dark theme). Owner question 2: is that right until those get a twin, or should a preset with a dark-only Colors show only the half it has?
  4. The shared mockups.html is not in the repo (see my correction comment). I will add one entry to the dev-02 copy and nothing else.

Judgment calls, to be judged on the screenshots

  • The card is split top to bottom, including its caption, so a long line such as "100% tint · 100% blur" crosses the join and changes colours mid-glyph, each half fully legible. The alternative is to split only the picture and keep the caption in the current mode.
  • The selected card is an accent edge plus a tick, not the quiet row fill TASTE asks for list rows, because a card needs a visible state.
  • No delete for a preset the person made, and no sticky strip: neither was asked.
  • A mouse without a trackpad scrolls the strip with Shift and the wheel, the arrow keys, or by clicking the card that peeks in.

Next

Browser run (specs: behaviour and layout, then legibility in dark and light), fix what it shows, the production-build screenshots, the mockups.html entry and preview server, the gate with the budget lines.

## Progress 1: the mockup is built and pushed; the browser run is queued Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, head `42aa9c907`, base `c88619630`. Typecheck clean and unit tests pass on compute01 (15 pass: the 9 existing catalog tests and my 6 model tests). **No browser run yet**: compute01 has 4/4 slots busy and 6 jobs waiting, dev-02 is at load 43, so my Playwright job (`build-slot`, ~/j129-run1.log on compute01) is queued. Nothing below has been looked at in a browser; I will not call it done until it has. ### What exists (each a separate commit, all pushed) - `packages/ui/src/preset-strip.ts` + styles: the strip. Solid, Tinted, Frosted, then a dotted-border add card with a 2.5rem plus. Each card is the same markup twice, clipped left and right: the left half in the preset's Colors, the right half in the opposite mode, with the same tint and blur. A card shows the material over real terminal text, "Aa" in the preset's font, the Colors as dots, the UI size as the sample's scale, the name and "N% tint · N% blur". Reset is a small icon button on the card's top-right corner, half outside it, only on a built-in preset that changed. A selected card has the accent edge and a tick on its top-left corner. - `mock/appearance-presets/`: the model (pure, tested), the editor (strip, then Name for a made preset, Tint, Blur, Font, Colors, UI size, all editing the selected preset; the existing sliders and the existing option lists), and the page-wide apply. - Switch: `&presets=1` on the `settings=sections` URL. Without it the page is exactly the #304 mockup, so J92's entry and tests are untouched. With it, Appearance has three windows: Presets, Background (not part of a preset in D322, so it keeps a window), Layout. ### Findings (with evidence) 1. **D275 conflicts with "the strip scrolls by wheel".** `gestures.ts` (the comment above `routeWheel`): "Horizontal-dominant gestures (Shift+wheel arrives as one) and Ctrl/Cmd (zoom) are always the canvas's." So a sideways trackpad swipe over any horizontally scrolling thing moves between windows. I gave the strip the same rule vertical lists already have (it takes the swipe while it can scroll that way; a fresh swipe at its end moves on). It lives inside the strip component, not in `gestures.ts`, because that file is in the deferred chunk (369 B of room) and it amends D275. **Owner question 1:** amend D275 so any horizontally scrolling region takes the wheel while it can? 2. **Continuous tint and blur cannot use the product's level rules.** `themes.ts installLevelRules` writes the four levels as literal rules because custom properties on the root restyled every element (its comment: 10 to 26 ms against about 1 ms with 1,800 elements). A preset's tint and blur are any percentage. The mockup writes two custom properties on the root (mock only) and the specs measure the cost; a production version must benchmark this again and may need to quantise the percentages into literal rules (TASTE §3: make the expensive look fast, never cheaper). 3. **Only three Colors have a light or dark twin** (Ink/Paper, Mocha/Latte, Rosé Pine/Dawn). Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox and Dracula are dark only, so the card's right half falls back to the default of the other mode (Latte for a dark theme). **Owner question 2:** is that right until those get a twin, or should a preset with a dark-only Colors show only the half it has? 4. **The shared `mockups.html` is not in the repo** (see my correction comment). I will add one entry to the dev-02 copy and nothing else. ### Judgment calls, to be judged on the screenshots - The card is split top to bottom, including its caption, so a long line such as "100% tint · 100% blur" crosses the join and changes colours mid-glyph, each half fully legible. The alternative is to split only the picture and keep the caption in the current mode. - The selected card is an accent edge plus a tick, not the quiet row fill TASTE asks for list rows, because a card needs a visible state. - No delete for a preset the person made, and no sticky strip: neither was asked. - A mouse without a trackpad scrolls the strip with Shift and the wheel, the arrow keys, or by clicking the card that peeks in. ### Next Browser run (specs: behaviour and layout, then legibility in dark and light), fix what it shows, the production-build screenshots, the mockups.html entry and preview server, the gate with the budget lines.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 08:07:04 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Finding: the built-in numbers do not all pass the legibility checks in both modes (evidence, nothing changed)

Per the owner's rule I did not touch the numbers. Method: the repo's own checks pointed at the presets, apps/tracer/test/appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts (commit on this branch), run on compute01 against the production build of the mockup, 1280x800, DPR 1, in Catppuccin Mocha and Ink (dark), Catppuccin Latte and Paper (light). Branch head at the run: b34d25407. The raw log is attached as a file in the next comment.

1. Ghost text through floating cards (limit 0.02, ghost-metric.ts: the fraction of the text behind that still shows), over a dense page of text

Floating cards follow the preset (owner, D322). The palette and the sidebar:

Preset Palette (Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper) Sidebar (Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper) Result
Solid 100% / 0% 0.0000 / 0.0000 / 0.0000 / 0.0000 0.0008 / 0.0010 / 0.0003 / 0.0005 pass
Tinted 75% / 0% 0.1474 / 0.1502 / 0.1486 / 0.1460 0.2544 / 0.2568 / 0.2533 / 0.2539 fails, 7 to 13 times the limit, in both modes
Frosted 50% / 100% (24 px) 0.0010 / 0.0011 / 0.0010 / 0.0011 0.0015 / 0.0019 / 0.0011 / 0.0014 pass

Tinted has no blur, so a quarter of every glyph behind the card shows through it. This is the old "Clear" problem (D189: windows at Tinted/Clear had no blur because windows rarely sit over text; D322 now gives the same numbers to popovers, the palette and the sidebar, which sit over terminal text all the time). It is the same for dark and light, so it is not a per-mode problem. In the strip, the Tinted card's own "Aa" sample shows it too: terminal text fights the sample.

2. Contrast of the theme's text on a floating card (needs 4.5:1; 1st percentile over every pixel behind the text; p1 = the worst pixel after ignoring 1% outliers)

Preset Palette primary Palette secondary Sidebar primary Sidebar secondary
Solid 7.86 to 15.98 5.44 to 6.68 8.09 to 16.26 5.16 to 6.16
Tinted 6.06 to 11.79 pass 4.06 to 5.09 (Ink 4.11, Latte 4.19, Paper 4.06 fail) 4.93 to 9.56 pass 2.44 to 3.73 fail in all four
Frosted 6.32 to 14.44 pass Latte 4.37, Paper 4.38 fail; Mocha 6.41, Ink 5.16 pass 6.76 to 13.23 pass Ink 4.28 fails; Mocha 5.23, Latte 4.67, Paper 4.56 pass

3. Contrast of window text over the worst of the canvas backdrop (existing transparency-contrast.spec.ts method: the strongest mesh colour with a dot on it, through the window's fill; conservative)

Preset Mocha primary / secondary Latte Ink Paper
Solid 11.34 / 7.37 7.52 / 5.20 16.37 / 5.85 15.55 / 5.36
Tinted 7.16 / 4.65 5.90 / 4.08 11.11 / 3.97 12.22 / 4.21
Frosted 4.30 / 2.79 4.52 / 3.13 6.52 / 2.33 9.39 / 3.23

Primary text passes at Solid and Tinted in all four themes. At Frosted (50% tint) primary text fails on Mocha (4.30) and passes elsewhere; secondary text fails for Frosted everywhere and for Tinted on three of four themes. The repo already accepted this on the old thin levels (the same spec reports them and gates only Solid and Tinted primary), so these are reported, not hidden: the spec asserts Solid and Tinted primary and annotates the rest.

What I did not do, and what the owner can choose

I did not change a number. Options for the owner, none of which I applied:

  • a. Floating cards keep the shared overlay blur (D72, about 16 px) as a floor, so a preset with less blur than that still blurs its floating cards (fixes row 1 for Tinted without changing Tinted's 75%/0% on windows). Cards would "follow" the preset's tint but not drop below the overlay's blur.
  • b. Tinted gets a blur (for example 25% = 6 px does not fix ghost text: calibrated in glass-ghost.spec.ts, 8 px or less fails, 16 px passes), i.e. a different number from his 75% / 0%.
  • c. Floating cards keep one shared material and do not follow the preset (his earlier question a; he answered "yes", so only if the evidence changes his mind).
  • d. Accept: windows and the cards stay as specified and secondary text is reported.
    Recommendation: a. It keeps all three of his numbers for windows and fixes the one that leaks.

Note on test reliability

In my first run the third surface (the view list) could not open because the Settings mockup replaces the top pill with its breadcrumb, so only the palette and the sidebar are measured. The popovers (machine card, "?") are not measured; they use the same material as the palette, and the palette's numbers are above.

## Finding: the built-in numbers do not all pass the legibility checks in both modes (evidence, nothing changed) Per the owner's rule I did not touch the numbers. Method: the repo's own checks pointed at the presets, `apps/tracer/test/appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts` (commit on this branch), run on compute01 against the production build of the mockup, 1280x800, DPR 1, in Catppuccin Mocha and Ink (dark), Catppuccin Latte and Paper (light). Branch head at the run: `b34d25407`. The raw log is attached as a file in the next comment. ### 1. Ghost text through floating cards (limit 0.02, `ghost-metric.ts`: the fraction of the text behind that still shows), over a dense page of text Floating cards follow the preset (owner, D322). The palette and the sidebar: | Preset | Palette (Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper) | Sidebar (Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper) | Result | |---|---|---|---| | Solid 100% / 0% | 0.0000 / 0.0000 / 0.0000 / 0.0000 | 0.0008 / 0.0010 / 0.0003 / 0.0005 | pass | | Tinted 75% / 0% | **0.1474 / 0.1502 / 0.1486 / 0.1460** | **0.2544 / 0.2568 / 0.2533 / 0.2539** | **fails, 7 to 13 times the limit, in both modes** | | Frosted 50% / 100% (24 px) | 0.0010 / 0.0011 / 0.0010 / 0.0011 | 0.0015 / 0.0019 / 0.0011 / 0.0014 | pass | Tinted has no blur, so a quarter of every glyph behind the card shows through it. This is the old "Clear" problem (D189: windows at Tinted/Clear had no blur because windows rarely sit over text; D322 now gives the same numbers to popovers, the palette and the sidebar, which sit over terminal text all the time). It is the same for dark and light, so it is not a per-mode problem. In the strip, the Tinted card's own "Aa" sample shows it too: terminal text fights the sample. ### 2. Contrast of the theme's text on a floating card (needs 4.5:1; 1st percentile over every pixel behind the text; p1 = the worst pixel after ignoring 1% outliers) | Preset | Palette primary | Palette secondary | Sidebar primary | Sidebar secondary | |---|---|---|---|---| | Solid | 7.86 to 15.98 | 5.44 to 6.68 | 8.09 to 16.26 | 5.16 to 6.16 | | Tinted | 6.06 to 11.79 pass | **4.06 to 5.09** (Ink 4.11, Latte 4.19, Paper 4.06 fail) | 4.93 to 9.56 pass | **2.44 to 3.73 fail in all four** | | Frosted | 6.32 to 14.44 pass | Latte **4.37**, Paper **4.38** fail; Mocha 6.41, Ink 5.16 pass | 6.76 to 13.23 pass | Ink **4.28** fails; Mocha 5.23, Latte 4.67, Paper 4.56 pass | ### 3. Contrast of window text over the worst of the canvas backdrop (existing `transparency-contrast.spec.ts` method: the strongest mesh colour with a dot on it, through the window's fill; conservative) | Preset | Mocha primary / secondary | Latte | Ink | Paper | |---|---|---|---|---| | Solid | 11.34 / 7.37 | 7.52 / 5.20 | 16.37 / 5.85 | 15.55 / 5.36 | | Tinted | 7.16 / **4.65** | 5.90 / **4.08** | 11.11 / **3.97** | 12.22 / **4.21** | | Frosted | **4.30** / **2.79** | 4.52 / **3.13** | 6.52 / **2.33** | 9.39 / **3.23** | Primary text passes at Solid and Tinted in all four themes. At Frosted (50% tint) primary text fails on Mocha (4.30) and passes elsewhere; secondary text fails for Frosted everywhere and for Tinted on three of four themes. The repo already accepted this on the old thin levels (the same spec reports them and gates only Solid and Tinted primary), so these are reported, not hidden: the spec asserts Solid and Tinted primary and annotates the rest. ### What I did not do, and what the owner can choose I did not change a number. Options for the owner, none of which I applied: - **a.** Floating cards keep the shared overlay blur (D72, about 16 px) as a floor, so a preset with less blur than that still blurs its floating cards (fixes row 1 for Tinted without changing Tinted's 75%/0% on windows). Cards would "follow" the preset's tint but not drop below the overlay's blur. - **b.** Tinted gets a blur (for example 25% = 6 px does not fix ghost text: calibrated in `glass-ghost.spec.ts`, 8 px or less fails, 16 px passes), i.e. a different number from his 75% / 0%. - **c.** Floating cards keep one shared material and do not follow the preset (his earlier question a; he answered "yes", so only if the evidence changes his mind). - **d.** Accept: windows and the cards stay as specified and secondary text is reported. Recommendation: a. It keeps all three of his numbers for windows and fixes the one that leaks. ### Note on test reliability In my first run the third surface (the view list) could not open because the Settings mockup replaces the top pill with its breadcrumb, so only the palette and the sidebar are measured. The popovers (machine card, "?") are not measured; they use the same material as the palette, and the palette's numbers are above.
j129-legibility-run1.log
62 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-03 08:57:52 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone

Preview: http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, with #304 and #94 untouched) → the app at http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 1752858, mine: kill 1752858 when reviewed).
Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head e6113f26b. These were taken by appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts against the tested build of the same tree (f489d6c25; git diff f489d6c25 e6113f26b is empty: the later commits only squashed fixups). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha, light is Catppuccin Latte, background Soft so the windows' tint has something to show. Each card is split: the left half is the preset's Colors, the right half the opposite mode, same numbers.

Every image below is an attachment of this comment; the strips are close-ups of the card strip, the pages are whole screens.

Desktop, dark

Solid selected — whole page

desktop-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default) — whole page

desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected — whole page

desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field) — whole page

desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-dark-tinted-page.png

Desktop, light

Solid selected — whole page

desktop-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default) — whole page

desktop-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected — whole page

desktop-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field) — whole page

desktop-light-just-added-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-light-tinted-page.png

Phone, dark

Solid selected — whole page

phone-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default) — whole page

phone-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected — whole page

phone-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card — whole page

phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field) — whole page

phone-dark-just-added-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-dark-tinted-page.png

Phone, light

Solid selected — whole page

phone-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default) — whole page

phone-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected — whole page

phone-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card — whole page

phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field) — whole page

phone-light-just-added-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-light-tinted-page.png
## Captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone **Preview:** http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, with #304 and #94 untouched) → the app at http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 1752858, mine: `kill 1752858` when reviewed). Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, head `e6113f26b`. These were taken by `appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts` against the tested build of the same tree (`f489d6c25`; `git diff f489d6c25 e6113f26b` is empty: the later commits only squashed fixups). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha, light is Catppuccin Latte, background Soft so the windows' tint has something to show. Each card is split: the left half is the preset's Colors, the right half the opposite mode, same numbers. Every image below is an attachment of this comment; the strips are close-ups of the card strip, the pages are whole screens. ### Desktop, dark **Solid selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2b0f43e2-92ef-4d05-8572-439cb95cc1a6) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/f0dbba76-9a0d-4707-89c8-e372c4ea1294" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/10fc938f-6156-4490-ad21-5a09f756dd83) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/bc009a76-3e71-4ae6-b77e-f0dcb25a1709" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/4b4045a1-ad9a-451b-a761-e991fd1bd647) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9b34d1e0-32c8-4ccb-a4b4-4f68668fd01c" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/bb9a9c0b-a0ca-4c1a-a0ef-e6f6f205d26c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/303e159d-abae-484e-82ac-5b59668343b7" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/f6ce53a8-7974-42d2-9470-dbeffed9b1fc) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/585a8df0-724e-424b-83c9-e35206368b17" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/10fc938f-6156-4490-ad21-5a09f756dd83" width="760" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Desktop, light **Solid selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/dd27d6c8-8cb8-4515-b03f-0ab404f29e50) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/1821c8e7-7ea4-4f92-add1-d99ded4dbab5" width="700" alt="desktop-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/58c42604-6137-4d32-9ddc-6a16d0c29baa) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2cc43fb5-f5db-47c9-abb7-33cd8da06344" width="700" alt="desktop-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/231d2407-2e7a-4fc7-9101-f5c954a7d6e2) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/f69e00d7-8b2d-4b2a-a31e-a0ec128466a3" width="700" alt="desktop-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/46c40a09-65e6-47f5-ad2e-a5457d2b76a4) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/6439feb2-a840-45c8-aa11-20eb8159df49" width="700" alt="desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9159d484-b281-49b2-a087-e3503ac5f055) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/841acac0-1006-4fdc-ada6-22218e5bb4d5" width="700" alt="desktop-light-just-added-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/58c42604-6137-4d32-9ddc-6a16d0c29baa" width="760" alt="desktop-light-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, dark **Solid selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0871b310-7014-4d38-900b-f38a4d592251) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a1c7437f-7ec5-47a5-85da-b3a100f9fb21" width="330" alt="phone-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/5117b52c-e1fe-457d-a5bb-c49cd679532e) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/69d30e2e-1c3f-44bd-981e-7078f3548f4c" width="330" alt="phone-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2f76b03c-a7d4-4dad-b7ba-7e20b500cfed) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/5778dacb-73cc-4a49-b358-7683a864ffe0" width="330" alt="phone-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/6b8221fd-dd30-4003-98e5-7f091ba830a8) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/66c3e8f4-e859-457f-8d7e-c80c74a626f8" width="330" alt="phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a5a7e972-465e-4a54-8945-7cde16c26a26) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3e7cc016-bf3e-4b79-bfc9-09c0aff61cf6" width="330" alt="phone-dark-just-added-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/5117b52c-e1fe-457d-a5bb-c49cd679532e" width="300" alt="phone-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, light **Solid selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/af891988-a07f-4c68-b5e8-ce441316bd7e) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d6eed7f3-6b3e-45ca-97dc-a878459ede44" width="330" alt="phone-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/531ad9d4-3762-4880-b526-35f51590784c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9dd79852-c665-4b0c-878d-8ac24859f10d" width="330" alt="phone-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/807e2e8f-4062-4a0c-a5b4-5d9c71d2eb37) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/95af8671-ad48-4999-afd7-49214a5e5f6a" width="330" alt="phone-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur), Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/1929e032-6f0d-4c71-8155-68e7cfd1f019) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/81c20247-47a2-4617-9a88-e0fb5db12999" width="330" alt="phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after + (a copy of the selected preset, Name field)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/126de541-05f4-4fe5-be4a-03c3df425c82) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3c41d0f6-5811-4521-9495-3fc08f59983e" width="330" alt="phone-light-just-added-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/531ad9d4-3762-4880-b526-35f51590784c" width="300" alt="phone-light-tinted-page.png">
desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
88 KiB
desktop-dark-frosted-page.png
845 KiB
desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png
84 KiB
desktop-dark-just-added-page.png
833 KiB
desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png
83 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-page.png
596 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-strip.png
78 KiB
desktop-dark-tinted-page.png
1.1 MiB
desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png
88 KiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-page.png
804 KiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png
89 KiB
desktop-light-frosted-page.png
847 KiB
desktop-light-frosted-strip.png
89 KiB
desktop-light-just-added-page.png
823 KiB
desktop-light-just-added-strip.png
81 KiB
desktop-light-solid-page.png
574 KiB
desktop-light-solid-strip.png
78 KiB
desktop-light-tinted-page.png
1.2 MiB
desktop-light-tinted-strip.png
90 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-page.png
648 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
124 KiB
phone-dark-frosted-page.png
727 KiB
phone-dark-frosted-strip.png
144 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-page.png
639 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-strip.png
112 KiB
phone-dark-solid-page.png
456 KiB
phone-dark-solid-strip.png
62 KiB
phone-dark-tinted-page.png
838 KiB
phone-dark-tinted-strip.png
117 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-page.png
651 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png
129 KiB
phone-light-frosted-page.png
734 KiB
phone-light-frosted-strip.png
151 KiB
phone-light-just-added-page.png
632 KiB
phone-light-just-added-strip.png
109 KiB
phone-light-solid-page.png
439 KiB
phone-light-solid-strip.png
62 KiB
phone-light-tinted-page.png
876 KiB
phone-light-tinted-strip.png
124 KiB
desktop-dark-changed-reset-page.png
772 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-03 10:17:54 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Finish: mockup built, served and gated. Waiting for the owner's review (nothing merged or deployed)

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head 3322662c3, base c88619630 (J92's #304 branch), 7 atomic commits. TypeScript and CSS only: git diff --stat c88619630 HEAD -- '*.rs' 'Cargo.*' is empty.

Review it: http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323; #304 and #94 untouched; I backed the file up as mockups.html.bak-j129 and inserted one entry) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 1752858, mine: kill 1752858 when reviewed). Links in the entry start the page on each preset, on the changed state with Reset, on the state just after +, and in light and dark.
Captures: the comment above this one (40 images: desktop and phone, dark and light, Solid, Tinted, Frosted, Tinted changed with Reset, just after +). The page needs &presets=1; without it the page is exactly the #304 mockup.

Gate: scripts/verify fast, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at 3322662c3, verbatim

+---------------------------+--------------+
| Rust gate                 | Result       |
+---------------------------+--------------+
| fmt                       | PASS         |
| VT native fmt             | PASS         |
| CLI plugin compile-out    | PASS         |
| clippy                    | PASS         |
| SSH runtime test helper   | PASS         |
| real-binary fixture paths | PASS         |
| test                      | PASS         |
| SSH inode reuse fixture   | PASS         |
| shim process-per-user     | PASS         |
| cargo-deny                | PASS         |
| gate architecture         | PASS         |
| static builds             | PASS         |
+---------------------------+--------------+
JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315001/327680 brotli=262930/273408 bytes
JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174402 gzip=61066/61440 brotli=53863/55296 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=391833 gzip=154333/20480 brotli=137434/18432 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-hdgyrm3v.js: gzip=16220/20480 brotli=14394/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154333 brotli=137434, not limited)
VERIFY_EXIT=0

Budget (D188): nothing added to critical or deferred. Against the base's own gate (#304 finish): critical gzip 315,010 → 315,001, deferred 61,071 → 61,066, largest on-demand chunk 16,223 → 16,220 (the small drops are bundler noise from the exports I added; nothing grew). The strip, the editor, the model and the apply code are in *.on-demand.ts modules reached only from the mockup, and the mockups are left out of the production build entirely. The only edits to code that production reaches are three export keywords (heading, choiceBlock, paintChoice) and one (RESET_ICON): no new code.
The first gate attempt failed, honestly: VERIFY_EXIT=2 at head e6113f26b, all Rust rows PASS, one TypeScript error in my own new spec (a touch event type declared as string). Fixed in the spec's commit (3322662c3), typecheck clean, gate rerun above. The failed log is on compute01 as ~/j129-gate-run1-failed-tsc.log.

Tests

  • Unit (bun test, 15 pass): the model's rules (6) and the existing catalog tests (9).
  • Browser, production build of the mockup, compute01, run 4: 53 passed, 0 failed, on f489d6c25 (the tree of 3322662c3 apart from that one type annotation): appearance-presets.spec.ts (behaviour and layout, desktop 1440x900 and phone 393x852, plus the touch test), appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts, appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts. Four earlier runs found and I fixed real bugs: a first strip scroll computed with rects (the canvas camera's zoom made it overshoot a whole card; now offsets, and it settles with the window), the selected tick clipped by its own button, the colour dots on the wrong grid row (the alignment test measured them 30 px from the name), and a palette expectation that ignored the palette's own material.
  • Checked, all within 0.5 px where a length: the first card starts on the heading's left edge; cards share one top; name and dots share a centre line; both halves draw the same caption in the same place; Tint/Blur/UI size read as N% (never px); no "Themes", "Card transparency", "Window transparency" or "Clear" text in the window; the page and the pane never scroll sideways; one finger scrolls the strip and not the canvas or the pane; two fingers over the strip still move the canvas one row (D159, D275); the sideways wheel and keys scroll the strip while the window and the canvas stay put.

What the owner decided, and what I did with it (D322, answers of 2026-11-03)

  1. Floating cards follow the preset: done for the palette, sidebar, popovers, pills and tooltips. Detail the owner should know: the palette adds its own material on top (style.css: its fill is the card tint mixed 58/42 with the background), so at Frosted it is 71% opaque, not 50%, and at Tinted about 86%. It is pre-existing. The sidebar is the plain material.
  2. One set of tint and blur for both modes; each card's left half is the preset's Colors and its right half the opposite mode: done. The legibility result is on the finding comment above (#issuecomment-76672, with the raw log): Solid passes everything; Frosted passes ghost text but its floating-card secondary text is 4.28 to 4.38 in three cases and its window primary text is 4.30 on Mocha; Tinted lets 15% (palette) to 25% (sidebar) of the text behind through, in both modes. I changed no number.
  3. New people start on Tinted: done (?presets=1 opens on it).

Owner questions (each with my recommendation)

  1. Tinted floating cards leak text (finding above). Recommendation a: floating cards follow the preset's tint but never blur less than the shared overlay's 16 px.
  2. D275 and the sideways wheel. The strip takes a sideways swipe while it can scroll that way (a fresh swipe at its end moves on). It lives inside the strip, not in gestures.ts (deferred chunk, 369 B of room; it amends D275). Recommendation: amend D275 so any horizontally scrolling region does the same.
  3. Dark-only Colors (Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox, Dracula) have no light twin; the right half shows Mocha's twin Latte. Recommendation: fine until they get a twin.
  4. The card is split top to bottom, caption included, so "100% tint · 100% blur" crosses the join and changes colour mid-glyph (each half legible). Alternative: split only the picture, keep the caption in the current mode.
  5. No way to delete a preset you made, and Background kept its own window (not in a preset per D322). Neither was asked for; say if you want either changed.
  6. Production cost of continuous tint and blur is unmeasured: the mockup writes two custom properties on the root, which the product avoids for its four levels (10 to 26 ms against about 1 ms with 1,800 elements, per themes.ts). A production build must benchmark this first and may need to quantise the percentages into literal rules.

Not done, on purpose

No production wiring; no change to gestures.ts, themes.ts, the old Appearance panel or any number; no delete for presets; the old transparency levels remain in production code until the owner approves.

Cleanup

compute01: gate worktree and its target deleted, no stray processes, 156 GB free; ~/worktrees/j129 (node_modules and a preview build, small) left. dev-02: ~/worktrees/j129, ~/j129-preview-dist and the preview server (PID 1752858) stay up for the review; kill 1752858 ends it.

## Finish: mockup built, served and gated. Waiting for the owner's review (nothing merged or deployed) **Branch** `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, **head `3322662c3`**, base `c88619630` (J92's #304 branch), 7 atomic commits. TypeScript and CSS only: `git diff --stat c88619630 HEAD -- '*.rs' 'Cargo.*'` is empty. **Review it:** http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323; #304 and #94 untouched; I backed the file up as `mockups.html.bak-j129` and inserted one entry) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 1752858, mine: `kill 1752858` when reviewed). Links in the entry start the page on each preset, on the changed state with Reset, on the state just after +, and in light and dark. **Captures:** the comment above this one (40 images: desktop and phone, dark and light, Solid, Tinted, Frosted, Tinted changed with Reset, just after +). The page needs `&presets=1`; without it the page is exactly the #304 mockup. ### Gate: `scripts/verify fast`, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at `3322662c3`, verbatim ``` +---------------------------+--------------+ | Rust gate | Result | +---------------------------+--------------+ | fmt | PASS | | VT native fmt | PASS | | CLI plugin compile-out | PASS | | clippy | PASS | | SSH runtime test helper | PASS | | real-binary fixture paths | PASS | | test | PASS | | SSH inode reuse fixture | PASS | | shim process-per-user | PASS | | cargo-deny | PASS | | gate architecture | PASS | | static builds | PASS | +---------------------------+--------------+ JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315001/327680 brotli=262930/273408 bytes JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174402 gzip=61066/61440 brotli=53863/55296 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=391833 gzip=154333/20480 brotli=137434/18432 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-hdgyrm3v.js: gzip=16220/20480 brotli=14394/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154333 brotli=137434, not limited) VERIFY_EXIT=0 ``` **Budget (D188): nothing added to critical or deferred.** Against the base's own gate (#304 finish): critical gzip 315,010 → 315,001, deferred 61,071 → 61,066, largest on-demand chunk 16,223 → 16,220 (the small drops are bundler noise from the exports I added; nothing grew). The strip, the editor, the model and the apply code are in `*.on-demand.ts` modules reached only from the mockup, and the mockups are left out of the production build entirely. The only edits to code that production reaches are three `export` keywords (`heading`, `choiceBlock`, `paintChoice`) and one (`RESET_ICON`): no new code. **The first gate attempt failed**, honestly: `VERIFY_EXIT=2` at head `e6113f26b`, all Rust rows PASS, one TypeScript error in my own new spec (a touch event type declared as `string`). Fixed in the spec's commit (`3322662c3`), typecheck clean, gate rerun above. The failed log is on compute01 as `~/j129-gate-run1-failed-tsc.log`. ### Tests - Unit (`bun test`, 15 pass): the model's rules (6) and the existing catalog tests (9). - Browser, production build of the mockup, compute01, run 4: **53 passed**, 0 failed, on `f489d6c25` (the tree of `3322662c3` apart from that one type annotation): `appearance-presets.spec.ts` (behaviour and layout, desktop 1440x900 and phone 393x852, plus the touch test), `appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts`, `appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts`. Four earlier runs found and I fixed real bugs: a first strip scroll computed with rects (the canvas camera's zoom made it overshoot a whole card; now offsets, and it settles with the window), the selected tick clipped by its own button, the colour dots on the wrong grid row (the alignment test measured them 30 px from the name), and a palette expectation that ignored the palette's own material. - Checked, all within 0.5 px where a length: the first card starts on the heading's left edge; cards share one top; name and dots share a centre line; both halves draw the same caption in the same place; Tint/Blur/UI size read as `N%` (never px); no "Themes", "Card transparency", "Window transparency" or "Clear" text in the window; the page and the pane never scroll sideways; one finger scrolls the strip and not the canvas or the pane; two fingers over the strip still move the canvas one row (D159, D275); the sideways wheel and keys scroll the strip while the window and the canvas stay put. ### What the owner decided, and what I did with it (D322, answers of 2026-11-03) 1. Floating cards follow the preset: done for the palette, sidebar, popovers, pills and tooltips. **Detail the owner should know:** the palette adds its own material on top (`style.css`: its fill is the card tint mixed 58/42 with the background), so at Frosted it is 71% opaque, not 50%, and at Tinted about 86%. It is pre-existing. The sidebar is the plain material. 2. One set of tint and blur for both modes; each card's left half is the preset's Colors and its right half the opposite mode: done. The **legibility result is on the finding comment above** (`#issuecomment-76672`, with the raw log): Solid passes everything; **Frosted passes ghost text but its floating-card secondary text is 4.28 to 4.38 in three cases and its window primary text is 4.30 on Mocha; Tinted lets 15% (palette) to 25% (sidebar) of the text behind through, in both modes.** I changed no number. 3. New people start on Tinted: done (`?presets=1` opens on it). ### Owner questions (each with my recommendation) 1. **Tinted floating cards leak text** (finding above). Recommendation a: floating cards follow the preset's tint but never blur less than the shared overlay's 16 px. 2. **D275 and the sideways wheel.** The strip takes a sideways swipe while it can scroll that way (a fresh swipe at its end moves on). It lives inside the strip, not in `gestures.ts` (deferred chunk, 369 B of room; it amends D275). Recommendation: amend D275 so any horizontally scrolling region does the same. 3. **Dark-only Colors** (Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox, Dracula) have no light twin; the right half shows Mocha's twin Latte. Recommendation: fine until they get a twin. 4. **The card is split top to bottom, caption included**, so "100% tint · 100% blur" crosses the join and changes colour mid-glyph (each half legible). Alternative: split only the picture, keep the caption in the current mode. 5. **No way to delete a preset you made**, and Background kept its own window (not in a preset per D322). Neither was asked for; say if you want either changed. 6. **Production cost of continuous tint and blur** is unmeasured: the mockup writes two custom properties on the root, which the product avoids for its four levels (10 to 26 ms against about 1 ms with 1,800 elements, per `themes.ts`). A production build must benchmark this first and may need to quantise the percentages into literal rules. ### Not done, on purpose No production wiring; no change to `gestures.ts`, `themes.ts`, the old Appearance panel or any number; no delete for presets; the old transparency levels remain in production code until the owner approves. ### Cleanup compute01: gate worktree and its target deleted, no stray processes, 156 GB free; `~/worktrees/j129` (node_modules and a preview build, small) left. dev-02: `~/worktrees/j129`, `~/j129-preview-dist` and the preview server (PID 1752858) stay up for the review; `kill 1752858` ends it.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 11:13:43 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Gradient library question (owner, round 2): research and recommendation

Question: "is there a pretty mesh/gradient library we can use where we can proactively offer many matching gradients per colour scheme with really good defaults and the ability for the user to choose their own gradient?" Nothing was chosen here (CLAUDE.md foundational rule); the mockup uses our own generated gradients either way.

What I measured (packages downloaded from the npm registry on 2026-11-03; sizes are the shipped JavaScript, gzip -9)

Candidate Licence (read from its LICENSE file) Size Renders with Gives matching gradients per scheme?
@paper-design/shaders 0.0.82 Apache-2.0 (LICENSE file; a search summary said PolyForm Shield, the file and README say Apache 2.0, so I trust the file) mesh-gradient shader 1.3 kB, shader mount 6.0 kB, so about 7.4 kB; a noise-texture helper is 17.9 kB and I did not check whether the mesh shader needs it; 0.0.x versions, "pin it" WebGL canvas, one context per instance No: you pass the colours
@mesh-gradient/core 2.0.2 MIT 10.7 kB (index.mjs) WebGL canvas No: you pass the colours (the search summary said up to 4 colours; not verified)
culori 4.0.2 MIT 30.7 kB for the whole bundle (not tree-shaken; not measured) none: a colour maths library It would only do what we already do
uiGradients, WebGradients (data) MIT (both) JSON / CSS lists CSS Fixed two-colour pictures, not tied to any scheme
chroma-js BSD-3-Clause and Apache-2.0 (from search; not measured) not measured none same as culori
Ours: OKLab generation (gradients.ts) ours (AGPL-3.0-only) 6006 B source, 2451 B gzip as TypeScript source, on top of color.ts (2.3 kB source, 1.1 kB gzip) which the product already ships for paintMesh CSS (layered radial gradients over the scheme's background; the custom one is a CSS linear gradient in OKLab) Yes, by construction: 8 meshes and a wash per scheme from the scheme's own palette

The existing painter, for comparison

paintMesh (packages/ui/src/backdrop.ts, 4.2 kB gzip as source) is a WebGL one-shot: four warped Gaussian blobs, rendered to a still image, the context released afterwards (D83; TASTE "phones never run out of memory", GPU contexts only during an animation). It paints one recipe per scheme. Both libraries above are WebGL canvases that live in the page; a card strip with 3 to 5 cards plus 10 swatches would be 13 to 15 canvases (contexts) on a phone, against none for CSS.

Recommendation

  1. Generate the gradients ourselves, in OKLab, from each scheme's palette (what the mockup does). It is the only option that is "matching per colour scheme" by construction and gives a good default for a scheme added later with no new art; it adds no dependency, no licence, no WebGL context, and about 2451 B gzip on demand; it draws on a card and while a colour is dragged, which a one-shot WebGL painter cannot.
  2. Keep paintMesh for what it is good at, a still image with grain and a warp that CSS cannot do, and teach it the same recipes if the owner wants that look on the canvas itself (a production decision, not made here).
  3. If the owner later wants animated or physically blended meshes, the lightest licence-clean candidate is @mesh-gradient/core (MIT, 10.7 kB), with Paper's shaders (Apache-2.0, about 7 kB plus the unknown noise helper, 0.0.x) second. Neither helps "matching per scheme"; both would be fed the colours our generator produces. That would be a grill question with a measured memory cost per context, not a job's choice.
  4. Not recommended: culori and chroma-js (we already have OKLab, 1.1 kB against 31 kB), and the two data collections (fixed pictures that clash with a scheme).

What the mockup's gradients are, so the owner can judge them

Nine per scheme: Aurora, Dusk, Lagoon, Ember, Meadow, Orchid, Sunrise, Haze (layered blobs at fixed places from three of the scheme's palette colours) and Horizon (a straight wash from the background to the accent). Each colour is moved to a lightness just off the scheme's background with its hue kept (a glow on dark, a wash on light, chroma softened by 15%), so text over it keeps contrast: the unit test requires 4.5:1 for the scheme's primary text over the strongest colour any recipe puts behind it, for all ten schemes. The person's own gradient is up to four colour stops and an angle, interpolated in OKLab. Soft is gone; Plain is Solid; Mesh is Gradient.

## Gradient library question (owner, round 2): research and recommendation **Question:** "is there a pretty mesh/gradient library we can use where we can proactively offer many matching gradients per colour scheme with really good defaults and the ability for the user to choose their own gradient?" Nothing was chosen here (CLAUDE.md foundational rule); the mockup uses our own generated gradients either way. ### What I measured (packages downloaded from the npm registry on 2026-11-03; sizes are the shipped JavaScript, gzip -9) | Candidate | Licence (read from its LICENSE file) | Size | Renders with | Gives matching gradients per scheme? | |---|---|---|---|---| | `@paper-design/shaders` 0.0.82 | **Apache-2.0** (LICENSE file; a search summary said PolyForm Shield, the file and README say Apache 2.0, so I trust the file) | mesh-gradient shader 1.3 kB, shader mount 6.0 kB, so about 7.4 kB; a noise-texture helper is 17.9 kB and I did not check whether the mesh shader needs it; 0.0.x versions, "pin it" | WebGL canvas, one context per instance | No: you pass the colours | | `@mesh-gradient/core` 2.0.2 | **MIT** | 10.7 kB (index.mjs) | WebGL canvas | No: you pass the colours (the search summary said up to 4 colours; not verified) | | `culori` 4.0.2 | **MIT** | 30.7 kB for the whole bundle (not tree-shaken; not measured) | none: a colour maths library | It would only do what we already do | | uiGradients, WebGradients (data) | **MIT** (both) | JSON / CSS lists | CSS | Fixed two-colour pictures, not tied to any scheme | | chroma-js | BSD-3-Clause and Apache-2.0 (from search; not measured) | not measured | none | same as culori | | **Ours: OKLab generation** (`gradients.ts`) | ours (AGPL-3.0-only) | **6006 B source, 2451 B gzip as TypeScript source**, on top of `color.ts` (2.3 kB source, 1.1 kB gzip) which the product already ships for `paintMesh` | **CSS** (layered radial gradients over the scheme's background; the custom one is a CSS linear gradient in OKLab) | **Yes, by construction**: 8 meshes and a wash per scheme from the scheme's own palette | ### The existing painter, for comparison `paintMesh` (`packages/ui/src/backdrop.ts`, 4.2 kB gzip as source) is a WebGL one-shot: four warped Gaussian blobs, rendered to a still image, the context released afterwards (D83; TASTE "phones never run out of memory", GPU contexts only during an animation). It paints one recipe per scheme. Both libraries above are WebGL canvases that live in the page; a card strip with 3 to 5 cards plus 10 swatches would be 13 to 15 canvases (contexts) on a phone, against none for CSS. ### Recommendation 1. **Generate the gradients ourselves, in OKLab, from each scheme's palette** (what the mockup does). It is the only option that is "matching per colour scheme" by construction and gives a good default for a scheme added later with no new art; it adds no dependency, no licence, no WebGL context, and about 2451 B gzip on demand; it draws on a card and while a colour is dragged, which a one-shot WebGL painter cannot. 2. Keep `paintMesh` for what it is good at, a still image with grain and a warp that CSS cannot do, and teach it the same recipes if the owner wants that look on the canvas itself (a production decision, not made here). 3. If the owner later wants **animated** or physically blended meshes, the lightest licence-clean candidate is **`@mesh-gradient/core` (MIT, 10.7 kB)**, with Paper's shaders (Apache-2.0, about 7 kB plus the unknown noise helper, 0.0.x) second. Neither helps "matching per scheme"; both would be fed the colours our generator produces. That would be a grill question with a measured memory cost per context, not a job's choice. 4. Not recommended: culori and chroma-js (we already have OKLab, 1.1 kB against 31 kB), and the two data collections (fixed pictures that clash with a scheme). ### What the mockup's gradients are, so the owner can judge them Nine per scheme: Aurora, Dusk, Lagoon, Ember, Meadow, Orchid, Sunrise, Haze (layered blobs at fixed places from three of the scheme's palette colours) and Horizon (a straight wash from the background to the accent). Each colour is moved to a lightness just off the scheme's background with its hue kept (a glow on dark, a wash on light, chroma softened by 15%), so text over it keeps contrast: the unit test requires 4.5:1 for the scheme's primary text over the strongest colour any recipe puts behind it, for all ten schemes. The person's own gradient is up to four colour stops and an angle, interpolated in OKLab. Soft is gone; Plain is Solid; Mesh is Gradient.
kayg commented 2026-11-03 12:20:20 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 2 captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone

Preview (re-served): http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, updated; backups mockups.html.bak-j129-r2 next to both copies) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 3396518, mine: kill 3396518 when reviewed).
Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head f4421dde3. Captured by appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts on the tested build (78599aea1; the later commits only reorganise the work into four and change tests). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha and light is Catppuccin Latte (one entry, "Catppuccin", shown in the person's mode). There is no split any more: each card is its preset in its own scheme over its own background, with tint and blur applied.

Every image is an attachment of this comment. Strips are close-ups of the card strip; pages are whole screens.

Desktop, dark

Solid selected (solid background) — whole page

desktop-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient) — whole page

desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur) — whole page

desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field — whole page

desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-dark-tinted-page.png

Desktop, light

Solid selected (solid background) — whole page

desktop-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient) — whole page

desktop-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur) — whole page

desktop-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field — whole page

desktop-light-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-light-tinted-page.png

Phone, dark

Solid selected (solid background) — whole page

phone-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient) — whole page

phone-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur) — whole page

phone-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card — whole page

phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field — whole page

phone-dark-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-dark-tinted-page.png

Phone, light

Solid selected (solid background) — whole page

phone-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient) — whole page

phone-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur) — whole page

phone-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card — whole page

phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field — whole page

phone-light-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-light-tinted-page.png

The edge fade and the merged Colors list

Desktop: the strip scrolled to its end (only the left edge fades, there is nothing more on the right): desktop-06-fade.png

The Colors list with one entry per light/dark pair, and the Background choices below it: desktop-07-colors-pairs.png

Phone: the strip scrolled to its end (only the left edge fades, there is nothing more on the right): phone-06-fade.png

The Colors list with one entry per light/dark pair, and the Background choices below it: phone-07-colors-pairs.png

## Round 2 captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone **Preview** (re-served): http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, updated; backups `mockups.html.bak-j129-r2` next to both copies) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 3396518, mine: `kill 3396518` when reviewed). Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, head `f4421dde3`. Captured by `appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts` on the tested build (`78599aea1`; the later commits only reorganise the work into four and change tests). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha and light is Catppuccin Latte (one entry, "Catppuccin", shown in the person's mode). **There is no split any more:** each card is its preset in its own scheme over its own background, with tint and blur applied. Every image is an attachment of this comment. Strips are close-ups of the card strip; pages are whole screens. ### Desktop, dark **Solid selected (solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/07f4939d-c6ea-4f05-a1d3-9e880d4172aa) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d0aff8d3-eabf-4dd2-be9b-87e19e4246fb" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/173b1279-e350-4791-84ca-cbb0085fd6d0) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/39b30505-17e1-4ad8-b07d-79a7fe860dc0" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ea1a3036-8dbb-4089-8aa5-ee8f756f4d58) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0217aae5-0ab1-49da-9bbd-9f3e4acc2049" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/fc0319d9-34fc-4028-8a08-4e310a45ee0c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/1936ab50-74c7-42b6-aecf-a96bcaf47327" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/68cd83b3-cb3c-469c-bf05-f2417e1c0698) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/234336d2-7c39-4912-a417-9d50ec4cdb93" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9e2fa9b9-ca5d-4a82-9c2e-cfd3da99e241) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d192ad10-5f91-47f5-b446-893a7cd3ef0a" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/173b1279-e350-4791-84ca-cbb0085fd6d0" width="760" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Desktop, light **Solid selected (solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d0b5e106-a73a-41e6-9d01-cc41a68949b8) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9b5aba98-3f42-47e3-b3a4-8afbc972b77b" width="700" alt="desktop-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a258abf9-0127-4794-a893-c73bf376955c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/21c35ffe-f840-4264-9455-c5448d27c360" width="700" alt="desktop-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d79a914d-bfca-4a3c-ad70-0507ac0de87b) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/45cf6b49-e09b-4bcd-a736-b518482865e0" width="700" alt="desktop-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/767980d9-51d0-4cc2-8d34-13f21191d639) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a73166b1-9e9e-4848-8d94-47e922e3d9ea" width="700" alt="desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/6a313b95-b116-46a2-b08d-7f30f48d81bc) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/860472f2-354b-49e9-b5da-c03b4c916290" width="700" alt="desktop-light-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ae6920f7-66c8-46fd-b9bb-c50cfd4e1cea) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3eb6f56a-bd34-499a-9af5-d35dec513cfb" width="700" alt="desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a258abf9-0127-4794-a893-c73bf376955c" width="760" alt="desktop-light-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, dark **Solid selected (solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/428655c4-cb64-4edc-b0bb-6b3ae5161ffe) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/aa6b3712-8efe-47c2-91b3-a6d39d10bf38" width="330" alt="phone-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/da56502b-19db-4bb8-99b7-017c460465a6) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/84e019db-fc08-45fe-91d6-e8336e5cac65" width="330" alt="phone-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a125323b-6303-4f6c-b6c2-95b978536eee) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/6f716010-1686-4f63-b52a-d01a93724e61" width="330" alt="phone-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2eac5409-e832-4768-9ed1-c74745610990) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/83628160-34b5-48a2-a22b-c1e8333a30a2" width="330" alt="phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/58d46418-97cb-4efb-affc-2c2d937f850c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0915a48f-72db-4bcf-a7ec-1fbf58adc4bc" width="330" alt="phone-dark-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/86f1b22c-db27-4eb1-9378-3da73a2273eb) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/fdd1e8bd-4375-47b3-89d4-535db6874936" width="330" alt="phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/da56502b-19db-4bb8-99b7-017c460465a6" width="300" alt="phone-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, light **Solid selected (solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ae16af77-f5b7-4477-9944-a9a6babce1e8) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3f96ddaa-0fc3-4559-ae2b-f1fba2eac55f" width="330" alt="phone-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e4b8e072-0b9b-46cb-9f65-e13330ff541b) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d7657ac0-3cbf-4054-9eef-60dfe043a749" width="330" alt="phone-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (Aurora gradient, 100% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/229bf4fc-1f65-48c7-a762-b672ddcd5035) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/673abc43-c006-4515-846b-14fac591cda8" width="330" alt="phone-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed (55% tint, 30% blur): Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/c04bf398-9b4b-4434-a30b-c2244034334f) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/7625db16-33af-4726-b09f-060ce1c34074" width="330" alt="phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset, with its Name field** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/bba8946f-f86e-48dd-a3d4-30b16bfee68c) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/98827a5c-e8dd-454e-a371-bf134d7845c3" width="330" alt="phone-light-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3c9509f8-12b3-4299-af54-6dfb95a7396b) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ab047fdb-32b7-482d-b49b-c4a2d9cc7d89" width="330" alt="phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e4b8e072-0b9b-46cb-9f65-e13330ff541b" width="300" alt="phone-light-tinted-page.png"> ### The edge fade and the merged Colors list **Desktop**: the strip scrolled to its end (only the left edge fades, there is nothing more on the right): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/4da26db2-7df4-4d3f-828d-db86523dfbf8" width="700" alt="desktop-06-fade.png"> The Colors list with one entry per light/dark pair, and the Background choices below it: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d89aa6f7-758f-47a1-b84e-2b0f843c0cf9" width="700" alt="desktop-07-colors-pairs.png"> **Phone**: the strip scrolled to its end (only the left edge fades, there is nothing more on the right): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/cb387ebf-a33e-4fc4-89ae-ffae9fa89e76" width="300" alt="phone-06-fade.png"> The Colors list with one entry per light/dark pair, and the Background choices below it: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a3b7cb44-d93f-4364-a9f2-af1ac3eca8a0" width="300" alt="phone-07-colors-pairs.png">
desktop-dark-changed-reset-page.png
2.2 MiB
desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
122 KiB
desktop-dark-custom-gradient-page.png
3.6 MiB
desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png
157 KiB
desktop-dark-frosted-page.png
2.3 MiB
desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png
138 KiB
desktop-dark-just-added-page.png
2.2 MiB
desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png
113 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-page.png
325 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-strip.png
124 KiB
desktop-dark-tinted-page.png
3.5 MiB
desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png
172 KiB
desktop-light-frosted-page.png
2.1 MiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-page.png
2 MiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png
114 KiB
desktop-light-custom-gradient-page.png
3.6 MiB
desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png
157 KiB
desktop-light-frosted-strip.png
128 KiB
desktop-light-just-added-page.png
1.9 MiB
desktop-light-just-added-strip.png
108 KiB
desktop-light-solid-page.png
309 KiB
desktop-light-solid-strip.png
120 KiB
desktop-light-tinted-page.png
2.9 MiB
desktop-light-tinted-strip.png
145 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-page.png
990 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
194 KiB
phone-dark-custom-gradient-page.png
1.8 MiB
phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png
246 KiB
phone-dark-frosted-page.png
1.1 MiB
phone-dark-frosted-strip.png
216 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-page.png
941 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-strip.png
166 KiB
phone-dark-solid-page.png
256 KiB
phone-dark-solid-strip.png
94 KiB
phone-dark-tinted-page.png
1.8 MiB
phone-dark-tinted-strip.png
250 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-page.png
886 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png
179 KiB
phone-light-custom-gradient-page.png
1.8 MiB
phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png
245 KiB
phone-light-frosted-page.png
982 KiB
phone-light-frosted-strip.png
209 KiB
phone-light-just-added-page.png
832 KiB
phone-light-just-added-strip.png
148 KiB
phone-light-solid-page.png
237 KiB
phone-light-solid-strip.png
89 KiB
phone-light-tinted-page.png
1.5 MiB
phone-light-tinted-strip.png
229 KiB
desktop-06-fade.png
3.5 MiB
desktop-07-colors-pairs.png
3.6 MiB
phone-06-fade.png
1.8 MiB
phone-07-colors-pairs.png
1.8 MiB
kayg commented 2026-11-03 13:28:43 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 2 finish: backgrounds in presets, one face per card, edge fade, Colors pairs, sideways swipe in the shared gesture code

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head f4421dde3, on top of settings-sections-mock-j92 (c88619630, unmoved). 4 new atomic commits on top of round 1's 7 (3322662c3). Only Appearance content changed, plus one function in gestures.ts (below). TypeScript and CSS only: no Rust or Cargo file.

Review: http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323 replaced with the round 2 text; backed up as mockups.html.bak-j129-r2 beside both copies; note the orchestrator had already removed #304 and #94 from the index at 11:00 UTC, so my entry now sits above #156 only) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 3396518, mine: kill 3396518 when reviewed). Captures: issuecomment-76893 (52 images: desktop and phone, dark and light, Solid, Tinted, Frosted, changed with Reset, just after +, own gradient, plus the fade and the Colors list). Library research and recommendation: issuecomment-76798.

What was asked, and what I did

  1. Background is part of the preset; the Background window is gone. Solid (was Plain), Gradient (was Mesh), no Soft. Nine gradients per scheme (Aurora, Dusk, Lagoon, Ember, Meadow, Orchid, Sunrise, Haze, Horizon) made from the scheme's own palette in OKLab, so each is "matching" by construction; plus Custom: two to four colour stops (native colour fields) and an angle, in OKLab. A unit test requires 4.5:1 for each scheme's primary text over the strongest colour of any recipe, in all ten schemes. Solid starts on a solid background; Tinted and Frosted start on Aurora because tint and blur only show over something (Reset restores that).
  2. Library question: recommendation is our own OKLab generation (what the mockup does): zero dependency, no WebGL context per card, 2.5 kB gzip as TypeScript source on demand (6,006 B raw, comments included; the minified chunk is smaller, not measured separately). The only MIT/Apache candidates are @mesh-gradient/core (MIT, 10.7 kB gzip, WebGL) and Paper's shaders (Apache-2.0 by their LICENSE file, about 7 kB plus an unchecked 17.9 kB noise helper, 0.0.x, WebGL); neither gives matching gradients per scheme. Table with licences read from the files and sizes measured from the packages: the research comment. Nothing was added as a dependency.
  3. Cards: the split is gone. A card is the preset in its own scheme (dark shows the dark version, light the light version), over its chosen background, with its tint and blur.
  4. Strip: left and right edges fade, only while there is more to scroll that way (data-fade, set from one passive scroll listener; tested: right at the start, both in the middle, left at the end).
  5. Floating cards follow the preset's tint and keep at least the shared 16 px overlay blur (owner, D329: "agreed").
  6. Sideways swipe (D329, amends D275): moved into the shared gesture code (gestures.ts, one routing function, both axes): content that scrolls sideways takes the swipe first, the canvas gets it at its end. The strip's own copy is deleted. It fit the deferred budget: +47 B (below).
  7. Colors list (D329): a scheme with a light and a dark version is one entry with a small round light/dark icon right of its name: Ink and Paper, Catppuccin (Latte and Mocha), Rosé Pine (Dawn and Rosé Pine). Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox and Dracula have one version and stay as they were (hint "dark"). No new schemes or fonts. A preset stores the entry; the mode the person is in picks the version.

Gate: scripts/verify fast, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at f4421dde3, verbatim

+---------------------------+--------------+
| Rust gate                 | Result       |
+---------------------------+--------------+
| fmt                       | PASS         |
| VT native fmt             | PASS         |
| CLI plugin compile-out    | PASS         |
| clippy                    | PASS         |
| SSH runtime test helper   | PASS         |
| real-binary fixture paths | PASS         |
| test                      | PASS         |
| SSH inode reuse fixture   | PASS         |
| shim process-per-user     | PASS         |
| cargo-deny                | PASS         |
| gate architecture         | PASS         |
| static builds             | PASS         |
+---------------------------+--------------+
JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315001/327680 brotli=262733/273408 bytes
JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174635 gzip=61118/61440 brotli=53962/55296 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=392121 gzip=154414/20480 brotli=137473/18432 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-6pk3ayf7.js: gzip=16221/20480 brotli=14373/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154414 brotli=137473, not limited)
VERIFY_EXIT=0

Budget (D188) against the base c88619630 (#304's own gate): critical gzip 315,010 → 315,001 (-9); deferred 61,071 → 61,118 (+47 B, all of it the shared sideways-swipe rule in gestures.ts; 322 B left under the 61,440 cap); largest on-demand chunk 16,223 → 16,221. Everything else new is *.on-demand.ts or mockup-only (left out of the production build).

Tests

  • Unit: 19 pass in src/canvas/mock (model with background, colours and gradient contrast, Colors entries and mode, plus the 9 existing catalog tests).
  • Browser, production build, compute01: my three specs: 59 passed, 4 failed in run 6, and the 4 were mistakes in my tests (Solid's two empty layers read as "none, none"; a "no Mesh" check that matched the fixture terminal text "Mesh grants…"); fixed, rerun: 4 passed. Captures come from the passing run.
  • Regressions for the shared wheel rule (clusters-swipes, clusters-swipes-both, wheel-scroll, settings-sections): 27 passed, 5 failed. The same 5 fail identically on the unmodified base c88619630 (rerun in a separate worktree): four tests of wheel-scroll.spec.ts (a docs heading "Keys and how long they last" is not found) and the desktop breadcrumb-centring test (0.6 px against the 0.5 px limit). So they are not caused by this work, but it also means wheel-scroll.spec.ts cannot confirm that a sideways swipe over non-scrolling content still moves between windows; the six horizontal-swipe tests of clusters-swipes*.spec.ts (real wheel input) pass, and my strip test covers the new behaviour.
  • Checked within 0.5 px where a length: the first card on the heading's edge, cards share a top, name and dots share a centre line, the pair icon sits right of its name on its centre line.

Legibility of the three built-ins again (as the owner asked), dark and light, floating cards with the 16 px floor

Same method as before (appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts), Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper. Window contrast is now over the colours the preset gradients can put behind a window (conservative: the strongest colour at full strength, a dot on it).

Ghost text, palette (limit 0.02) Ghost text, sidebar Window text, primary / secondary (needs 4.5)
Solid 0.0000 all 0.0008 / 0.0010 / 0.0003 / 0.0005 11.34 / 7.37, 7.52 / 5.20, 16.37 / 5.85, 15.55 / 5.36: pass
Tinted 0.0009 / 0.0008 / 0.0008 / 0.0008 (was 0.147 to 0.150) 0.0017 / 0.0022 / 0.0013 / 0.0016 (was 0.253 to 0.257) primary 8.05, 5.84, 12.52, 12.25 pass; secondary 5.23 pass, 4.04 Latte, 4.48 Ink, 4.22 Paper miss
Frosted 0.0010 / 0.0011 / 0.0010 / 0.0011 0.0015 / 0.0019 / 0.0011 / 0.0014 primary 5.42, 4.45 Latte, 8.54, 9.45 (one miss); secondary 3.52, 3.08, 3.05, 3.25 miss
Floating cards, theme text against every pixel of the card over dense text (1st percentile): primary passes everywhere (lowest 6.37). Secondary: Solid and Tinted pass everywhere (lowest 4.70); Frosted misses in three places: palette Latte 4.41, palette Paper 4.39, sidebar Ink 4.28 (the other five pass). The 16 px floor fixed the one big failure (Tinted leaked 15% and 25% of the text behind; it is now 0.1% to 0.2%). I changed no number. What is left is secondary (quieter) text on Frosted and, over the gradient colours, on Tinted windows; the owner can decide whether the built-ins' tint (50% and 75%) or the secondary text colour should move.

Owner questions (with my recommendation)

  1. Is Ink and Paper a pair? I treated Paper and Ink (the two monochrome schemes) as the light and dark version of one scheme, like the other two pairs. If not, they are two entries again (one line in colors.ts).
  2. The mode that picks the version starts as the theme the page shows and follows the system's light/dark setting. There is no light/dark switch in Settings in this mockup. Recommendation: keep it that way; the palette's theme: actions still pick a version directly.
  3. Frosted's secondary text (above). Recommendation: leave the numbers, and raise the contrast of secondary text on floating cards, which is one token for every preset (not a per-preset change).
  4. Custom gradient is stops plus an angle only (no mesh points), as the owner said to keep it simple.
  5. Carried over: no delete for a preset you made; the card's own "Aa" sample over Tinted still shows terminal text behind it, because that is what the material does at 75% (now at 0.1% leak through the palette, but the card has no blur floor: it is a picture of the preset, not a floating card).

Cleanup

compute01: gate worktree and target, the base-check worktree and both preview copies deleted; no stray processes; 103 GB free. ~/worktrees/j129 (node_modules and a preview build, small) left. dev-02: ~/worktrees/j129, ~/j129-preview-dist and the server (PID 3396518) stay up for the review.

## Round 2 finish: backgrounds in presets, one face per card, edge fade, Colors pairs, sideways swipe in the shared gesture code **Branch** `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, **head `f4421dde3`**, on top of `settings-sections-mock-j92` (`c88619630`, unmoved). 4 new atomic commits on top of round 1's 7 (`3322662c3`). Only Appearance content changed, plus one function in `gestures.ts` (below). TypeScript and CSS only: no Rust or Cargo file. **Review:** http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323 replaced with the round 2 text; backed up as `mockups.html.bak-j129-r2` beside both copies; note the orchestrator had already removed #304 and #94 from the index at 11:00 UTC, so my entry now sits above #156 only) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, bun PID 3396518, mine: `kill 3396518` when reviewed). **Captures:** `issuecomment-76893` (52 images: desktop and phone, dark and light, Solid, Tinted, Frosted, changed with Reset, just after +, own gradient, plus the fade and the Colors list). **Library research and recommendation:** `issuecomment-76798`. ### What was asked, and what I did 1. **Background is part of the preset; the Background window is gone.** Solid (was Plain), Gradient (was Mesh), no Soft. Nine gradients per scheme (Aurora, Dusk, Lagoon, Ember, Meadow, Orchid, Sunrise, Haze, Horizon) made from the scheme's own palette in OKLab, so each is "matching" by construction; plus **Custom**: two to four colour stops (native colour fields) and an angle, in OKLab. A unit test requires 4.5:1 for each scheme's primary text over the strongest colour of any recipe, in all ten schemes. Solid starts on a solid background; Tinted and Frosted start on Aurora because tint and blur only show over something (Reset restores that). 2. **Library question:** recommendation is our own OKLab generation (what the mockup does): zero dependency, no WebGL context per card, 2.5 kB gzip as TypeScript source on demand (6,006 B raw, comments included; the minified chunk is smaller, not measured separately). The only MIT/Apache candidates are `@mesh-gradient/core` (MIT, 10.7 kB gzip, WebGL) and Paper's shaders (Apache-2.0 by their LICENSE file, about 7 kB plus an unchecked 17.9 kB noise helper, 0.0.x, WebGL); neither gives matching gradients per scheme. Table with licences read from the files and sizes measured from the packages: the research comment. Nothing was added as a dependency. 3. **Cards:** the split is gone. A card is the preset in its own scheme (dark shows the dark version, light the light version), over its chosen background, with its tint and blur. 4. **Strip:** left and right edges fade, only while there is more to scroll that way (`data-fade`, set from one passive scroll listener; tested: right at the start, both in the middle, left at the end). 5. **Floating cards** follow the preset's tint and keep at least the shared 16 px overlay blur (owner, D329: "agreed"). 6. **Sideways swipe (D329, amends D275):** moved into the shared gesture code (`gestures.ts`, one routing function, both axes): content that scrolls sideways takes the swipe first, the canvas gets it at its end. The strip's own copy is deleted. **It fit the deferred budget:** +47 B (below). 7. **Colors list (D329):** a scheme with a light and a dark version is one entry with a small round light/dark icon right of its name: **Ink and Paper, Catppuccin (Latte and Mocha), Rosé Pine (Dawn and Rosé Pine)**. Nord, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox and Dracula have one version and stay as they were (hint "dark"). No new schemes or fonts. A preset stores the entry; the mode the person is in picks the version. ### Gate: `scripts/verify fast`, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at `f4421dde3`, verbatim ``` +---------------------------+--------------+ | Rust gate | Result | +---------------------------+--------------+ | fmt | PASS | | VT native fmt | PASS | | CLI plugin compile-out | PASS | | clippy | PASS | | SSH runtime test helper | PASS | | real-binary fixture paths | PASS | | test | PASS | | SSH inode reuse fixture | PASS | | shim process-per-user | PASS | | cargo-deny | PASS | | gate architecture | PASS | | static builds | PASS | +---------------------------+--------------+ JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315001/327680 brotli=262733/273408 bytes JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174635 gzip=61118/61440 brotli=53962/55296 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=392121 gzip=154414/20480 brotli=137473/18432 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-6pk3ayf7.js: gzip=16221/20480 brotli=14373/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154414 brotli=137473, not limited) VERIFY_EXIT=0 ``` **Budget (D188) against the base `c88619630` (#304's own gate):** critical gzip 315,010 → **315,001** (-9); deferred 61,071 → **61,118** (+47 B, all of it the shared sideways-swipe rule in `gestures.ts`; 322 B left under the 61,440 cap); largest on-demand chunk 16,223 → 16,221. Everything else new is `*.on-demand.ts` or mockup-only (left out of the production build). ### Tests - Unit: 19 pass in `src/canvas/mock` (model with background, colours and gradient contrast, Colors entries and mode, plus the 9 existing catalog tests). - Browser, production build, compute01: my three specs: **59 passed, 4 failed** in run 6, and the 4 were mistakes in my tests (Solid's two empty layers read as "none, none"; a "no Mesh" check that matched the fixture terminal text "Mesh grants…"); fixed, rerun: **4 passed**. Captures come from the passing run. - **Regressions for the shared wheel rule** (`clusters-swipes`, `clusters-swipes-both`, `wheel-scroll`, `settings-sections`): 27 passed, 5 failed. **The same 5 fail identically on the unmodified base `c88619630`** (rerun in a separate worktree): four tests of `wheel-scroll.spec.ts` (a docs heading "Keys and how long they last" is not found) and the desktop breadcrumb-centring test (0.6 px against the 0.5 px limit). So they are not caused by this work, but it also means `wheel-scroll.spec.ts` cannot confirm that a sideways swipe over non-scrolling content still moves between windows; the six horizontal-swipe tests of `clusters-swipes*.spec.ts` (real wheel input) pass, and my strip test covers the new behaviour. - Checked within 0.5 px where a length: the first card on the heading's edge, cards share a top, name and dots share a centre line, the pair icon sits right of its name on its centre line. ### Legibility of the three built-ins again (as the owner asked), dark and light, floating cards with the 16 px floor Same method as before (`appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts`), Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper. Window contrast is now over the colours the preset gradients can put behind a window (conservative: the strongest colour at full strength, a dot on it). | | Ghost text, palette (limit 0.02) | Ghost text, sidebar | Window text, primary / secondary (needs 4.5) | |---|---|---|---| | Solid | 0.0000 all | 0.0008 / 0.0010 / 0.0003 / 0.0005 | 11.34 / 7.37, 7.52 / 5.20, 16.37 / 5.85, 15.55 / 5.36: pass | | Tinted | **0.0009 / 0.0008 / 0.0008 / 0.0008** (was 0.147 to 0.150) | **0.0017 / 0.0022 / 0.0013 / 0.0016** (was 0.253 to 0.257) | primary 8.05, 5.84, 12.52, 12.25 pass; secondary 5.23 pass, **4.04 Latte, 4.48 Ink, 4.22 Paper** miss | | Frosted | 0.0010 / 0.0011 / 0.0010 / 0.0011 | 0.0015 / 0.0019 / 0.0011 / 0.0014 | primary 5.42, **4.45 Latte**, 8.54, 9.45 (one miss); secondary **3.52, 3.08, 3.05, 3.25** miss | Floating cards, theme text against every pixel of the card over dense text (1st percentile): **primary passes everywhere** (lowest 6.37). Secondary: Solid and Tinted pass everywhere (lowest 4.70); **Frosted misses in three places: palette Latte 4.41, palette Paper 4.39, sidebar Ink 4.28** (the other five pass). **The 16 px floor fixed the one big failure** (Tinted leaked 15% and 25% of the text behind; it is now 0.1% to 0.2%). I changed no number. What is left is secondary (quieter) text on Frosted and, over the gradient colours, on Tinted windows; the owner can decide whether the built-ins' tint (50% and 75%) or the secondary text colour should move. ### Owner questions (with my recommendation) 1. **Is Ink and Paper a pair?** I treated Paper and Ink (the two monochrome schemes) as the light and dark version of one scheme, like the other two pairs. If not, they are two entries again (one line in `colors.ts`). 2. **The mode that picks the version** starts as the theme the page shows and follows the system's light/dark setting. There is no light/dark switch in Settings in this mockup. Recommendation: keep it that way; the palette's `theme:` actions still pick a version directly. 3. **Frosted's secondary text** (above). Recommendation: leave the numbers, and raise the contrast of secondary text on floating cards, which is one token for every preset (not a per-preset change). 4. **Custom gradient is stops plus an angle** only (no mesh points), as the owner said to keep it simple. 5. Carried over: no delete for a preset you made; the card's own "Aa" sample over Tinted still shows terminal text behind it, because that is what the material does at 75% (now at 0.1% leak through the palette, but the card has no blur floor: it is a picture of the preset, not a floating card). ### Cleanup compute01: gate worktree and target, the base-check worktree and both preview copies deleted; no stray processes; 103 GB free. `~/worktrees/j129` (node_modules and a preview build, small) left. dev-02: `~/worktrees/j129`, `~/j129-preview-dist` and the server (PID 3396518) stay up for the review.
kayg commented 2026-11-04 04:28:22 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 3 start

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, base head f4421dde3 (still on top of settings-sections-mock-j92 = c88619630, unmoved). Read: BRIEF-COMMON (new rules: questions only here, verify quick before verify fast, push as I go), D338. Items 1 to 6 are mine; item 7 (Appearance scrolling sideways, the active window scrolling out of view) is J132's, not touched.

Plan, one atomic commit each, each pushed

  1. New built-ins: Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50 (model, tests); legibility rerun in both modes; failures reported, numbers unchanged.
  2. Colour replaces "Colors" everywhere (UK spelling); the Colour list: rows aligned in two columns (name, then the light and dark circles), clicking a circle picks that scheme and that mode, a one-version scheme has one circle. Because the circle now chooses the mode, a preset stores the concrete version again (no "follow the system"), which also makes the card exactly "the items chosen". This is how a person gets to light.
  3. Backgrounds: Solid gets options (a "Default" plus seven solids from each scheme's palette in OKLab) and a custom colour; no text on swatches (names in the shared warm tooltip); custom is marked with a dashed ring and a small pen.
  4. Order UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts. Grain: 0 to 100%, the product's own noise tile (grainTile()), blended as the product's mesh grain is, one static layer over the background: no animation, so reduced motion has nothing to stop, and nothing per frame beyond the compositor.
  5. Tint, Blur and Grain in 3 columns when the window's own width allows (a container query on the window's content, never the viewport).
  6. The preview card's first terminal line: the glass pane started inside it; the pane now starts below it.

Reading of D338, and one question (continuing with the default)

  • D338's list reads "Colour, Backgrounds, Fonts" (singular, plural, plural) next to "Tint, Blur, Grain, UI Size". I use the owner's words as headings (UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts). Question for the owner: all singular (Colour, Background, Font) or all plural? Recommendation: all singular, like Tint, Blur and Grain; it is a one-word change.
  • Ink and Paper stays one entry (round 2 question 1, unanswered).
## Round 3 start Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, base head `f4421dde3` (still on top of `settings-sections-mock-j92` = `c88619630`, unmoved). Read: BRIEF-COMMON (new rules: questions only here, `verify quick` before `verify fast`, push as I go), D338. Items 1 to 6 are mine; item 7 (Appearance scrolling sideways, the active window scrolling out of view) is J132's, not touched. **Plan, one atomic commit each, each pushed** 1. New built-ins: Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50 (model, tests); legibility rerun in both modes; failures reported, numbers unchanged. 2. **Colour** replaces "Colors" everywhere (UK spelling); the Colour list: rows aligned in two columns (name, then the light and dark circles), clicking a circle picks that scheme *and* that mode, a one-version scheme has one circle. Because the circle now chooses the mode, a preset stores the concrete version again (no "follow the system"), which also makes the card exactly "the items chosen". This is how a person gets to light. 3. Backgrounds: Solid gets options (a "Default" plus seven solids from each scheme's palette in OKLab) and a custom colour; no text on swatches (names in the shared warm tooltip); custom is marked with a dashed ring and a small pen. 4. Order UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts. **Grain**: 0 to 100%, the product's own noise tile (`grainTile()`), blended as the product's mesh grain is, one static layer over the background: no animation, so reduced motion has nothing to stop, and nothing per frame beyond the compositor. 5. Tint, Blur and Grain in 3 columns when the *window's own* width allows (a container query on the window's content, never the viewport). 6. The preview card's first terminal line: the glass pane started inside it; the pane now starts below it. **Reading of D338, and one question (continuing with the default)** - D338's list reads "Colour, Backgrounds, Fonts" (singular, plural, plural) next to "Tint, Blur, Grain, UI Size". I use the owner's words as headings (UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts). **Question for the owner:** all singular (Colour, Background, Font) or all plural? Recommendation: all singular, like Tint, Blur and Grain; it is a one-word change. - Ink and Paper stays one entry (round 2 question 1, unanswered).
kayg commented 2026-11-04 07:16:39 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 3 captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone

Preview (re-served): http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, round 3; backups mockups.html.bak-j129-r3) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, mine).
Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129; captured by appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts on the tree of the final head (the squash of fixups changed no file). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha, light is Catppuccin Latte. The page is the whole screen in each case; strips are close-ups of the card strip. Every image is an attachment of this comment.

New in this round: built-ins Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50; controls in the order UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts; the Colour list with two circles; Solid options; label-free swatches with a dashed-ring-and-pen Custom; Grain; the three columns in a wide window; the first terminal line whole.

Desktop, dark

Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background) — whole page

desktop-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient) — whole page

desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur) — whole page

desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed: Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset — whole page

desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png

With film grain (45%) — whole page

desktop-dark-grain-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-dark-tinted-page.png

Desktop, light

Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background) — whole page

desktop-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient) — whole page

desktop-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur) — whole page

desktop-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed: Reset on its card — whole page

desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset — whole page

desktop-light-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png

With film grain (45%) — whole page

desktop-light-grain-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

desktop-light-tinted-page.png

Phone, dark

Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background) — whole page

phone-dark-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient) — whole page

phone-dark-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur) — whole page

phone-dark-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed: Reset on its card — whole page

phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset — whole page

phone-dark-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png

With film grain (45%) — whole page

phone-dark-grain-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-dark-tinted-page.png

Phone, light

Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background) — whole page

phone-light-solid-strip.png

Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient) — whole page

phone-light-tinted-strip.png

Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur) — whole page

phone-light-frosted-strip.png

Tinted changed: Reset on its card — whole page

phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png

Just after +: a copy of the selected preset — whole page

phone-light-just-added-strip.png

Your own gradient (three colours, 120°) — whole page

phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png

With film grain (45%) — whole page

phone-light-grain-strip.png

Whole page, Tinted (default):

phone-light-tinted-page.png

The Colour list in light, solid backgrounds, grain and the fade

Desktop

A circle chosen: the light circle of Catppuccin switches to light: desktop-07-colour-light.png

Solid backgrounds (your own solid colour chosen): desktop-05-background-solid.png

Grain at 50%: desktop-08-grain.png

The strip at its end (only the left edge fades): desktop-06-fade.png

Phone

A circle chosen: the light circle of Catppuccin switches to light: phone-07-colour-light.png

Solid backgrounds (your own solid colour chosen): phone-05-background-solid.png

Grain at 50%: phone-08-grain.png

The strip at its end (only the left edge fades): phone-06-fade.png

A wide window (2560 px screen, the window a third of it)

Tint, Blur and Grain in three columns, each slider under its label: desktop-09-wide-three-columns.png

## Round 3 captures: production build of the mockup, dark and light, desktop and phone **Preview** (re-served): http://10.69.69.117:47650/mockups.html (entry #323, round 3; backups `mockups.html.bak-j129-r3`) → http://10.69.69.117:47680/?mock=1&proto=clusters&scene=3&settings=sections&presets=1&at=appearance.presets (dev-02, mine). Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`; captured by `appearance-presets-shots.spec.ts` on the tree of the final head (the squash of fixups changed no file). Desktop 1440x900 at DPR 2, phone 393x852 at DPR 3. Dark is Catppuccin Mocha, light is Catppuccin Latte. The page is the **whole screen** in each case; strips are close-ups of the card strip. Every image is an attachment of this comment. New in this round: built-ins Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50; controls in the order UI size, Colour, Backgrounds, Tint, Blur, Grain, Fonts; the Colour list with two circles; Solid options; label-free swatches with a dashed-ring-and-pen Custom; Grain; the three columns in a wide window; the first terminal line whole. ### Desktop, dark **Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0ac822ae-7cf6-45a2-a6cb-7e304824c127) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ecf4d61d-7ed9-44d7-b437-69bcc3bdb144" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8456d8c2-50f2-480b-aca2-a2e291c00455) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/1e18f0c4-1040-412e-8517-a5f54253b79d" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e1758a3d-cd8d-4a18-b6d2-5cd28b840fcb) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/f5897faf-94ec-460f-8c71-e16c8be34d64" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed: Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/685836e5-3760-4d3e-b795-712ea9d4e1c9) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/7e3fd455-fcab-40f8-9630-0c66fa54d5d7" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/156be489-e325-41c4-936d-3e8001e07904) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8d4993f9-026f-47aa-b758-2d187b03367b" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/620edc72-5484-4062-a6c4-470880b1f6c0) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/4e692532-899b-46a1-9a6c-108a0ce0f305" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png"> **With film grain (45%)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2b9a0753-8816-4a18-933b-446effc3f3da) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a89ebbcd-a02c-47a2-b0a5-b56dab2678f7" width="700" alt="desktop-dark-grain-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8456d8c2-50f2-480b-aca2-a2e291c00455" width="760" alt="desktop-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Desktop, light **Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/b5e659e7-4613-4e8f-b8d6-077afcffeb50) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/71b0dcd3-3d93-4f76-a452-4f8ba7788420" width="700" alt="desktop-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/02494ced-7383-452b-b3c5-8e307bbc1d29) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/013155c3-8f24-4f69-838c-f049d6e7caa1" width="700" alt="desktop-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d94b9e79-6563-420c-9a3e-3b6ae9a0d0ab) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/461e39a9-aba1-4ba7-8197-d585fda38a7d" width="700" alt="desktop-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed: Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0e00f435-caea-4904-93fb-50e105e72a3d) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/b49c9697-d55c-4b54-9fb6-4742f1030833" width="700" alt="desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/42c0868a-af37-4c3a-89f6-5a8edd09e09e) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/9a5b8fbb-cc9b-42d6-b2eb-bbd0c09b7ede" width="700" alt="desktop-light-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ff55e94d-b606-4450-a556-ede8ae99d052) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/10cf1d91-029f-4dee-a3f4-63f84c3d2fe9" width="700" alt="desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png"> **With film grain (45%)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/ca94ac8a-a0e1-44d5-b610-d3ef0eda4ae4) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/bb17efe2-cca0-41d9-8d77-ee85c1ded769" width="700" alt="desktop-light-grain-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/02494ced-7383-452b-b3c5-8e307bbc1d29" width="760" alt="desktop-light-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, dark **Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/54276d88-a821-4269-a964-69f251c02eee) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/be12401c-ccdb-4f40-bb2d-494cf27971db" width="330" alt="phone-dark-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8ecd7f5d-9f18-4928-9518-b3411713ead6) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8494a4c4-0733-4597-a9aa-4a8205e709e3" width="330" alt="phone-dark-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/c0da688f-7308-4624-8948-3aca416b14d9) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/17bb7cac-95af-45f8-a824-e3b9a904c81f" width="330" alt="phone-dark-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed: Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/6dd966be-a06e-402c-bd36-19a00c761c2b) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/98c32dd9-a6fc-40d7-8c4e-83c9d414ef3e" width="330" alt="phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/1dccf407-b797-4f7d-ac8b-99dccc7f5c95) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/159c5e52-646b-4d30-8fbc-9ee5fab51d42" width="330" alt="phone-dark-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/4c26d3b8-2685-4cff-8fec-13d11cd33978) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/59f923a8-c0af-4896-ab36-0f266ac64fc7" width="330" alt="phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png"> **With film grain (45%)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/d410d352-93b6-465f-9454-cc92827c066d) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/88a16b04-d68f-4c54-b549-75fc2d6351c4" width="330" alt="phone-dark-grain-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8ecd7f5d-9f18-4928-9518-b3411713ead6" width="300" alt="phone-dark-tinted-page.png"> ### Phone, light **Solid selected (100% tint, 0% blur, solid background)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/102a5713-d1e6-4dfb-b1ae-82a019b71f40) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/deeac1bc-aeb1-4744-a0fe-db4bf3c76b3e" width="330" alt="phone-light-solid-strip.png"> **Tinted selected (the default: 75% tint, 25% blur, Aurora gradient)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e7af180e-7201-411b-b53b-f87baa5a62ea) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/7b4f33c9-3c4e-4074-933a-5eaedc6c6b80" width="330" alt="phone-light-tinted-strip.png"> **Frosted selected (50% tint, 50% blur)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/f6a336a6-3801-46c8-a31e-0d2789b68a57) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/4c60d79f-0d8a-4783-870e-a9ff698d046a" width="330" alt="phone-light-frosted-strip.png"> **Tinted changed: Reset on its card** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/17b0b4f9-6b0e-4a8e-a82a-9d486fc1a1e6) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2be6acd5-415f-49b4-abb2-a3cdf46883e1" width="330" alt="phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png"> **Just after +: a copy of the selected preset** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e36e2e9d-b571-4d2a-aef6-be33dca005a0) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/5c85a242-1a13-4b23-b004-24d6df67f27f" width="330" alt="phone-light-just-added-strip.png"> **Your own gradient (three colours, 120°)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/da3dca67-9b71-4b99-922b-4f7bb3129a1a) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/8c534be3-acb1-425d-bf9a-4fc306b90762" width="330" alt="phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png"> **With film grain (45%)** — [whole page](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/fc8f70c7-f6ac-4672-83c4-1cdfe48ccb5e) <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/3439d878-eb0d-4943-94d4-dde89b6905b7" width="330" alt="phone-light-grain-strip.png"> Whole page, Tinted (default): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e7af180e-7201-411b-b53b-f87baa5a62ea" width="300" alt="phone-light-tinted-page.png"> ### The Colour list in light, solid backgrounds, grain and the fade **Desktop** A circle chosen: the light circle of Catppuccin switches to light: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/598fdb69-3927-4082-84ab-3a8acc338106" width="700" alt="desktop-07-colour-light.png"> Solid backgrounds (your own solid colour chosen): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/179a6743-0264-48a4-8650-a64cc0dcc992" width="700" alt="desktop-05-background-solid.png"> Grain at 50%: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/2b5b7972-29af-4382-b90b-78198e78ebd9" width="700" alt="desktop-08-grain.png"> The strip at its end (only the left edge fades): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/0df1e595-ad91-46aa-8de6-c962de35a9e3" width="700" alt="desktop-06-fade.png"> **Phone** A circle chosen: the light circle of Catppuccin switches to light: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/972bdc56-858f-4a47-ae3d-9bbe7144109a" width="300" alt="phone-07-colour-light.png"> Solid backgrounds (your own solid colour chosen): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/b20eda3d-3a3e-4fac-9066-f9be7c008fc7" width="300" alt="phone-05-background-solid.png"> Grain at 50%: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/a090c130-c417-45fd-be29-80774a6630d4" width="300" alt="phone-08-grain.png"> The strip at its end (only the left edge fades): <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/e2d75f49-8249-4fe7-9d8d-c81cea489912" width="300" alt="phone-06-fade.png"> ### A wide window (2560 px screen, the window a third of it) Tint, Blur and Grain in three columns, each slider under its label: <img src="https://git.kayg.org/attachments/60f1b2e9-79e8-425f-b8a6-f46bca7a4a59" width="900" alt="desktop-09-wide-three-columns.png">
desktop-dark-changed-reset-page.png
2.3 MiB
desktop-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
120 KiB
desktop-dark-custom-gradient-page.png
2.4 MiB
desktop-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png
100 KiB
desktop-dark-frosted-page.png
2.3 MiB
desktop-dark-frosted-strip.png
117 KiB
desktop-dark-grain-page.png
3 MiB
desktop-dark-grain-strip.png
136 KiB
desktop-dark-just-added-page.png
2.2 MiB
desktop-dark-just-added-strip.png
113 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-page.png
318 KiB
desktop-dark-solid-strip.png
102 KiB
desktop-dark-tinted-page.png
2.2 MiB
desktop-dark-tinted-strip.png
108 KiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-page.png
2 MiB
desktop-light-changed-reset-strip.png
112 KiB
desktop-light-custom-gradient-page.png
2.4 MiB
desktop-light-custom-gradient-strip.png
102 KiB
desktop-light-frosted-page.png
2.1 MiB
desktop-light-frosted-strip.png
111 KiB
desktop-light-grain-page.png
2.6 MiB
desktop-light-grain-strip.png
123 KiB
desktop-light-just-added-page.png
2 MiB
desktop-light-just-added-strip.png
107 KiB
desktop-light-solid-page.png
303 KiB
desktop-light-solid-strip.png
99 KiB
desktop-light-tinted-page.png
2 MiB
desktop-light-tinted-strip.png
102 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-page.png
1,004 KiB
phone-dark-changed-reset-strip.png
186 KiB
phone-dark-custom-gradient-page.png
1,003 KiB
phone-dark-custom-gradient-strip.png
163 KiB
phone-dark-frosted-page.png
1 MiB
phone-dark-frosted-strip.png
178 KiB
phone-dark-grain-page.png
1.1 MiB
phone-dark-grain-strip.png
231 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-page.png
954 KiB
phone-dark-just-added-strip.png
164 KiB
phone-dark-solid-page.png
264 KiB
phone-dark-solid-strip.png
76 KiB
phone-dark-tinted-page.png
919 KiB
phone-dark-tinted-strip.png
162 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-page.png
899 KiB
phone-light-changed-reset-strip.png
170 KiB
phone-light-custom-gradient-page.png
979 KiB
phone-light-custom-gradient-strip.png
162 KiB
phone-light-frosted-page.png
915 KiB
phone-light-frosted-strip.png
165 KiB
phone-light-grain-page.png
1,020 KiB
phone-light-grain-strip.png
209 KiB
phone-light-just-added-page.png
844 KiB
phone-light-just-added-strip.png
146 KiB
phone-light-solid-page.png
246 KiB
phone-light-solid-strip.png
72 KiB
phone-light-tinted-page.png
817 KiB
phone-light-tinted-strip.png
148 KiB
desktop-05-background-solid.png
1.4 MiB
desktop-06-fade.png
2.2 MiB
desktop-07-colour-light.png
2 MiB
desktop-08-grain.png
2.9 MiB
desktop-09-wide-three-columns.png
5.6 MiB
phone-05-background-solid.png
562 KiB
phone-06-fade.png
846 KiB
phone-07-colour-light.png
842 KiB
phone-08-grain.png
1.1 MiB
kayg commented 2026-11-04 09:13:21 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 3 finish (head 10041b042): the gate, the legibility of the new values, and what is open

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head 10041b042, on top of settings-sections-mock-j92 (c88619630, unmoved). 7 round 3 commits (new values; Colour list with two circles; Solid options, label-free swatches, marked Custom; the control order and Grain; Tint/Blur/Grain in three columns; the first terminal line; comments). No Rust or Cargo file. Captures: issuecomment-77428. Round 4 (the owner's review of this head) follows in the next comment.

Gate: scripts/verify quick, then scripts/verify fast, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at 10041b042, verbatim

quick has no entry on J92's base, so dev's scripts/ were overlaid for that step only (nothing committed) with VERIFY_QUICK_BASE=c88619630:

quick scope vs merge base with c88619630: workspace=0 packages=[] tracer=1
| fmt                       | PASS         |
| tracer typecheck          | PASS         |
QUICK_EXIT=0

then fast with this branch's own scripts:

+---------------------------+--------------+
| Rust gate                 | Result       |
+---------------------------+--------------+
| fmt                       | PASS         |
| VT native fmt             | PASS         |
| CLI plugin compile-out    | PASS         |
| clippy                    | PASS         |
| SSH runtime test helper   | PASS         |
| real-binary fixture paths | PASS         |
| test                      | PASS         |
| SSH inode reuse fixture   | PASS         |
| shim process-per-user     | PASS         |
| cargo-deny                | PASS         |
| gate architecture         | PASS         |
| static builds             | PASS         |
+---------------------------+--------------+
JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315020/327680 brotli=262753/273408 bytes
JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174635 gzip=61122/61440 brotli=53961/55296 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=391833 gzip=154383/20480 brotli=137356/18432 bytes
JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-ye6jjv33.js: gzip=16225/20480 brotli=14373/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154383 brotli=137356, not limited)
VERIFY_EXIT=0

Budget against #304's own gate (critical 315,010, deferred 61,071, largest on-demand 16,223): critical +10, deferred +51 (the shared sideways-swipe rule, round 2), largest on-demand +2. Deferred has 318 B left.

Legibility of the new built-ins (Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50), dark and light; no number changed

Run on compute01 against the production build, appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts, at 4f13dbb43 (the same code for these checks as 10041b042), Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper.

Window text, primary / secondary (needs 4.5:1, worst colour a gradient can put behind) Ghost text, palette / sidebar (limit 0.02) Floating card, text on the card over dense text, 1st percentile, primary / secondary
Solid pass everywhere (primary 7.52 to 16.37, secondary 5.20 to 7.37) 0.0000 / 0.0003 to 0.0010 pass (primary 7.86 to 16.26, secondary 5.16 to 6.68)
Tinted primary 5.84 to 12.52 pass; secondary Mocha 5.23 pass, Latte 4.04, Ink 4.48, Paper 4.22 miss 0.0008 to 0.0009 / 0.0013 to 0.0022 pass primary pass (7.07 to 14.91); secondary pass (palette 4.89 to 6.53, sidebar 4.70 to 5.64)
Frosted primary Mocha 5.42, Ink 8.54, Paper 9.45 pass, Latte 4.45 misses; secondary 3.05 to 3.52 miss in all four 0.0016 to 0.0017 / 0.0022 to 0.0030 pass primary pass (6.32 to 14.45); secondary palette Latte 4.37, Paper 4.39 and sidebar Ink 4.21 miss; the other five pass
Reading: both new blurs (25% and 50% are 6 and 12 px) are under the shared 16 px floor, so a floating card blurs 16 px for all three and ghost text is fine everywhere. What fails is quieter text on the thinner fills: Frosted's secondary text everywhere on windows, Frosted's primary on Latte windows (4.45), Tinted's secondary on three of four schemes, and Frosted's secondary on three floating cards. Nothing changed; round 2's recommendation stands (raise the contrast of secondary text on translucent surfaces once, for every theme, rather than move a preset's numbers).

Tests

Unit 22 pass. Browser (production build): run 9 of my specs 71 passed, 2 failed (Colour alignment, 0.57 px against the 0.5 limit: fixed by giving the label and the circles cell one text line of height each), then run 10 on the final tree: 57 passed. Two tests of the first round 3 run were mistakes of mine (a 9 against 10 character slice of a URL; a duplicate Rosé Pine solid: its palette's cyan IS its accent, so that scheme offers six solids and the test says so).

Questions for the owner (continuing with the defaults)

  1. Headings: D338's list is "Colour, Backgrounds, Fonts" (singular, plural, plural) beside "Tint, Blur, Grain". I used his words. Recommendation: all singular (Colour, Background, Font) like Tint, Blur and Grain.
  2. Is Ink and Paper a pair? Treated as one (one row, two circles). One line in colors.ts if not.
## Round 3 finish (head `10041b042`): the gate, the legibility of the new values, and what is open Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, head **`10041b042`**, on top of `settings-sections-mock-j92` (`c88619630`, unmoved). 7 round 3 commits (new values; Colour list with two circles; Solid options, label-free swatches, marked Custom; the control order and Grain; Tint/Blur/Grain in three columns; the first terminal line; comments). No Rust or Cargo file. Captures: `issuecomment-77428`. Round 4 (the owner's review of this head) follows in the next comment. ### Gate: `scripts/verify quick`, then `scripts/verify fast`, compute01, own worktree, through build-slot, at `10041b042`, verbatim `quick` has no entry on J92's base, so dev's `scripts/` were overlaid for that step only (nothing committed) with `VERIFY_QUICK_BASE=c88619630`: ``` quick scope vs merge base with c88619630: workspace=0 packages=[] tracer=1 | fmt | PASS | | tracer typecheck | PASS | QUICK_EXIT=0 ``` then `fast` with this branch's own scripts: ``` +---------------------------+--------------+ | Rust gate | Result | +---------------------------+--------------+ | fmt | PASS | | VT native fmt | PASS | | CLI plugin compile-out | PASS | | clippy | PASS | | SSH runtime test helper | PASS | | real-binary fixture paths | PASS | | test | PASS | | SSH inode reuse fixture | PASS | | shim process-per-user | PASS | | cargo-deny | PASS | | gate architecture | PASS | | static builds | PASS | +---------------------------+--------------+ JavaScript transfer, critical: identity=1010708 gzip=315020/327680 brotli=262753/273408 bytes JavaScript transfer, deferred: identity=174635 gzip=61122/61440 brotli=53961/55296 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand: identity=391833 gzip=154383/20480 brotli=137356/18432 bytes JavaScript transfer, onDemand largest chunk chunk-ye6jjv33.js: gzip=16225/20480 brotli=14373/18432 bytes (class total gzip=154383 brotli=137356, not limited) VERIFY_EXIT=0 ``` Budget against #304's own gate (critical 315,010, deferred 61,071, largest on-demand 16,223): critical +10, deferred +51 (the shared sideways-swipe rule, round 2), largest on-demand +2. Deferred has 318 B left. ### Legibility of the new built-ins (Solid 100/0, Tinted 75/25, Frosted 50/50), dark and light; no number changed Run on compute01 against the production build, `appearance-presets-legibility.spec.ts`, at `4f13dbb43` (the same code for these checks as `10041b042`), Mocha / Latte / Ink / Paper. | | Window text, primary / secondary (needs 4.5:1, worst colour a gradient can put behind) | Ghost text, palette / sidebar (limit 0.02) | Floating card, text on the card over dense text, 1st percentile, primary / secondary | |---|---|---|---| | Solid | pass everywhere (primary 7.52 to 16.37, secondary 5.20 to 7.37) | 0.0000 / 0.0003 to 0.0010 | pass (primary 7.86 to 16.26, secondary 5.16 to 6.68) | | Tinted | primary 5.84 to 12.52 pass; secondary Mocha 5.23 pass, **Latte 4.04, Ink 4.48, Paper 4.22 miss** | 0.0008 to 0.0009 / 0.0013 to 0.0022 pass | primary pass (7.07 to 14.91); secondary pass (palette 4.89 to 6.53, sidebar 4.70 to 5.64) | | Frosted | primary Mocha 5.42, Ink 8.54, Paper 9.45 pass, **Latte 4.45 misses**; secondary **3.05 to 3.52 miss in all four** | 0.0016 to 0.0017 / 0.0022 to 0.0030 pass | primary pass (6.32 to 14.45); secondary **palette Latte 4.37, Paper 4.39 and sidebar Ink 4.21 miss**; the other five pass | Reading: both new blurs (25% and 50% are 6 and 12 px) are under the shared 16 px floor, so a floating card blurs 16 px for all three and ghost text is fine everywhere. What fails is quieter text on the thinner fills: Frosted's secondary text everywhere on windows, Frosted's primary on Latte windows (4.45), Tinted's secondary on three of four schemes, and Frosted's secondary on three floating cards. Nothing changed; round 2's recommendation stands (raise the contrast of secondary text on translucent surfaces once, for every theme, rather than move a preset's numbers). ### Tests Unit 22 pass. Browser (production build): run 9 of my specs 71 passed, 2 failed (Colour alignment, 0.57 px against the 0.5 limit: fixed by giving the label and the circles cell one text line of height each), then run 10 on the final tree: 57 passed. Two tests of the first round 3 run were mistakes of mine (a 9 against 10 character slice of a URL; a duplicate Rosé Pine solid: its palette's cyan IS its accent, so that scheme offers six solids and the test says so). ### Questions for the owner (continuing with the defaults) 1. Headings: D338's list is "Colour, Backgrounds, Fonts" (singular, plural, plural) beside "Tint, Blur, Grain". I used his words. Recommendation: all singular (Colour, Background, Font) like Tint, Blur and Grain. 2. Is Ink and Paper a pair? Treated as one (one row, two circles). One line in `colors.ts` if not.
kayg commented 2026-11-04 12:04:01 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Round 4 progress (not finished): what is proven, what is not, and what I am waiting on

Branch appearance-presets-mock-j129 (head 7ad3af072, on top of J92 c88619630). Nothing below is a claim of "done"; the gate has not been run on round 4.

Proven in a real browser (Playwright against the production build of the mockup, compute01/dev-02), with photographs

1. The Colour circle. The new test presses and holds every circle (a real mouse hold on desktop; a real touch hold then a real tap on the phone) and asserts the circle does not move, the row is not transformed, and the theme, --bg, the card and the circle's checked state follow.

  • On the round 3 build the owner reviewed, it fails exactly as he said: pressing Ink and Paper's light circle moves the circle 4.84 px under the held pointer, the row is scaled to 0.97 (the product's .ui-sp-row:active), and the page stays mocha instead of paper. Photograph: desktop-press-held-paper.png (the Ink and Paper row visibly shrunk, its circle off the column).
  • On the new build the desktop run passes for all thirteen presses. The phone run still fails on its theme assertion (the click does fire on the circle, click:cl-colour-dot is in the event log, but the theme was still mocha 500 ms later; desktop does not show it). I do not yet know whether that is the theme taking longer than 500 ms on the emulated phone or a real defect; the next run polls for the theme and prints how long it took, so it answers that. I am not calling bug 1 fixed on a phone until it does.

2. The empty screen. The new test takes every row of Settings to its end sideways and back (a real wheel, and a real two-finger touch drag), and asserts a window of that row is on the screen and that the camera has no stop on an empty track.

  • On the round 3 build it fails: Appearance (two windows) has 5 camera stops, three of them on empty tracks. Photograph: desktop-extent-appearance-end.png is the owner's screenshot reproduced: only the background and the breadcrumb pills.
  • Cause (the element that makes the extent): Settings is one grid with a track for each window of the longest row (You has five), and the camera has a stop per track. The empty tracks cannot be removed (the rows must line up), so the stops on them are: while a row is framed, its stops are only the columns it has a window in (layout/band-limit.on-demand.ts, a hook in camera/lock.ts and layout/stops.ts, and an event from layout/columns.ts so the camera re-aims when the group moves to another row).
  • On the new build the desktop test passes for all seven rows. The phone test passes rows 0 to 4 and fails at row 5 (its first window is not in view at the start); I have not found why, and the next run prints what the camera and the windows were.

Not good yet: my fix broke four of J92's own tests

With the row limit engaged, J92's settings-sections.spec.ts now fails close-ups of the action group and the three no side is clipped tests (s-appearance-size is not whole on screen, in J92's original Appearance layout with four windows). The other J92 failure (breadcrumb centred, 0.6 px against 0.5) fails identically on the unmodified base c88619630, so it is not mine. I have not found the cause of the four; the next run replays J92's exact flight through every window with and without the limit and prints the camera after each (settings-extent-diagnostic.spec.ts, temporary). This touches the canvas code J132 is rebuilding, so it needs care and may need the orchestrator's call: tell me if you would rather I leave the canvas alone and hand the cause to J132.

Grain: measured, and my first scale was wrong

appearance-grain.spec.ts measures the RMS change a grain makes to a real window (8-bit levels, dark / light):

product mesh grain (0.035 overlay) round 3's 100% (0.4 overlay, what the owner found too much) new 100% at largest 0.08 new 100% at largest 0.04 25% / 50% at 0.04
dark window 0.69 7.14 6.95 3.47 0.80 / 1.63
light window 0.57 3.27 7.74 3.91 1.05 / 2.02
My first "tamed" maximum (0.08) measured the same strength as round 3 (about 7 levels in dark), so it was not tamed. At 0.04 the scale is linear (25% is 0.23 and 50% is 0.47 of 100%) and 100% is half of round 3's in dark (and about the same as round 3's in light, where an overlay blend is weaker): proposed maximum 0.04, about 3.5 to 3.9 levels, five to seven times the product's own (nearly invisible) mesh grain. Captures at 25, 50 and 100%, and 100% at 0.02, 0.03, 0.04, 0.06, 0.08, will be in the final comment. 0.03 (2.6 / 2.9 levels) is the quieter choice.

Done and pushed (no browser claim beyond the above)

Themes (renamed, comments too), "Windows" heading with Tint / Blur / Grain, grain on window and floating-card surfaces (not the canvas) with the amount baked into the tile, label-free swatches already in round 3. Also fixed on the way: I had cut the three-column CSS out of clusters.css with a bad truncation and turned file names in comments into appearance-themes / theme-strip; both repaired.

Waiting on

Run 13 (dev-02, second in the queue behind two gate runs 1h40 old). Then: fix what it shows, drop the diagnostic, the index entry, re-serve :47680, the before/after table with captures (dark, light, phone), and verify quick then verify fast.

## Round 4 progress (not finished): what is proven, what is not, and what I am waiting on Branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129` (head `7ad3af072`, on top of J92 `c88619630`). Nothing below is a claim of "done"; the gate has not been run on round 4. ### Proven in a real browser (Playwright against the production build of the mockup, compute01/dev-02), with photographs **1. The Colour circle.** The new test presses and holds every circle (a real mouse hold on desktop; a real touch hold then a real tap on the phone) and asserts the circle does not move, the row is not transformed, and the theme, `--bg`, the card and the circle's checked state follow. - On the **round 3 build the owner reviewed**, it fails exactly as he said: pressing Ink and Paper's light circle moves the circle 4.84 px under the held pointer, the row is scaled to 0.97 (the product's `.ui-sp-row:active`), and the page stays `mocha` instead of `paper`. Photograph: `desktop-press-held-paper.png` (the Ink and Paper row visibly shrunk, its circle off the column). - On the new build the **desktop** run passes for all thirteen presses. The **phone** run still fails on its theme assertion (the click does fire on the circle, `click:cl-colour-dot` is in the event log, but the theme was still `mocha` 500 ms later; desktop does not show it). I do not yet know whether that is the theme taking longer than 500 ms on the emulated phone or a real defect; the next run polls for the theme and prints how long it took, so it answers that. I am not calling bug 1 fixed on a phone until it does. **2. The empty screen.** The new test takes every row of Settings to its end sideways and back (a real wheel, and a real two-finger touch drag), and asserts a window of that row is on the screen and that the camera has no stop on an empty track. - On the **round 3 build** it fails: Appearance (two windows) has **5 camera stops**, three of them on empty tracks. Photograph: `desktop-extent-appearance-end.png` is the owner's screenshot reproduced: only the background and the breadcrumb pills. - **Cause (the element that makes the extent):** Settings is one grid with a track for each window of the longest row (You has five), and the camera has a stop per track. The empty tracks cannot be removed (the rows must line up), so the stops on them are: while a row is framed, its stops are only the columns it has a window in (`layout/band-limit.on-demand.ts`, a hook in `camera/lock.ts` and `layout/stops.ts`, and an event from `layout/columns.ts` so the camera re-aims when the group moves to another row). - On the new build the **desktop** test passes for all seven rows. The **phone** test passes rows 0 to 4 and fails at row 5 (its first window is not in view at the start); I have not found why, and the next run prints what the camera and the windows were. ### Not good yet: my fix broke four of J92's own tests With the row limit engaged, J92's `settings-sections.spec.ts` now fails `close-ups of the action group` and the three `no side is clipped` tests (`s-appearance-size is not whole on screen`, in J92's original Appearance layout with four windows). The other J92 failure (breadcrumb centred, 0.6 px against 0.5) fails identically on the unmodified base `c88619630`, so it is not mine. I have not found the cause of the four; the next run replays J92's exact flight through every window with and without the limit and prints the camera after each (`settings-extent-diagnostic.spec.ts`, temporary). This touches the canvas code J132 is rebuilding, so it needs care and may need the orchestrator's call: tell me if you would rather I leave the canvas alone and hand the cause to J132. ### Grain: measured, and my first scale was wrong `appearance-grain.spec.ts` measures the RMS change a grain makes to a real window (8-bit levels, dark / light): | | product mesh grain (0.035 overlay) | **round 3's 100%** (0.4 overlay, what the owner found too much) | new 100% at largest 0.08 | **new 100% at largest 0.04** | 25% / 50% at 0.04 | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | dark window | 0.69 | **7.14** | 6.95 | **3.47** | 0.80 / 1.63 | | light window | 0.57 | 3.27 | 7.74 | 3.91 | 1.05 / 2.02 | My first "tamed" maximum (0.08) measured the same strength as round 3 (about 7 levels in dark), so it was not tamed. At **0.04** the scale is linear (25% is 0.23 and 50% is 0.47 of 100%) and 100% is half of round 3's in dark (and about the same as round 3's in light, where an overlay blend is weaker): **proposed maximum 0.04**, about 3.5 to 3.9 levels, five to seven times the product's own (nearly invisible) mesh grain. Captures at 25, 50 and 100%, and 100% at 0.02, 0.03, 0.04, 0.06, 0.08, will be in the final comment. 0.03 (2.6 / 2.9 levels) is the quieter choice. ### Done and pushed (no browser claim beyond the above) Themes (renamed, comments too), "Windows" heading with Tint / Blur / Grain, grain on window and floating-card surfaces (not the canvas) with the amount baked into the tile, label-free swatches already in round 3. Also fixed on the way: I had cut the three-column CSS out of `clusters.css` with a bad truncation and turned file names in comments into `appearance-themes` / `theme-strip`; both repaired. ### Waiting on Run 13 (dev-02, second in the queue behind two gate runs 1h40 old). Then: fix what it shows, drop the diagnostic, the index entry, re-serve :47680, the before/after table with captures (dark, light, phone), and `verify quick` then `verify fast`.
kayg commented 2026-11-04 16:26:31 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J129 final note (round 4). The owner approved round 4 (D349), with the remark that the requested additional colour schemes and fonts are still missing. Those and the product build of Themes are J206's.

  • Reference branch appearance-presets-mock-j129, head 36822cd50 (pushed, on J92's base c88619630).
  • Fixed in this round: the bounce and the light circle (the held press moved the circle out from under the finger; plus a shared tooltip bug where a long press that ended without a click ate the next tap, packages/ui/src/tooltip.ts), the invisible third screen (stops limited to the framed row's own columns), grain on window surfaces with the tamed scale (maximum 0.04), "Themes" everywhere, and Tint, Blur and Grain under "Windows".
  • Not completed: the final run of my specs (run 28) and scripts/verify quick / fast on 36822cd50 were cancelled by the orchestrator's instruction when the owner approved, so there is no gate output for this head. J206 runs the gates on the product build.
  • Cleaned up: the preview on :47680 is stopped, the VM worktrees, targets and dist copies of this job are removed. The branch stays on the remote as the reference.
**J129 final note (round 4).** The owner approved round 4 (D349), with the remark that the requested additional colour schemes and fonts are still missing. Those and the product build of Themes are J206's. - Reference branch `appearance-presets-mock-j129`, head `36822cd50` (pushed, on J92's base `c88619630`). - Fixed in this round: the bounce and the light circle (the held press moved the circle out from under the finger; plus a shared tooltip bug where a long press that ended without a click ate the next tap, `packages/ui/src/tooltip.ts`), the invisible third screen (stops limited to the framed row's own columns), grain on window surfaces with the tamed scale (maximum 0.04), "Themes" everywhere, and Tint, Blur and Grain under "Windows". - Not completed: the final run of my specs (run 28) and `scripts/verify quick` / `fast` on `36822cd50` were cancelled by the orchestrator's instruction when the owner approved, so there is no gate output for this head. J206 runs the gates on the product build. - Cleaned up: the preview on :47680 is stopped, the VM worktrees, targets and dist copies of this job are removed. The branch stays on the remote as the reference.
kayg commented 2026-11-04 16:26:53 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 start — branch themes-j206, base origin/dev e9f2b3ef4 (stacking decision below).

Findings so far (evidence):

  1. The approved mock (appearance-presets-mock-j129) keeps its model, editor, gradients and grain under apps/tracer/src/canvas/mock/appearance-presets/. The real product's Appearance is still the old card/window levels in core-screen.ts + packages/ui/src/settings-panels.ts (localStorage keys). So this job ports the model into the product rather than reusing the mock.
  2. Persistence question. The only "account-synced" setting today is the toolbar layout, and it goes through /__mock/account/toolbar (core-screen.ts:1164). grep over crates/ finds no route and no per-person settings store on the server. Real server-side sync therefore needs a storage choice that is not mine to make in a job (CLAUDE.md foundational rule).
    Recommendation / safe default I will build: themes persist per device in localStorage and per person through the same account endpoint pattern the toolbar uses (/__mock/account/appearance, test double only), behind one small adapter, so a real store can replace it in one place. Owner decision needed: where per-person settings live on the real server.
  3. J132 (settings-rows-j132) restructures Settings (rows of windows, palette jumps by group), which the Appearance window sits inside. I will stack on it if it is the Appearance window's parent structure; I'll confirm after reading its Appearance group and say so in a comment.

Plan (estimate ~10–12 h of job time, then verify):

  1. Theme model + apply (Solid/Tinted/Frosted, copy-on-+, tint/blur/grain, window-only grain with tamed scale) in packages/ui + core-screen.
  2. Themes strip UI (reuse preset-strip.ts pattern), Windows heading over Tint/Blur/Grain, round-4 fixes.
  3. Persistence adapter; default Tinted.
  4. D329 colour schemes (contrast-audited per D80, licences in THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md).
  5. D329 fonts (subset, on demand, D188 font budget).
  6. Playwright at 1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark+light; screenshots to #323; verify quick then verify fast.
**J206 start** — branch `themes-j206`, base `origin/dev` e9f2b3ef4 (stacking decision below). Findings so far (evidence): 1. The approved mock (`appearance-presets-mock-j129`) keeps its model, editor, gradients and grain under `apps/tracer/src/canvas/mock/appearance-presets/`. The real product's Appearance is still the old card/window levels in `core-screen.ts` + `packages/ui/src/settings-panels.ts` (localStorage keys). So this job ports the model into the product rather than reusing the mock. 2. **Persistence question.** The only "account-synced" setting today is the toolbar layout, and it goes through `/__mock/account/toolbar` (`core-screen.ts:1164`). `grep` over `crates/` finds no route and no per-person settings store on the server. Real server-side sync therefore needs a storage choice that is not mine to make in a job (CLAUDE.md foundational rule). **Recommendation / safe default I will build:** themes persist per device in localStorage and per person through the same account endpoint pattern the toolbar uses (`/__mock/account/appearance`, test double only), behind one small adapter, so a real store can replace it in one place. **Owner decision needed:** where per-person settings live on the real server. 3. J132 (`settings-rows-j132`) restructures Settings (rows of windows, palette jumps by group), which the Appearance window sits inside. I will stack on it if it is the Appearance window's parent structure; I'll confirm after reading its Appearance group and say so in a comment. Plan (estimate ~10–12 h of job time, then verify): 1. Theme model + apply (Solid/Tinted/Frosted, copy-on-+, tint/blur/grain, window-only grain with tamed scale) in `packages/ui` + core-screen. 2. Themes strip UI (reuse `preset-strip.ts` pattern), Windows heading over Tint/Blur/Grain, round-4 fixes. 3. Persistence adapter; default Tinted. 4. D329 colour schemes (contrast-audited per D80, licences in THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md). 5. D329 fonts (subset, on demand, D188 font budget). 6. Playwright at 1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark+light; screenshots to #323; `verify quick` then `verify fast`.
kayg commented 2026-11-04 17:45:40 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 progress — branch themes-j206 (stacked on settings-rows-j132 @ ca248d9ba, because J132 splits the Appearance panel into windows by heading text and I replace those headings).

Done and pushed (WIP commits, to be split into atomic ones at the end):

  • Themes model with validation (canvas/themes/model.ts, 19 unit tests pass on compute01), apply, persistence (device + account adapter), controller started from core-screen for the product screens, palette rows Theme: <name>.
  • Strip (packages/ui/src/theme-strip.ts), Themes window (strip, UI size, Colour with light/dark circles, Backgrounds, Windows heading over Tint/Blur/Grain, Fonts). The old Theme/Font/Size windows and the old Appearance panel are gone (Appearance row is now Themes + Layout). Grain lies on windows and floating cards, scale tamed (max speck 0.04).
  • D329 colour schemes: 17 added (Solarized, Everforest, Kanagawa Lotus/Wave, Ayu, GitHub, Flexoki, Gruvbox Light, Tokyo Night Day, Catppuccin Frappé/Macchiato, Light/Night Owl). D80 audit is now code + a unit-test gate (theme-audit.ts), all 27 schemes pass; every repaired colour is logged in docs/design/THEME-AUDIT.md; licences read from each upstream repo and recorded in THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md (MIT, Tokyo Night Day Apache-2.0; Gruvbox: no LICENSE file in the repo, package.json declares MIT).
  • D329 fonts: 14 families (Iosevka, Victor Mono, Recursive Mono, Martian Mono, Intel One Mono, Fantasque Sans Mono, Hack, Inconsolata, 0xProto, Lilex, Monaspace Argon/Xenon/Radon/Krypton), subset by the pinned pipeline (sha256-checked archives), internal names replaced, loaded only when chosen, budgets added to transfer-budget.ts (all pass).

Numbers (production build, gzip):

  • Critical JS: 319,847 → 326,296 B (+6,449 B, +2.0%); cap 327,680 B, so 1,384 B of headroom left. Cause is mostly data (17 schemes, 14 font entries) plus store/apply code. Not changed the budget. Option for the owner if more headroom is wanted: load the extra schemes on demand (needs an async boot when a saved scheme is one of them).
  • Themes editor chunk (on demand): 5,640 B gzip (cap 20 KiB).
  • Font files added: 37 woff2, 1.0 MB in total, none fetched until chosen (spec asserts it).

Findings:

  1. Per-person sync has no server store (see first comment); the account adapter works against the test double only.
  2. Font weights for the 14 new families are common defaults (variable 450 / static 400, bold 700), not ink measurements as for the existing ones. I can measure on request.
  3. First spec run: 12 pass / 5 fail; 4 were test isolation (account state shared between tests), 1 is a real 0.9 px centre-line offset between a Colour name and its circle. Fixing; a batch with the affected existing specs is queued on compute01 (long queue).
**J206 progress** — branch `themes-j206` (stacked on `settings-rows-j132` @ ca248d9ba, because J132 splits the Appearance panel into windows by heading text and I replace those headings). Done and pushed (WIP commits, to be split into atomic ones at the end): - Themes model with validation (`canvas/themes/model.ts`, 19 unit tests pass on compute01), apply, persistence (device + account adapter), controller started from `core-screen` for the product screens, palette rows `Theme: <name>`. - Strip (`packages/ui/src/theme-strip.ts`), Themes window (strip, UI size, Colour with light/dark circles, Backgrounds, **Windows** heading over Tint/Blur/Grain, Fonts). The old Theme/Font/Size windows and the old Appearance panel are gone (Appearance row is now Themes + Layout). Grain lies on windows and floating cards, scale tamed (max speck 0.04). - D329 colour schemes: 17 added (Solarized, Everforest, Kanagawa Lotus/Wave, Ayu, GitHub, Flexoki, Gruvbox Light, Tokyo Night Day, Catppuccin Frappé/Macchiato, Light/Night Owl). D80 audit is now code + a unit-test gate (`theme-audit.ts`), all 27 schemes pass; every repaired colour is logged in `docs/design/THEME-AUDIT.md`; licences read from each upstream repo and recorded in `THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md` (MIT, Tokyo Night Day Apache-2.0; Gruvbox: no LICENSE file in the repo, `package.json` declares MIT). - D329 fonts: 14 families (Iosevka, Victor Mono, Recursive Mono, Martian Mono, Intel One Mono, Fantasque Sans Mono, Hack, Inconsolata, 0xProto, Lilex, Monaspace Argon/Xenon/Radon/Krypton), subset by the pinned pipeline (sha256-checked archives), internal names replaced, loaded only when chosen, budgets added to `transfer-budget.ts` (all pass). Numbers (production build, gzip): - Critical JS: 319,847 → 326,296 B (+6,449 B, +2.0%); cap 327,680 B, so **1,384 B of headroom left**. Cause is mostly data (17 schemes, 14 font entries) plus store/apply code. Not changed the budget. Option for the owner if more headroom is wanted: load the extra schemes on demand (needs an async boot when a saved scheme is one of them). - Themes editor chunk (on demand): 5,640 B gzip (cap 20 KiB). - Font files added: 37 woff2, 1.0 MB in total, none fetched until chosen (spec asserts it). Findings: 1. Per-person sync has no server store (see first comment); the account adapter works against the test double only. 2. Font weights for the 14 new families are common defaults (variable 450 / static 400, bold 700), not ink measurements as for the existing ones. I can measure on request. 3. First spec run: 12 pass / 5 fail; 4 were test isolation (account state shared between tests), 1 is a real 0.9 px centre-line offset between a Colour name and its circle. Fixing; a batch with the affected existing specs is queued on compute01 (long queue).
kayg commented 2026-11-04 22:37:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 progress 2 — themes-j206 head 9cc5443e7 (7 atomic commits on settings-rows-j132 + 1 test fix).

Gate: scripts/verify fast on compute01 at 9cc5443e7: FAST_EXIT=0. Rust gate table, verbatim:

| fmt | PASS | VT native fmt | PASS | CLI plugin compile-out | PASS | clippy | PASS |
| SSH runtime test helper | PASS | real-binary fixture paths | PASS | Traefik component manifest | PASS |
| release component publication | PASS | test | PASS | SSH inode reuse fixture | PASS |
| shim process-per-user | PASS | cargo-deny | PASS | gate architecture | PASS |
| doc coverage ratchet | PASS | static builds | PASS |

(first run found one real failure, the Settings-map unit test still naming the old Appearance windows: fixed in 9cc5443e7.) verify quick passed earlier on the previous head (fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals +0/+0/+0, tracer typecheck).
Static size (report only): x86_64 23,385,200 B (+966,944 vs the gate baseline), aarch64 21,250,032 B (+796,752). The delta includes J132's own and my 1.0 MB of woff2 files.

Browser specs (production build, compute01): Themes spec 18/18 (1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark+light captures); settings-rows-of-windows 29/29; ui-size 8/8; ui-size-windows 7/7; font-switch 3/3; settings-edges 4/4; settings-rows 7/7; machine-sections 7/7; font-picker 2/2; clusters-appearance 1/1. On the unmodified J132 base these fail the same way, so they are not mine: core-screen (2, #rtt stays "··"), palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title", clusters "window header actions are one pill".

Regression I introduced, being measured: clusters.spec "toolbar rows snap" passes 3/3 on the base and 1/3 on this branch. A diagnostic (temporary spec, not committed) shows the touch drag of the key tray does not commit under the new default look (Tinted: windows blur 25% = 6 px) and does commit with blur 0 (same tint, same gradient). So the window blur costs enough frames in software rendering to lose the drag. The mock's own note said a production version must measure this again; I'm measuring frame times per look (idle and while panning) and will report numbers here before choosing a mitigation. Candidates: keep blur only on windows that overlap something to blur, or quantise the blur into a few literal rules. Not changing the owner's numbers (D338).

**J206 progress 2** — `themes-j206` head `9cc5443e7` (7 atomic commits on `settings-rows-j132` + 1 test fix). Gate: `scripts/verify fast` on compute01 at `9cc5443e7`: **FAST_EXIT=0**. Rust gate table, verbatim: ``` | fmt | PASS | VT native fmt | PASS | CLI plugin compile-out | PASS | clippy | PASS | | SSH runtime test helper | PASS | real-binary fixture paths | PASS | Traefik component manifest | PASS | | release component publication | PASS | test | PASS | SSH inode reuse fixture | PASS | | shim process-per-user | PASS | cargo-deny | PASS | gate architecture | PASS | | doc coverage ratchet | PASS | static builds | PASS | ``` (first run found one real failure, the Settings-map unit test still naming the old Appearance windows: fixed in `9cc5443e7`.) `verify quick` passed earlier on the previous head (fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals +0/+0/+0, tracer typecheck). Static size (report only): x86_64 23,385,200 B (+966,944 vs the gate baseline), aarch64 21,250,032 B (+796,752). The delta includes J132's own and my 1.0 MB of woff2 files. Browser specs (production build, compute01): Themes spec 18/18 (1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark+light captures); settings-rows-of-windows 29/29; ui-size 8/8; ui-size-windows 7/7; font-switch 3/3; settings-edges 4/4; settings-rows 7/7; machine-sections 7/7; font-picker 2/2; clusters-appearance 1/1. On the unmodified J132 base these fail the same way, so they are not mine: core-screen (2, `#rtt` stays "··"), palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title", clusters "window header actions are one pill". **Regression I introduced, being measured:** `clusters.spec` "toolbar rows snap" passes 3/3 on the base and 1/3 on this branch. A diagnostic (temporary spec, not committed) shows the touch drag of the key tray does not commit under the new default look (Tinted: windows blur 25% = 6 px) and does commit with blur 0 (same tint, same gradient). So the window blur costs enough frames in software rendering to lose the drag. The mock's own note said a production version must measure this again; I'm measuring frame times per look (idle and while panning) and will report numbers here before choosing a mitigation. Candidates: keep blur only on windows that overlap something to blur, or quantise the blur into a few literal rules. Not changing the owner's numbers (D338).
kayg commented 2026-11-05 00:47:21 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 screenshots (production build of themes-j206, THEMES_SHOTS captures of test/themes.spec.ts; 1440×900 DPR 2, 393×852 DPR 3, 375×667 DPR 2; dark = Catppuccin Mocha, light = Catppuccin Latte; a new person, so Tinted is selected). Attached: the Themes window at each size and mode, plus the Windows and Colour sections.

**J206 screenshots** (production build of `themes-j206`, THEMES_SHOTS captures of `test/themes.spec.ts`; 1440×900 DPR 2, 393×852 DPR 3, 375×667 DPR 2; dark = Catppuccin Mocha, light = Catppuccin Latte; a new person, so Tinted is selected). Attached: the Themes window at each size and mode, plus the Windows and Colour sections.
desktop-1440x900-dark-3-windows.png
1.1 MiB
desktop-1440x900-dark-themes.png
1.2 MiB
desktop-1440x900-light-themes.png
1.1 MiB
phone-375x667-dark-themes.png
316 KiB
phone-375x667-light-themes.png
288 KiB
phone-393x852-dark-1-colour.png
568 KiB
phone-393x852-dark-themes.png
643 KiB
phone-393x852-light-themes.png
594 KiB
desktop-1440x900-dark-3-windows.png desktop-1440x900-dark-themes.png desktop-1440x900-light-themes.png phone-375x667-dark-themes.png phone-375x667-light-themes.png phone-393x852-dark-1-colour.png phone-393x852-dark-themes.png phone-393x852-light-themes.png
kayg commented 2026-11-05 00:48:41 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 finish — branch themes-j206, head 444834516 (base: settings-rows-j132 @ 574037ea5, stacked because J132 splits the Appearance panel into windows by heading text). Not merged, not deployed.

Commits (atomic): D80 gate + 17 colour schemes + licences · 14 fonts · Themes model + persistence · page follows the theme · Appearance › Themes window · Themes spec · specs follow the window (+ small test fixes, ?look=).

Gate. scripts/verify quick passed on the final source head (fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals +0/+0/+0, tracer typecheck). scripts/verify fast on compute01 at fe70324a1 (the only later commits change test files; tsc on 444834516 is clean): FAST_EXIT=0, Rust gate table:

| fmt PASS | VT native fmt PASS | CLI plugin compile-out PASS | clippy PASS | SSH runtime test helper PASS |
| real-binary fixture paths PASS | Traefik component manifest PASS | release component publication PASS | test PASS |
| SSH inode reuse fixture PASS | shim process-per-user PASS | cargo-deny PASS | gate architecture PASS |
| doc coverage ratchet PASS | static builds PASS |

Static (report only, D243 amended): x86_64 23,385,200 B (+966,944 vs the gate baseline 22,418,256), aarch64 21,250,032 B (+796,752 vs 20,453,280); includes J132's delta and my 1.0 MB of woff2.
Transfer budgets: critical JS gzip 319,847 → 326,296 B (cap 327,680: 1,384 B left), Themes editor chunk 5,640 B (on demand), font families all within their budgets, none fetched until chosen.

Browser specs (production build, compute01): themes 19/19; settings-rows-of-windows 29/29; ui-size 8/8; ui-size-windows 7/7; font-switch 3/3; settings-edges 4/4; settings-rows 7/7; machine-sections 7/7; font-picker 2/2; clusters-appearance 1/1; clusters.spec all pass except "window header actions are one pill", which fails identically on the unmodified J132 base (so do core-screen ×2 and palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title"). Screenshots at 1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark and light are attached above.

Needs your decision — the default look costs frames. Headless software rendering, mean frame time (ms), idle / panning:

look phone idle desktop idle desktop pan
Solid 100/0 17.2 17.5 25.2
Tinted 75/25 (default, D322/D338) 27.3 64.5 97.8
tint only 75/0 18.6 26.4 29.1
Frosted 50/50 53.7 89.5 116.6
The cost is the window blur (backdrop-filter on every on-screen window); tint alone is cheap. Software rendering overstates a phone GPU, but it lost touch gestures in specs (toolbar-row snap, long press) and wheel zooms, so those specs now open with look=solid; I did not change your numbers. Options: (a) accept (real GPUs), (b) blur only the active window or windows that overlap something, (c) quantise blur into a few literal rules, (d) default to tint-only. I recommend measuring on the Mac VM / a real phone first (perf VM has no GPU).

Other questions for kayg

  1. Per-person sync has no server store (first comment): themes sync through /__mock/account/appearance in the test double only; on the real server they stay on the device. Where should per-person settings live?
  2. Critical-path headroom is 1,384 B. If more is wanted, the extra schemes can load on demand (async boot when a saved scheme is one of them).
  3. The 14 new fonts use default weights (variable 450, static 400), not ink measurements; Catppuccin Frappé and Macchiato are dark-only rows beside the Catppuccin row; Paper+Ink pairing is still my reading (from J129); Ayu has Light and Dark only (no Mirage).
  4. Gruvbox upstream has no LICENSE file (package.json says MIT); Tokyo Night Day is Apache-2.0.
  5. TASTE.md: I updated two lines (default background, UI size's place).
**J206 finish** — branch `themes-j206`, head `444834516` (base: `settings-rows-j132` @ 574037ea5, stacked because J132 splits the Appearance panel into windows by heading text). Not merged, not deployed. Commits (atomic): D80 gate + 17 colour schemes + licences · 14 fonts · Themes model + persistence · page follows the theme · Appearance › Themes window · Themes spec · specs follow the window (+ small test fixes, `?look=`). **Gate.** `scripts/verify quick` passed on the final source head (fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals +0/+0/+0, tracer typecheck). `scripts/verify fast` on compute01 at `fe70324a1` (the only later commits change test files; `tsc` on `444834516` is clean): **FAST_EXIT=0**, Rust gate table: ``` | fmt PASS | VT native fmt PASS | CLI plugin compile-out PASS | clippy PASS | SSH runtime test helper PASS | | real-binary fixture paths PASS | Traefik component manifest PASS | release component publication PASS | test PASS | | SSH inode reuse fixture PASS | shim process-per-user PASS | cargo-deny PASS | gate architecture PASS | | doc coverage ratchet PASS | static builds PASS | ``` Static (report only, D243 amended): x86_64 23,385,200 B (+966,944 vs the gate baseline 22,418,256), aarch64 21,250,032 B (+796,752 vs 20,453,280); includes J132's delta and my 1.0 MB of woff2. Transfer budgets: critical JS gzip 319,847 → 326,296 B (cap 327,680: 1,384 B left), Themes editor chunk 5,640 B (on demand), font families all within their budgets, none fetched until chosen. **Browser specs** (production build, compute01): themes 19/19; settings-rows-of-windows 29/29; ui-size 8/8; ui-size-windows 7/7; font-switch 3/3; settings-edges 4/4; settings-rows 7/7; machine-sections 7/7; font-picker 2/2; clusters-appearance 1/1; clusters.spec all pass except "window header actions are one pill", which fails identically on the unmodified J132 base (so do core-screen ×2 and palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title"). Screenshots at 1440×900, 393×852, 375×667, dark and light are attached above. **Needs your decision — the default look costs frames.** Headless software rendering, mean frame time (ms), idle / panning: | look | phone idle | desktop idle | desktop pan | |---|---|---|---| | Solid 100/0 | 17.2 | 17.5 | 25.2 | | **Tinted 75/25 (default, D322/D338)** | **27.3** | **64.5** | **97.8** | | tint only 75/0 | 18.6 | 26.4 | 29.1 | | Frosted 50/50 | 53.7 | 89.5 | 116.6 | The cost is the window blur (backdrop-filter on every on-screen window); tint alone is cheap. Software rendering overstates a phone GPU, but it lost touch gestures in specs (toolbar-row snap, long press) and wheel zooms, so those specs now open with `look=solid`; I did not change your numbers. Options: (a) accept (real GPUs), (b) blur only the active window or windows that overlap something, (c) quantise blur into a few literal rules, (d) default to tint-only. I recommend measuring on the Mac VM / a real phone first (perf VM has no GPU). **Other questions for kayg** 1. Per-person sync has no server store (first comment): themes sync through `/__mock/account/appearance` in the test double only; on the real server they stay on the device. Where should per-person settings live? 2. Critical-path headroom is 1,384 B. If more is wanted, the extra schemes can load on demand (async boot when a saved scheme is one of them). 3. The 14 new fonts use default weights (variable 450, static 400), not ink measurements; Catppuccin Frappé and Macchiato are dark-only rows beside the Catppuccin row; Paper+Ink pairing is still my reading (from J129); Ayu has Light and Dark only (no Mirage). 4. Gruvbox upstream has no LICENSE file (package.json says MIT); Tokyo Night Day is Apache-2.0. 5. TASTE.md: I updated two lines (default background, UI size's place).
kayg commented 2026-11-05 04:29:00 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 — merged with origin/dev — themes-j206 head 757717854 (dev 54ca98177 merged in as 59f5c313d; 127 commits). Not merged to dev.

Merge. Textually clean (no conflict markers); the real conflicts were semantic, and I fixed them so both sides' intent stands:

  • D188 critical-path budget (the big one). Dev alone is 321,146 B gzip / 268,072 B brotli; with Themes the merge was 327,918 / 273,852, over the 327,680 / 273,408 caps. Ablation builds: the D329 data is 2.4 KB (schemes 2.0, fonts 0.4), Themes code ~4.3 KB. Compacting the tables saved ~70 B (hex digits are the floor), so the background maker and grain-tile maker (gradient recipes, colour maths) now load on demand after first paint (paint.on-demand.ts; backgrounds.ts keeps the ids on the critical path). Result: 326,859 gzip / 273,227 brotli, i.e. 821 B / 181 B under the caps. The caps are untouched. Dev has little headroom left for anyone else.
  • Toast stack (J165). toast-stack.spec passed 25/25 on dev and failed 2/4 on my head: a diagnostic printing the boxes over time shows stacked toasts reach their scale (0.95 / 0.90) in ~300 ms under both looks, but under the default look the transition's first frame comes ~100 ms after the toast is drawn, and the spec measured the instant it existed. It now waits for the stack's transitions to finish (document.getAnimations). 25/25 again.
  • UI consistency (J195) / doc coverage / TASTE: ui-literals +0/+0/+0, doc coverage ratchet PASS, TASTE merged without overlap.
  • Spec fixes from dev's own changes: palette-polish expects two Appearance rows (Themes, Layout) and the window name "Themes".
    Correction to my earlier report: the D329 list is 18 schemes (I wrote 17).

Gate scripts/verify fast, compute01, head d8478afd2 (later commits change only spec files; tsc clean on 757717854): FAST_EXIT=0. Table: fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, static builds — all PASS. scripts/verify quick (base origin/dev) on 757717854: scope guard, migration names, fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals, tracer typecheck — all PASS. Static size (report only): x86_64 23,601,648 B (+1,183,392 vs gate baseline), aarch64 21,449,056 B (+995,776); includes dev's own deltas.

Specs on the production build (compute01): themes 19/19 (with the three-size dark/light captures), palette-polish 11/11, toast-stack 25/25, clusters 42/42, settings-rows 7/7, settings-edges 4/4, machine-sections 7/7, font-switch 3/3, font-picker 2/2, ui-size 8/8, ui-size-windows 7/7, clusters-appearance 1/1, settings-rows-of-windows 28/29.

The "pre-existing" failures, on unmodified origin/dev vs my head:

spec origin/dev my head verdict
core-screen "core screen themes…" (#rtt stays "··") fails fails dev-also-fails
core-screen "UI font choice persists…" (same #rtt) fails fails dev-also-fails
palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title" passes failed, now 11/11 mine (Appearance has 2 windows, "Themes"); fixed
clusters "window header actions are one pill" passes passes (clusters 42/42) not failing any more (dev fixed it)
toast-stack "newest in front" (new in dev) passes failed 2/4, now 25/25 mine (timing under the default look); fixed in the spec
settings-rows-of-windows "close-ups of the action group" (docs button of w-build-01 never appears) fails fails dev-also-fails

?look= — kept, and made safe. Reviewing it I found it was not: an edit after it chose the theme saved a snapshot with that theme selected, the first account sync could send the device copy (with the forced selection) up or replace the selection, and it was honoured on a real server, so someone else's link could change how a person's page looks. Now (71ee078ad): it is read only when the screen runs on the test double (mockMode); the page is a preview that reads nothing from the account and writes nothing to the device or the account, however it is edited; an id that is not a theme is ignored. Verified by a spec: with the person's own Frosted saved, a page opened with ?look=solid shows Solid, ignores the account, an edit and a theme click on it leave the device copy byte-identical and the account unchanged, and the next load without the parameter shows Frosted. It affects that page load only.

Owner questions are unchanged and listed in my previous comment (default blur cost, per-person settings store, fonts, Catppuccin rows, Ayu, Gruvbox licence, TASTE edits); the new facts for the blur question: the toast transition starts ~100 ms late and the touch/wheel gestures lost in software rendering under the default look.

**J206 — merged with origin/dev** — `themes-j206` head `757717854` (dev `54ca98177` merged in as `59f5c313d`; 127 commits). Not merged to dev. **Merge.** Textually clean (no conflict markers); the real conflicts were semantic, and I fixed them so both sides' intent stands: - *D188 critical-path budget (the big one).* Dev alone is 321,146 B gzip / 268,072 B brotli; with Themes the merge was 327,918 / 273,852, over the 327,680 / 273,408 caps. Ablation builds: the D329 data is 2.4 KB (schemes 2.0, fonts 0.4), Themes code ~4.3 KB. Compacting the tables saved ~70 B (hex digits are the floor), so the background maker and grain-tile maker (gradient recipes, colour maths) now load on demand after first paint (`paint.on-demand.ts`; `backgrounds.ts` keeps the ids on the critical path). Result: **326,859 gzip / 273,227 brotli**, i.e. **821 B / 181 B under the caps**. The caps are untouched. Dev has little headroom left for anyone else. - *Toast stack (J165).* `toast-stack.spec` passed 25/25 on dev and failed 2/4 on my head: a diagnostic printing the boxes over time shows stacked toasts reach their scale (0.95 / 0.90) in ~300 ms under both looks, but under the default look the transition's first frame comes ~100 ms after the toast is drawn, and the spec measured the instant it existed. It now waits for the stack's transitions to finish (`document.getAnimations`). 25/25 again. - *UI consistency (J195) / doc coverage / TASTE:* `ui-literals` +0/+0/+0, doc coverage ratchet PASS, TASTE merged without overlap. - Spec fixes from dev's own changes: palette-polish expects two Appearance rows (Themes, Layout) and the window name "Themes". Correction to my earlier report: the D329 list is **18** schemes (I wrote 17). **Gate** `scripts/verify fast`, compute01, head `d8478afd2` (later commits change only spec files; `tsc` clean on `757717854`): **FAST_EXIT=0**. Table: fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, static builds — all PASS. `scripts/verify quick` (base origin/dev) on `757717854`: scope guard, migration names, fmt, doc coverage ratchet, ui literals, tracer typecheck — all PASS. Static size (report only): x86_64 23,601,648 B (+1,183,392 vs gate baseline), aarch64 21,449,056 B (+995,776); includes dev's own deltas. **Specs on the production build** (compute01): themes 19/19 (with the three-size dark/light captures), palette-polish 11/11, toast-stack 25/25, clusters 42/42, settings-rows 7/7, settings-edges 4/4, machine-sections 7/7, font-switch 3/3, font-picker 2/2, ui-size 8/8, ui-size-windows 7/7, clusters-appearance 1/1, settings-rows-of-windows 28/29. **The "pre-existing" failures, on unmodified origin/dev vs my head:** | spec | origin/dev | my head | verdict | |---|---|---|---| | core-screen "core screen themes…" (`#rtt` stays "··") | fails | fails | **dev-also-fails** | | core-screen "UI font choice persists…" (same `#rtt`) | fails | fails | **dev-also-fails** | | palette-polish "no palette row renders without a title" | passes | failed, now 11/11 | **mine** (Appearance has 2 windows, "Themes"); fixed | | clusters "window header actions are one pill" | passes | passes (clusters 42/42) | **not failing any more** (dev fixed it) | | toast-stack "newest in front" (new in dev) | passes | failed 2/4, now 25/25 | **mine** (timing under the default look); fixed in the spec | | settings-rows-of-windows "close-ups of the action group" (docs button of `w-build-01` never appears) | fails | fails | **dev-also-fails** | **`?look=` — kept, and made safe.** Reviewing it I found it was not: an edit after it chose the theme saved a snapshot with that theme selected, the first account sync could send the device copy (with the forced selection) up or replace the selection, and it was honoured on a real server, so someone else's link could change how a person's page looks. Now (`71ee078ad`): it is read **only when the screen runs on the test double** (`mockMode`); the page is a *preview* that **reads nothing from the account and writes nothing to the device or the account, however it is edited**; an id that is not a theme is ignored. Verified by a spec: with the person's own Frosted saved, a page opened with `?look=solid` shows Solid, ignores the account, an edit and a theme click on it leave the device copy byte-identical and the account unchanged, and the next load without the parameter shows Frosted. It affects that page load only. Owner questions are unchanged and listed in my previous comment (default blur cost, per-person settings store, fonts, Catppuccin rows, Ayu, Gruvbox licence, TASTE edits); the new facts for the blur question: the toast transition starts ~100 ms late and the touch/wheel gestures lost in software rendering under the default look.
kayg commented 2026-11-05 07:44:52 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Blur cost on the Mac's GPU (kayg: "did you test it on infraternal-macos-01-std which has gpu acceleration?"). Measured now, under /tmp/mac-bench.lock (lockf, EXIT trap; both browsers and the driver quit, nothing left running).

Setup: production build of 757717854 (the tint, blur and grain code is unchanged since), served by the test double; the page is the canvas on scene 3 (Console view). scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs: real pointer input (a window dragged by its pill in a 100 px circle for 5 s), every animation frame recorded for 5 s idle and 5 s dragging, 3 runs per cell, medians shown (range of the dropped share in brackets where it varies). "Dropped" = an interval over 25 ms. Looks: Solid (100% tint, 0 blur), Tinted (the default, 75% / 25% = 6 px), tint only (Tinted with blur 0). 36 runs, 0 of which measured a different look than named (each run reads back the theme and blur the page shows).

Browser, GPU, viewport Windows (on screen) Look Idle p50 / p95 ms (dropped) Dragging p50 / p95 ms (dropped)
Safari 26.5.2, Apple GPU, 1440×848 4 (4, zoom 1) Solid 17 / 19 (0%) 17 / 20 (0%)
Tinted 17 / 19 (0%) 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3)
Tint only 17 / 20 (0%) 17 / 19 (0.3%, 0–0.9)
12 (7, zoom 0.65, live) Solid 17 / 20 (0%) 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3)
Tinted 17 / 20 (0%) 17 / 19 (0%)
Tint only 17 / 20 (0%) 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3)
Chrome 154, ANGLE Metal on the Apple paravirtual device, 1004×574 4 (4, zoom 1) Solid 18.7 / 34.7 (36%) 16.7 / 19.4 (0.9%)
Tinted 18.0 / 34.1 (31%) 16.7 / 19.0 (0.6%, 0–2.2)
Tint only 18.1 / 34.3 (29%) 16.7 / 19.5 (0.6%, 0–13.3)
12 (4, zoom 0.65, live) Solid 18.4 / 34.7 (32%) 16.6 / 19.1 (0.6%, 0–0.6)
Tinted 18.7 / 34.4 (34%) 16.7 / 19.2 (2.6%, 1.3–5.4)
Tint only 17.9 / 34.1 (32%) 16.7 / 19.1 (0%)

What it says:

  • On a real GPU the look does not cost frames. Safari is a locked 60 Hz in every cell (p50 17, p95 19–20 ms, 0–0.3% dropped), Solid and Tinted alike, with 4 or 12 windows, idle or dragging. In Chrome the dragging numbers are the same for the three looks within run-to-run noise (p50 16.6–16.7 ms; one tint-only run had 13% late frames, one Tinted run 5%, the others under 1%).
  • Chrome's idle p95 of 34 ms (about a third of frames late) is the same for Solid (the cheapest look) as for the others: in this VM Chrome alternates 17 and 33 ms when nothing moves. It is a property of Chrome on this paravirtual GPU, not of the look.
  • The earlier numbers on #323 (Tinted 27 to 64 ms a frame) were software rendering on a Linux VM with no GPU: the blur is expensive there and cheap on a GPU. They said nothing about the Mac, which is why they should not count as performance evidence. I did not change the defaults (D338).
  • Limits, stated plainly: the canvas shows only 4 windows at once at zoom 1 on this screen (12 windows fit as 7, or 4 in Chrome's smaller window, at the lowest zoom where windows are still drawn live; below about 0.6 the canvas draws thumbnails); Chrome's window is smaller than Safari's (the VM would not size it larger); the VM's GPU is paravirtual, not a bare M-series, so absolute figures on a phone or a laptop will differ.

Receipts: safari-final.jsonl and chrome-final.jsonl (every run, with the renderer string) are attached below; the script is scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs on themes-j206.

**Blur cost on the Mac's GPU** (kayg: "did you test it on infraternal-macos-01-std which has gpu acceleration?"). Measured now, under `/tmp/mac-bench.lock` (lockf, EXIT trap; both browsers and the driver quit, nothing left running). Setup: production build of `757717854` (the tint, blur and grain code is unchanged since), served by the test double; the page is the canvas on scene 3 (Console view). `scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs`: real pointer input (a window dragged by its pill in a 100 px circle for 5 s), every animation frame recorded for 5 s idle and 5 s dragging, 3 runs per cell, **medians shown** (range of the dropped share in brackets where it varies). "Dropped" = an interval over 25 ms. Looks: **Solid** (100% tint, 0 blur), **Tinted** (the default, 75% / 25% = 6 px), **tint only** (Tinted with blur 0). 36 runs, 0 of which measured a different look than named (each run reads back the theme and blur the page shows). | Browser, GPU, viewport | Windows (on screen) | Look | Idle p50 / p95 ms (dropped) | Dragging p50 / p95 ms (dropped) | |---|---|---|---|---| | Safari 26.5.2, Apple GPU, 1440×848 | 4 (4, zoom 1) | Solid | 17 / 19 (0%) | 17 / 20 (0%) | | | | Tinted | 17 / 19 (0%) | 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3) | | | | Tint only | 17 / 20 (0%) | 17 / 19 (0.3%, 0–0.9) | | | 12 (7, zoom 0.65, live) | Solid | 17 / 20 (0%) | 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3) | | | | Tinted | 17 / 20 (0%) | 17 / 19 (0%) | | | | Tint only | 17 / 20 (0%) | 17 / 19 (0%, 0–0.3) | | Chrome 154, ANGLE Metal on the Apple paravirtual device, 1004×574 | 4 (4, zoom 1) | Solid | 18.7 / 34.7 (36%) | 16.7 / 19.4 (0.9%) | | | | Tinted | 18.0 / 34.1 (31%) | 16.7 / 19.0 (0.6%, 0–2.2) | | | | Tint only | 18.1 / 34.3 (29%) | 16.7 / 19.5 (0.6%, 0–13.3) | | | 12 (4, zoom 0.65, live) | Solid | 18.4 / 34.7 (32%) | 16.6 / 19.1 (0.6%, 0–0.6) | | | | Tinted | 18.7 / 34.4 (34%) | 16.7 / 19.2 (2.6%, 1.3–5.4) | | | | Tint only | 17.9 / 34.1 (32%) | 16.7 / 19.1 (0%) | What it says: - **On a real GPU the look does not cost frames.** Safari is a locked 60 Hz in every cell (p50 17, p95 19–20 ms, 0–0.3% dropped), Solid and Tinted alike, with 4 or 12 windows, idle or dragging. In Chrome the dragging numbers are the same for the three looks within run-to-run noise (p50 16.6–16.7 ms; one tint-only run had 13% late frames, one Tinted run 5%, the others under 1%). - Chrome's *idle* p95 of 34 ms (about a third of frames late) is the same for **Solid** (the cheapest look) as for the others: in this VM Chrome alternates 17 and 33 ms when nothing moves. It is a property of Chrome on this paravirtual GPU, not of the look. - The earlier numbers on #323 (Tinted 27 to 64 ms a frame) were software rendering on a Linux VM with no GPU: the blur is expensive there and cheap on a GPU. They said nothing about the Mac, which is why they should not count as performance evidence. I did not change the defaults (D338). - Limits, stated plainly: the canvas shows only 4 windows at once at zoom 1 on this screen (12 windows fit as 7, or 4 in Chrome's smaller window, at the lowest zoom where windows are still drawn live; below about 0.6 the canvas draws thumbnails); Chrome's window is smaller than Safari's (the VM would not size it larger); the VM's GPU is paravirtual, not a bare M-series, so absolute figures on a phone or a laptop will differ. Receipts: `safari-final.jsonl` and `chrome-final.jsonl` (every run, with the renderer string) are attached below; the script is `scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs` on `themes-j206`.
safari-final-mac-frames.txt
6.8 KiB
chrome-final-mac-frames.txt
8.5 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-05 11:33:13 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J206 — kayg's answers built — themes-j206 head 006019753 (origin/dev merged again, 110 commits, clean). Not merged to dev.

1. Blur cost on the GPU: measured, table in the comment above (Safari and Chrome on the Mac VM, 36 runs, receipts attached). Result: on a real GPU Solid, Tinted and tint-only cost the same; the earlier numbers were Linux software rendering. Defaults unchanged.

2. Per-person settings → the canvas document (D178/D180). The real server does persist the canvas document (the Rust canvas plugin, revisioned, validated, server-ordered edits), so there was no gap to report and no new store:

  • The account's look (its themes, the selected one, the starting Colour/font/size) is an optional look field of the document, set by one new edit, look.set, that replaces it whole; the server orders edits, so the last one to arrive is every device's look. Only the camera stays per device. Server bounds: at most 16 distinct themes (a full list measured well under the 8 KiB edit limit, with a test), text ≤ 200, percentages 0–100, UI size 50–150, hex colours, 2–4 gradient stops, no unknown field. Which font/Colour/background an id names stays the client's business, so new schemes or fonts need no server change.
  • Client: the schema reads look with the same bounds, edits() emits look.set, the reducer applies it, the document sync saves it with the layout (a slider drag is one edit, sent when the person pauses; also on pagehide). The themes controller no longer talks to any server: it gives the canvas a bridge (snapshot / apply / onChange); the product applies the document's look on load and on every update from the store's subscription, so a look saved on one device arrives on the others the way a layout change does. An account with no look yet gets this page's, once.
  • D312 (the server is the only saved copy of layout): the browser keeps one small thing, a first-paint cache of the selected theme (tracer.look, like tracer.theme/tracer.font already are), so the first frame is right before the document arrives. It starts the page's store, is never sent anywhere on its own, and cannot seed another account's document. The test double's old /__mock/account/appearance is removed.
  • ?look= is unchanged in spirit: test double only, its bridge saves nothing and takes nothing.

3. Small items: approved ones done; Gruvbox MIT and the two TASTE lines stay as committed.

Commits (on top of the dev merge): look.set and look in the Rust plugin (+ rustfmt/clippy follow-ups) · client schema/edits/sync/bridge · specs · bench script · theme-limit module. Rust canvas plugin tests: 18 pass (3 new).

Gate scripts/verify fast, compute01, head 006019753: FAST_EXIT=0. Rust gate: fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, static builds: all PASS. Transfer: critical 326,989 B gzip / 273,010 B brotli (caps 327,680 / 273,408: 691 B and 398 B of headroom), deferred 58,175 / 61,440, every font family within budget. Static size (report only): x86_64 23,898,992 B (+1,480,736 vs the gate baseline), aarch64 21,706,384 B (+1,253,104); includes dev's own growth.
How the gate got green, honestly: run 1 failed fmt and clippy on my Rust (fixed); run 2 failed the critical-path budget (a mistake of mine: themes/model.ts imported a constant from the document decoder and pulled it into the first load; fixed with a one-line module, which also left more headroom than before); runs 3 and 4 each failed one test in a crate I did not touch (infraternal-plugin-ssh session_restaging_uses_one_compound_command: "Setup is already running on this host", passes 3/3 alone; infraternal-server ca_bootstrap::generated_remote_leaf_is_verifiable_after_cold_restart: a clock-edge race, certificate valid-from equals the verification second). After merging dev's gate-flake fixes the full gate passed.

Browser specs (production build, compute01): themes 21/21 with the three-size dark/light captures (incl. the new product-canvas tests: a theme chosen on one device is the look in another browser with nothing of ours, and survives a reload; a font picked in ⌘K reaches the document; a damaged first-paint cache is mended; ?look= saves nothing), settings-query-roundtrip, layout-current-view-removal, layout-revision-gap, layout-settlement-resize, account-card 17/17, account-summary 5/5, connection-pill, settings-rows 7/7, settings-edges, palette-polish, clusters 41/42 and settings-rows-of-windows 28/29 on the head before the last dev merge: the one in each is as before (settings-rows-of-windows "close-ups of the action group" fails on origin/dev too; clusters "motion rule" is a one-frame timing assertion that failed once under load and passed 3/3 on rerun, view jump 1.1–1.9 ms). After the last merge I reran themes + settings-query-roundtrip (17 pass) and the 502 canvas unit tests, not the whole browser set again.

Ready for the UI review.

**J206 — kayg's answers built** — `themes-j206` head `006019753` (origin/dev merged again, 110 commits, clean). Not merged to dev. **1. Blur cost on the GPU:** measured, table in the comment above (Safari and Chrome on the Mac VM, 36 runs, receipts attached). Result: on a real GPU Solid, Tinted and tint-only cost the same; the earlier numbers were Linux software rendering. Defaults unchanged. **2. Per-person settings → the canvas document (D178/D180).** The **real server does persist the canvas document** (the Rust canvas plugin, revisioned, validated, server-ordered edits), so there was no gap to report and no new store: - The account's look (its themes, the selected one, the starting Colour/font/size) is an optional `look` field of the document, set by one new edit, `look.set`, that replaces it whole; the server orders edits, so the last one to arrive is every device's look. Only the camera stays per device. Server bounds: at most 16 distinct themes (a full list measured well under the 8 KiB edit limit, with a test), text ≤ 200, percentages 0–100, UI size 50–150, hex colours, 2–4 gradient stops, no unknown field. Which font/Colour/background an id names stays the client's business, so new schemes or fonts need no server change. - Client: the schema reads `look` with the same bounds, `edits()` emits `look.set`, the reducer applies it, the document sync saves it with the layout (a slider drag is one edit, sent when the person pauses; also on `pagehide`). The themes controller no longer talks to any server: it gives the canvas a bridge (`snapshot` / `apply` / `onChange`); the product applies the document's look on load and on every update from the store's subscription, so a look saved on one device arrives on the others the way a layout change does. An account with no look yet gets this page's, once. - D312 (the server is the only saved copy of layout): the browser keeps one small thing, a first-paint cache of the *selected theme* (`tracer.look`, like `tracer.theme`/`tracer.font` already are), so the first frame is right before the document arrives. It starts the page's store, is never sent anywhere on its own, and cannot seed another account's document. The test double's old `/__mock/account/appearance` is removed. - `?look=` is unchanged in spirit: test double only, its bridge saves nothing and takes nothing. **3. Small items:** approved ones done; Gruvbox MIT and the two TASTE lines stay as committed. **Commits (on top of the dev merge):** `look.set` and `look` in the Rust plugin (+ rustfmt/clippy follow-ups) · client schema/edits/sync/bridge · specs · bench script · theme-limit module. Rust canvas plugin tests: 18 pass (3 new). **Gate** `scripts/verify fast`, compute01, head `006019753`: **FAST_EXIT=0**. Rust gate: fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, static builds: all PASS. Transfer: critical **326,989 B gzip / 273,010 B brotli** (caps 327,680 / 273,408: 691 B and 398 B of headroom), deferred 58,175 / 61,440, every font family within budget. Static size (report only): x86_64 23,898,992 B (+1,480,736 vs the gate baseline), aarch64 21,706,384 B (+1,253,104); includes dev's own growth. How the gate got green, honestly: run 1 failed fmt and clippy on my Rust (fixed); run 2 failed the critical-path budget (a mistake of mine: `themes/model.ts` imported a constant from the document decoder and pulled it into the first load; fixed with a one-line module, which also left more headroom than before); runs 3 and 4 each failed one test in a crate I did not touch (`infraternal-plugin-ssh` `session_restaging_uses_one_compound_command`: "Setup is already running on this host", passes 3/3 alone; `infraternal-server` `ca_bootstrap::generated_remote_leaf_is_verifiable_after_cold_restart`: a clock-edge race, certificate valid-from equals the verification second). After merging dev's gate-flake fixes the full gate passed. **Browser specs** (production build, compute01): themes 21/21 with the three-size dark/light captures (incl. the new product-canvas tests: a theme chosen on one device is the look in another browser with nothing of ours, and survives a reload; a font picked in ⌘K reaches the document; a damaged first-paint cache is mended; `?look=` saves nothing), settings-query-roundtrip, layout-current-view-removal, layout-revision-gap, layout-settlement-resize, account-card 17/17, account-summary 5/5, connection-pill, settings-rows 7/7, settings-edges, palette-polish, clusters 41/42 and settings-rows-of-windows 28/29 on the head before the last dev merge: the one in each is as before (settings-rows-of-windows "close-ups of the action group" fails on origin/dev too; clusters "motion rule" is a one-frame timing assertion that failed once under load and passed 3/3 on rerun, view jump 1.1–1.9 ms). After the last merge I reran themes + settings-query-roundtrip (17 pass) and the 502 canvas unit tests, not the whole browser set again. Ready for the UI review.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 12:27:43 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 implementation is starting on themes-sync-j304, based on themes-j206 at 00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4; I will merge current origin/dev (7b14fbb664cbfb9b2b9b8a56f724d924424accdb) into it. I am tracing J206's reports and inventorying browser-only appearance/canvas state now. I will post the D178/D180/D352 classification table here before product code changes.

J304 implementation is starting on `themes-sync-j304`, based on `themes-j206` at `00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4`; I will merge current `origin/dev` (`7b14fbb664cbfb9b2b9b8a56f724d924424accdb`) into it. I am tracing J206's reports and inventorying browser-only appearance/canvas state now. I will post the D178/D180/D352 classification table here before product code changes.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 12:44:22 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 appearance/canvas inventory (posted before product edits)

J206's reports show the change in status: #79147 and #79383 describe the test-double-only /__mock/account/appearance path; #79821 replaces that proposal with look.set on the revisioned canvas document. The branch has the SQLite canvas_heads account store and Rust validation/reduction for look.set, but J206's evidence does not include the requested two-client browser run against a real server build. I will verify that path directly and keep all sync on canvas.layout.

Browser value today What it stores D352 / D180 classification and destination
tracer.look; legacy tracer.theme, tracer.font, tracer.card, tracer.windows, tracer.background Selected theme and presets; each theme's Colors, font, tint/blur/grain, UI size, background and custom gradient; legacy choices are separate local values Per account. D352 makes the look part of the account canvas document. Migrate the newest composite/legacy value once through the existing document operation; after the server accepts it, remove legacy sources. Keep any first-paint cache derived from that account's document, never authoritative.
tracer.ui-size.v2, legacy tracer.ui-size UI density / scale Per account. It is already represented by each theme's uiSize; convert the legacy scale once and include it in the document look.
tracer.window-size.phone, tracer.window-size.desktop Default window width choices for phone and desktop layouts Per account. They affect the shared canvas arrangement under D178/D180; both platform choices belong in the same canvas document, not separate storage/sync.
tracer.extended-info Whether the Appearance details view shows extra machine facts Per account. This is an Appearance choice, not a device capability; move it into the same document path.
Canvas camera (current view, position and zoom) Runtime camera state; no localStorage or IndexedDB key found Per device, as D178 and D352 specify. It stays outside the document and must not change when a remote look arrives.
Font weights No separate saved weight setting exists; the selected font ID resolves to the registry's fixed weights Per account through the font ID in the document; no separate weight key or field.
infraternal.canvas.<account> A legacy local canvas document used by the existing one-time layout import; current canonical state uses the server's account document Per account. Reuse the existing initialize/apply and receipt flow; retire the local source after confirmation.
tracer.toolbar Optional local toolbar override Per device only where explicitly selected, per D178's toolbar follow-up. The account layout remains canonical; this override is not part of appearance.

No production IndexedDB appearance/canvas setting was found. tracer.shortcuts is a separate Settings → Shortcuts preference (D206 says per account), and tracer.ui-font is only the ?ui= preview override; neither is a canvas appearance value in this slice. The system reduced-motion preference is read from prefers-reduced-motion, with no stored app override.

Plan: keep J206's branch and merge current origin/dev into themes-sync-j304; extend the one canvas document for the remaining local Appearance values, write the real-server account-isolation and two-client regressions first, then implement only what those tests expose. No product code has changed yet.

## J304 appearance/canvas inventory (posted before product edits) J206's reports show the change in status: #79147 and #79383 describe the test-double-only `/__mock/account/appearance` path; #79821 replaces that proposal with `look.set` on the revisioned canvas document. The branch has the SQLite `canvas_heads` account store and Rust validation/reduction for `look.set`, but J206's evidence does not include the requested two-client browser run against a real server build. I will verify that path directly and keep all sync on `canvas.layout`. | Browser value today | What it stores | D352 / D180 classification and destination | |---|---|---| | `tracer.look`; legacy `tracer.theme`, `tracer.font`, `tracer.card`, `tracer.windows`, `tracer.background` | Selected theme and presets; each theme's Colors, font, tint/blur/grain, UI size, background and custom gradient; legacy choices are separate local values | **Per account.** D352 makes the look part of the account canvas document. Migrate the newest composite/legacy value once through the existing document operation; after the server accepts it, remove legacy sources. Keep any first-paint cache derived from that account's document, never authoritative. | | `tracer.ui-size.v2`, legacy `tracer.ui-size` | UI density / scale | **Per account.** It is already represented by each theme's `uiSize`; convert the legacy scale once and include it in the document look. | | `tracer.window-size.phone`, `tracer.window-size.desktop` | Default window width choices for phone and desktop layouts | **Per account.** They affect the shared canvas arrangement under D178/D180; both platform choices belong in the same canvas document, not separate storage/sync. | | `tracer.extended-info` | Whether the Appearance details view shows extra machine facts | **Per account.** This is an Appearance choice, not a device capability; move it into the same document path. | | Canvas camera (current view, position and zoom) | Runtime camera state; no localStorage or IndexedDB key found | **Per device**, as D178 and D352 specify. It stays outside the document and must not change when a remote look arrives. | | Font weights | No separate saved weight setting exists; the selected font ID resolves to the registry's fixed weights | **Per account through the font ID** in the document; no separate weight key or field. | | `infraternal.canvas.<account>` | A legacy local canvas document used by the existing one-time layout import; current canonical state uses the server's account document | **Per account.** Reuse the existing initialize/apply and receipt flow; retire the local source after confirmation. | | `tracer.toolbar` | Optional local toolbar override | **Per device only where explicitly selected**, per D178's toolbar follow-up. The account layout remains canonical; this override is not part of appearance. | No production IndexedDB appearance/canvas setting was found. `tracer.shortcuts` is a separate Settings → Shortcuts preference (D206 says per account), and `tracer.ui-font` is only the `?ui=` preview override; neither is a canvas appearance value in this slice. The system reduced-motion preference is read from `prefers-reduced-motion`, with no stored app override. Plan: keep J206's branch and merge current `origin/dev` into `themes-sync-j304`; extend the one canvas document for the remaining local Appearance values, write the real-server account-isolation and two-client regressions first, then implement only what those tests expose. No product code has changed yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 13:04:57 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Inventory addendum (before code changes)

Browser-held value Current storage D178/D180 classification and migration
Selected theme and theme list: colours, terminal font, UI size, background, tint, blur, grain and custom colours tracer.look first-paint cache Per account in document look; the browser copy is only a first-paint cache. Import once only when the server document has no look, then keep the server revision authoritative.
Older standalone colour and font choices tracer.theme, tracer.font Per-account canvas appearance; merge into an account with no server look, then retire the unscoped keys.
UI density tracer.ui-size.v2 and legacy tracer.ui-size Per account; folded into the selected theme UI size and removed as an unscoped source after server confirmation.
Default phone and desktop window widths tracer.window-size.phone, tracer.window-size.desktop Per account under D180; move into the same canvas document.
Extended machine details tracer.extended-info Per account; move into the same canvas document.
Older card/window transparency levels tracer.card, tracer.windows Legacy appearance values; fold into the one-time appearance import where valid, then retire. Current theme transparency is look.tint/blur/grain.
Toolbar layout override tracer.toolbar Per device only after the person explicitly chooses “Customise for this device”; the account toolbar layout already uses its existing account preference.
Camera centre and zoom in-memory canvas camera Per device by D352; never added to the document.
Reduced motion OS prefers-reduced-motion Device accessibility preference, read from the platform and not persisted by the canvas.
Font weights static font/design-system metadata No browser setting to sync; weights derive from the selected font and TASTE rules.
UI font query preview ?ui= writes tracer.ui-font Preview-only, not a canvas setting; I will stop persisting the URL override and remove its stale local key.

Theme edits and canvas layout continue through the one document subscription and look.set operation. Existing server revisions win over browser caches; the one-time import seeds an account document that has no look yet, and later concurrent look edits resolve in server revision order.

## Inventory addendum (before code changes) | Browser-held value | Current storage | D178/D180 classification and migration | |---|---|---| | Selected theme and theme list: colours, terminal font, UI size, background, tint, blur, grain and custom colours | `tracer.look` first-paint cache | Per account in document `look`; the browser copy is only a first-paint cache. Import once only when the server document has no look, then keep the server revision authoritative. | | Older standalone colour and font choices | `tracer.theme`, `tracer.font` | Per-account canvas appearance; merge into an account with no server look, then retire the unscoped keys. | | UI density | `tracer.ui-size.v2` and legacy `tracer.ui-size` | Per account; folded into the selected theme UI size and removed as an unscoped source after server confirmation. | | Default phone and desktop window widths | `tracer.window-size.phone`, `tracer.window-size.desktop` | Per account under D180; move into the same canvas document. | | Extended machine details | `tracer.extended-info` | Per account; move into the same canvas document. | | Older card/window transparency levels | `tracer.card`, `tracer.windows` | Legacy appearance values; fold into the one-time appearance import where valid, then retire. Current theme transparency is `look.tint/blur/grain`. | | Toolbar layout override | `tracer.toolbar` | Per device only after the person explicitly chooses “Customise for this device”; the account toolbar layout already uses its existing account preference. | | Camera centre and zoom | in-memory canvas camera | Per device by D352; never added to the document. | | Reduced motion | OS `prefers-reduced-motion` | Device accessibility preference, read from the platform and not persisted by the canvas. | | Font weights | static font/design-system metadata | No browser setting to sync; weights derive from the selected font and TASTE rules. | | UI font query preview | `?ui=` writes `tracer.ui-font` | Preview-only, not a canvas setting; I will stop persisting the URL override and remove its stale local key. | Theme edits and canvas layout continue through the one document subscription and `look.set` operation. Existing server revisions win over browser caches; the one-time import seeds an account document that has no look yet, and later concurrent look edits resolve in server revision order.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 13:31:52 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 inventory correction (still before production changes)

A production-source scan found two rows missing from the earlier table and clarified the UI-font row:

Browser-held value Current storage D352 / D180 classification
Standalone canvas background choice tracer.background Per account. It changes the shared canvas appearance; fold it into the account look when importing older settings, then remove the legacy key after the document confirms it.
UI font (mono / sans) tracer.ui-font, set by ?ui= and then read on later loads Per account. It changes the product appearance and is not device-bound. Import the saved value into the account look once, then retire the key; keep an explicit ?ui= choice as a page-only preview so it cannot silently write a second source.
Font weights No saved browser key; fixed by the selected font family in the registry Per account through the selected family. There is no independent weight preference to migrate.

The full appearance migration set is tracer.look, tracer.theme, tracer.font, tracer.background, tracer.card, tracer.windows, old UI-size keys, tracer.ui-font, tracer.window-size.phone, tracer.window-size.desktop, and tracer.extended-info. tracer.look remains only as a derived first-paint cache; the server document is authoritative after confirmation. The explicitly chosen tracer.toolbar device override stays per-device under D178. Camera state stays per-device under D178/D352; reduced motion is the OS preference, with no persisted app override. The account-scoped local canvas document is a cache/import source, not the sync authority. No production IndexedDB usage was found.

Branch choice is now realized: J304 stacks on themes-j206 at 006019753 and merges current origin/dev 48358a5 in 8ac3a1a14. The branch is pushed; production changes have not started.

## J304 inventory correction (still before production changes) A production-source scan found two rows missing from the earlier table and clarified the UI-font row: | Browser-held value | Current storage | D352 / D180 classification | |---|---|---| | Standalone canvas background choice | `tracer.background` | **Per account.** It changes the shared canvas appearance; fold it into the account look when importing older settings, then remove the legacy key after the document confirms it. | | UI font (`mono` / `sans`) | `tracer.ui-font`, set by `?ui=` and then read on later loads | **Per account.** It changes the product appearance and is not device-bound. Import the saved value into the account look once, then retire the key; keep an explicit `?ui=` choice as a page-only preview so it cannot silently write a second source. | | Font weights | No saved browser key; fixed by the selected font family in the registry | **Per account through the selected family.** There is no independent weight preference to migrate. | The full appearance migration set is `tracer.look`, `tracer.theme`, `tracer.font`, `tracer.background`, `tracer.card`, `tracer.windows`, old UI-size keys, `tracer.ui-font`, `tracer.window-size.phone`, `tracer.window-size.desktop`, and `tracer.extended-info`. `tracer.look` remains only as a derived first-paint cache; the server document is authoritative after confirmation. The explicitly chosen `tracer.toolbar` device override stays per-device under D178. Camera state stays per-device under D178/D352; reduced motion is the OS preference, with no persisted app override. The account-scoped local canvas document is a cache/import source, not the sync authority. No production IndexedDB usage was found. Branch choice is now realized: J304 stacks on `themes-j206` at `006019753` and merges current `origin/dev` `48358a5` in `8ac3a1a14`. The branch is pushed; production changes have not started.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 13:33:12 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 stack update: I created linked issue #400, kept the new branch on top of themes-j206 (base 00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4), merged current origin/dev 48358a5fababfdbbb50a233379956d576c3fc0a2 as 8ac3a1a14fc55488228b7dc4c92a5b80a3907d77, and pushed themes-sync-j304. This is a stack, not a rebase or a replacement of J206. I added the UI-font/background inventory correction above; the worktree still has only tests, no production implementation.

J304 stack update: I created linked issue #400, kept the new branch on top of `themes-j206` (base `00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4`), merged current `origin/dev` `48358a5fababfdbbb50a233379956d576c3fc0a2` as `8ac3a1a14fc55488228b7dc4c92a5b80a3907d77`, and pushed `themes-sync-j304`. This is a stack, not a rebase or a replacement of J206. I added the UI-font/background inventory correction above; the worktree still has only tests, no production implementation.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 13:36:40 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

One correction to the UI-font row after reading docs/design/TASTE.md §2: the product UI font is fixed to Geist Mono. ?ui= is a preview/test hook, not a saved account preference. The key tracer.ui-font still exists in localStorage because that hook currently writes it, so the migration must clear that stale preview key without copying it into the document; a query override may affect that page load only. The selected terminal font remains part of the account theme and syncs through look.

One correction to the UI-font row after reading `docs/design/TASTE.md` §2: the product UI font is fixed to Geist Mono. `?ui=` is a preview/test hook, not a saved account preference. The key `tracer.ui-font` still exists in localStorage because that hook currently writes it, so the migration must clear that stale preview key without copying it into the document; a query override may affect that page load only. The selected terminal font remains part of the account theme and syncs through `look`.
kayg commented 2026-11-06 15:15:06 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 source finding, before production changes:

apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.ts and themes/apply.ts show the current canvas appearance is the selected account theme, including tint, blur, grain, font, colour, UI size and theme background. In core-screen.ts, the older Background and Card/Window transparency palette rows are omitted when settingsView is enabled; applyLook maps the theme to those runtime surfaces.

I will treat tracer.card, tracer.windows and the old tracer.background mode as migration-only values, not add parallel fields to the document. A valid legacy background may seed the theme when there is no saved theme; otherwise the newest theme/cache or server look wins. I will remove these global keys only after a complete look is confirmed by the server. The missing current document fields are saved UI font, phone/desktop window sizes, and extended info; these will join the existing look in the same look.set flow.

J304 source finding, before production changes: `apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.ts` and `themes/apply.ts` show the current canvas appearance is the selected account theme, including tint, blur, grain, font, colour, UI size and theme background. In `core-screen.ts`, the older Background and Card/Window transparency palette rows are omitted when `settingsView` is enabled; `applyLook` maps the theme to those runtime surfaces. I will treat `tracer.card`, `tracer.windows` and the old `tracer.background` mode as migration-only values, not add parallel fields to the document. A valid legacy background may seed the theme when there is no saved theme; otherwise the newest theme/cache or server look wins. I will remove these global keys only after a complete look is confirmed by the server. The missing current document fields are saved UI font, phone/desktop window sizes, and extended info; these will join the existing look in the same `look.set` flow.
kayg commented 2026-11-07 11:59:58 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Inventory addendum: adjacent account preferences

A second source scan found two related Settings values outside the Appearance look:

Browser or test-double value Current source Decision classification
Shortcut rebindings tracer.shortcuts in packages/ui/src/shortcuts.ts Per account under D206, but a separate Shortcuts preference rather than a Themes/Appearance field. It remains outside this #400 appearance migration.
Account toolbar layout /__mock/account/toolbar GET/PUT in apps/tracer/src/core-screen.ts Per account under D177, with a separately chosen tracer.toolbar device override. The account layout still uses a mock-only endpoint; it is not currently carried by the real canvas document.

J304 remains scoped to the Appearance look (look.set) and does not add another sync path. The explicit toolbar override is device-bound; the toolbar account layout and shortcut rebindings are adjacent follow-up gaps.

## Inventory addendum: adjacent account preferences A second source scan found two related Settings values outside the Appearance look: | Browser or test-double value | Current source | Decision classification | |---|---|---| | Shortcut rebindings | `tracer.shortcuts` in `packages/ui/src/shortcuts.ts` | Per account under D206, but a separate Shortcuts preference rather than a Themes/Appearance field. It remains outside this #400 appearance migration. | | Account toolbar layout | `/__mock/account/toolbar` GET/PUT in `apps/tracer/src/core-screen.ts` | Per account under D177, with a separately chosen `tracer.toolbar` device override. The account layout still uses a mock-only endpoint; it is not currently carried by the real canvas document. | J304 remains scoped to the Appearance look (`look.set`) and does not add another sync path. The explicit toolbar override is device-bound; the toolbar account layout and shortcut rebindings are adjacent follow-up gaps.
kayg commented 2026-11-07 12:07:11 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Inventory note: client capability preference

infraternal.app-windows is also stored in localStorage. It is a client opt-in that gates whether this browser advertises desktop-video capability in its Hello (D200/D207/D208 and apps/tracer/src/canvas/appwin/flag.ts), so it is device-bound behavior rather than account appearance or canvas layout. No app-level reduced-motion override is stored; motion follows the OS prefers-reduced-motion preference. This remains outside the look document field.

## Inventory note: client capability preference `infraternal.app-windows` is also stored in localStorage. It is a client opt-in that gates whether this browser advertises desktop-video capability in its Hello (D200/D207/D208 and `apps/tracer/src/canvas/appwin/flag.ts`), so it is device-bound behavior rather than account appearance or canvas layout. No app-level reduced-motion override is stored; motion follows the OS `prefers-reduced-motion` preference. This remains outside the `look` document field.
kayg commented 2026-11-07 12:41:30 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Inventory correction from the source review: prefers-color-scheme is not stored in localStorage or IndexedDB. It is a per-device OS signal used for the auth screen and initial palette fallback; after the account canvas has a saved look, it must not replace that per-account palette (D352). The real-server spec now covers this new-client case.

Inventory correction from the source review: `prefers-color-scheme` is not stored in localStorage or IndexedDB. It is a per-device OS signal used for the auth screen and initial palette fallback; after the account canvas has a saved look, it must not replace that per-account palette (D352). The real-server spec now covers this new-client case.
kayg commented 2026-11-07 12:44:27 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Inventory addendum from the storage-key sweep: tracer.device-name in onboarding.ts is per-device identity metadata (D178 Settings → Devices), not a canvas appearance field. It stays local to this device. Production source has no IndexedDB appearance or canvas setting; the local canvas and tracer.look.account.* entries are account-scoped caches/import sources, with the server document authoritative.

Inventory addendum from the storage-key sweep: `tracer.device-name` in `onboarding.ts` is per-device identity metadata (D178 Settings → Devices), not a canvas appearance field. It stays local to this device. Production source has no IndexedDB appearance or canvas setting; the local canvas and `tracer.look.account.*` entries are account-scoped caches/import sources, with the server document authoritative.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 05:56:50 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J364 independent review of themes-j206 @ 0060197538: REQUEST CHANGES

Nobody had read this branch (J362's note 86341). I read the 24 own commits plus 2 dev merges (108 files) against origin/dev. Not merged, not pushed, not deployed. I did not run verify fast or verify quick (brief). The author's gate stands as the author's.

How I tested. dev-02 (aarch64), nix develop <worktree> -c cargo --version checked first, everything through build-slot. I built production bundles of the head and of the dev commit J206 last merged (8d3207cc8) for sizes. I ran a Playwright probe against the preview build served by the test double (the same build the author's themes.spec.ts uses). Chromium only: no WebKit, no real iPhone, no real-server run of this branch. Artifacts are on dev-02 under /home/claude/j364-logs/ (shots/, build.sh, pw.sh, j364_look.rs) and attached below.

Findings

P2-1. A look with a prototype key as its Colour breaks the Themes window for every device of the account (reproduced).
restore() in apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.ts accepts a Colour with colors in THEMES (three places: basics.colors, item.colors). THEMES is a plain object, so "toString", "constructor", "__proto__", "hasOwnProperty" all pass. The server only checks that colors is a non-empty string of at most 200 characters (model.rs theme()), so a client can store one in the account document, and the same restore() reads the first-paint cache.
Evidence: restore({... colors:"toString" ...}) returns it unchanged, and overlayMaterial(THEMES["toString"]) throws TypeError: undefined is not an object (evaluating 'hex.slice'). In the browser, with tracer.look holding Colour toString, __proto__ or constructor: pageerror TypeError twice, and the Themes window never renders its strip (cards: 0), while the rest of the canvas (33 windows) loads. Files: shots/poison-*.json, shots/poison-*.png.
Impact is bounded: it needs a client of that account, the rest of the app survives, and picking a Colour in ⌘K rewrites the selected theme's Colour, which should heal it (I did not run that heal).
Fix: Object.hasOwn(THEMES, x) (core-screen.ts:246 already does this) at the three sites; also check selected/theme ids and fontById. Add a model.test.ts case for "toString" and "__proto__". Optionally make the Rust side reject a colors/font/background value that is not a plausible id (lowercase, digits, -), so the server bounds the shape, not only the length.

P2-2. The contrast gate does not enforce 4.5:1 for all text. It enforces D80 as written, and D80 is lower for some text. (Owner decision, not mine.)
I ran theme-audit.test.ts (3/3 pass) and then measured every role in all 28 schemes (ink and paper included) with the gate's own contrast(): attached measure.out (script /tmp/j364-measure.ts on dev-02).

  • The gate holds fg 7, fg2 4.5, fg3 3, accent/ok 3, ANSI hues 4.5, and fg/fg2 on the card surface. That matches D80.
  • fg3 is below 4.5:1 on the background in 28 of 28 schemes (Paper 3.05, Ink 3.05, Latte 3.00, Tokyo 3.02, …). fg3 is real text: placeholders (.ui-chip-text::placeholder), the window session label, key hints (.ui-kv-hint). On the floating-card surface it is under 3:1 in 12 schemes (Tokyo 2.69, Gruvbox 2.67, Dracula 2.67, Frappé 2.69, …).
  • accent as text (prompt, log source, active toggles) is under 4.5 in 8 schemes (Dawn 3.03, Everforest Light 3.05, Ayu Light 3.05, Tokyo Day 3.11, …); ok in 3 (Paper 3.23, Latte 3.03, Dawn 3.14).
  • Not gated at all: danger/warn on the card surface (4 schemes at about 4.0–4.15: Solarized Dark, Everforest Dark, Flexoki Dark, Frappé); ANSI black/white and bright black/white (bright black is 1.69 on Nord, 1.91 on Tokyo, 2.46 on Mocha; shells use it for suggestions and comments); tint/blur/gradient presets (the gate checks the card surface at one level only; the gradient test checks fg at 4.5 over gradient stops, fg2 is not checked).
  • TASTE §2 says "Contrast is at least 4.5:1, measured over the real background", and D80 says fg3 ≥ 3. They disagree for fg3, accent and ok. I am not changing either. Owner question: is 3:1 for tertiary text, accent and ok intended (then TASTE needs the exception written down), or should the gate move to 4.5:1 (about 1–4 lightness steps per colour; the repair() already exists)? accent-fg on accent is under 4.5 in 8 schemes but it is only used for glyphs (tick, "+"), so 3:1 applies there.
  • My DOM-based text contrast probe was unreliable (CSS oklab() colours defeated my flattening), so I am not quoting its numbers.

P2-3. Phone touch targets in the Themes window are too small. At 393×852 the light/dark Colour circles (button.cl-colour-dot) are 18×18 px, 28 of them, two per row. TASTE: 44 px targets on touch. The colour-stop pickers are 36×36. The row's name button is the big target, but choosing the other version (light vs dark) needs the 18 px circle. Fix with padding/::before hit area, keeping the 18 px visual. Source: shots/phone-ink-measure.json.

P3-1. Notices. THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md abbreviates the MIT permission text with "..." and names Apache-2.0 (Tokyo Night Day, folke) without shipping the licence text (Apache §4(a) asks for a copy). The ten schemes that were already on dev (Rosé Pine, Nord, Dracula, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox dark, Catppuccin Latte/Mocha) are not listed, nor the eight older fonts' licences, though their OFL files sit next to them. Gruvbox light's copyright holder is "the Gruvbox authors"; its package.json names Pavel Pertsev (MIT confirmed there, no LICENSE file in the repo). Suggest a LICENSES/ folder with the full MIT and Apache text and the holders.

P3-2. Critical-path headroom is nearly gone. First-screen JS grows +5,529 B gzip / +4,771 B brotli (326,619 / 272,952 against caps 327,680 / 273,408): 1,061 B and 456 B of headroom. The budget is unchanged and passes, but J304 stacked on top and anything after it has almost nothing.

P3-3. Server-side look leaves ids unconstrained. selected need not name an existing theme, and font/colors/background are any 200-character string. The client mends them (apart from P2-1), so nothing is rendered unsafely, but an 8 KiB look can hold about 5 KiB of arbitrary text in a 48 KiB document. Bounded, not exploitable.

P3-4. The selected card's tick badge sits over the first glyph of the sample text ("git log", see shots/phone-ink-1-page.png). Desktop strip peeks a clipped third card at the window edge (intended carousel; TASTE row 149 says nothing at a window's side is clipped, so worth one owner look).

P3-5. The existing fuzz target canvas_layout_json never mentions look.

Checks that passed

  1. Licences. All 14 added families and all 17 added schemes verified against the upstream (GitHub licence API plus raw files). Every family has its licence file next to its faces; OFL bodies match the canonical text; Hack ships MIT plus the Bitstream Vera licence. Internal names in all 37 added woff2 files are replaced with IFR Web N (checked with fontTools: family, full name and PostScript name), which satisfies the Reserved Font Name rule (Intel, Monaspace, Bitstream/Vera). subset.sh pins a sha256 for every archive including Inconsolata. No Commons Clause, no non-free asset. sveltebits is not referenced.
  2. Names. Grepped all 3,163 added code lines: no "like X", "inspired by", "same as", "re-implemented". Product names appear only as scheme/font names, source credits and the Safari/Chrome drivers of scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs (integration). docs/ and notices are exempt.
  3. Rust validation is strict and bounded. shape() whitelists keys, numbers are finite integers in range, colours are exactly #rrggbb, stops 2–4, themes at most 16 and unique ids, text at most 200 UTF-16 units. The server caps a request at 8 KiB and the document at 48 KiB (canvas_store.rs). No CSS or URL can be stored in a colour field. I ran a mutation property test (j364_look.rs, throwaway, not committed): 300,000 mutated looks, 6,603 accepted, every accepted one inside the ranges, with 11 keys per theme, hex colours and at most 16 themes. The 18 canvas lib tests pass (rs2-run.log). The client renders names with textContent and ids with dataset: no HTML injection.
  4. Fonts are lazy. Cold canvas fetched only maple-mono-nf/roman (46,432 B). Opening the Themes window added Maple italic (53,444 B). Scrolling and hovering all 23 font rows fetched nothing else. Only Maple is preloaded in index.html. shots/fonts-net.json.
  5. UI against TASTE, from screenshots. 1440×900 and 393×852 (DPR 3), ink and paper, with Tinted, Frosted and an added theme: left edges line up (headings, strip, rows at the same x), no horizontal page overflow, no page errors, flat controls, no rings on mouse use. Findings above are P2-3 and P3-4 only.

Sizes (production build, branch vs the dev commit it merged)

raw gzip brotli
critical JS +12,328 +5,529 +4,771
deferred JS +1,261 +541 +485
on-demand JS +15,454 +6,550 +5,757
ui.css +8,429 +1,821 +1,501
clusters.css +9,256 +2,360 +2,069
fonts (37 new woff2, identity) +1,180,733 B not compressed not compressed

The web payload is a directory next to the binary (nix/package.nix, web_assets.rs ServeDir), so fonts add 0 B to the binary. The Rust change is about 180 lines of validation; I did not measure the static size delta (that is the gate's row). Fonts cost nothing on first paint for someone who does not pick them; they add about 1.13 MiB to the installed payload.

Asset and licence table

Asset Upstream (version) Licence File shipped
Iosevka be5invis/Iosevka v34.9.1 OFL-1.1 fonts/iosevka/OFL.txt
Victor Mono rubjo/victor-mono v1.5.6 OFL-1.1 fonts/victor-mono/OFL.txt
Recursive Mono arrowtype/recursive v1.085 OFL-1.1 fonts/recursive-mono/OFL.txt
Martian Mono evilmartians/mono v1.1.0 OFL-1.1 fonts/martian-mono/OFL.txt
Intel One Mono intel/intel-one-mono V1.4.0 OFL-1.1 fonts/intel-one-mono/OFL.txt
Fantasque Sans Mono belluzj/fantasque-sans v1.8.0 OFL-1.1 fonts/fantasque-sans-mono/OFL.txt
Hack source-foundry/Hack v3.003 MIT + Bitstream Vera fonts/hack/LICENSE.txt
Inconsolata googlefonts/Inconsolata v3.000 OFL-1.1 fonts/inconsolata/OFL.txt
0xProto 0xType/0xProto 2.502 OFL-1.1 fonts/0xproto/OFL.txt
Lilex mishamyrt/Lilex 2.630 OFL-1.1 fonts/lilex/OFL.txt
Monaspace Argon, Xenon, Radon, Krypton githubnext/monaspace v1.400 OFL-1.1 one OFL.txt each
Solarized Light/Dark altercation/solarized MIT notice table only
Everforest Light/Dark sainnhe/everforest MIT notice table only
Kanagawa Lotus/Wave rebelot/kanagawa.nvim MIT notice table only
Ayu Light/Dark ayu-theme/ayu-colors MIT notice table only
GitHub Light/Dark primer/primitives MIT notice table only
Flexoki Light/Dark kepano/flexoki MIT notice table only
Gruvbox Light morhetz/gruvbox MIT per package.json (no LICENSE file) notice table only
Tokyo Night Day folke/tokyonight.nvim Apache-2.0 (AGPL-compatible) notice table only, text not shipped (P3-1)
Catppuccin Frappé, Macchiato catppuccin/catppuccin MIT notice table only
Light Owl, Night Owl sdras/night-owl-vscode-theme MIT notice table only

Scheme names that are upstream project names (listed for the owner): Solarized, Everforest, Kanagawa, Ayu, GitHub, Flexoki, Gruvbox, Tokyo Night, Catppuccin, Night Owl / Light Owl, plus the pre-existing Rosé Pine, Nord, Dracula. All are used as plain names of bundled palettes, none as a comparison.

Verdict

REQUEST CHANGES for P2-1 (small, one-line fix plus test) and P2-3 (hit areas). P2-2 needs the owner's answer on D80 vs TASTE before anyone changes the gate. P3s can follow. Nothing here blocks reading the rest of the stack: licences, names, lazy fonts and Rust validation are sound.

## J364 independent review of `themes-j206` @ 00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4: REQUEST CHANGES Nobody had read this branch (J362's note 86341). I read the 24 own commits plus 2 dev merges (108 files) against origin/dev. Not merged, not pushed, not deployed. I did not run `verify fast` or `verify quick` (brief). The author's gate stands as the author's. **How I tested.** dev-02 (aarch64), `nix develop <worktree> -c cargo --version` checked first, everything through `build-slot`. I built production bundles of the head and of the dev commit J206 last merged (`8d3207cc8`) for sizes. I ran a Playwright probe against the preview build served by the test double (the same build the author's `themes.spec.ts` uses). Chromium only: no WebKit, no real iPhone, no real-server run of this branch. Artifacts are on dev-02 under `/home/claude/j364-logs/` (`shots/`, `build.sh`, `pw.sh`, `j364_look.rs`) and attached below. ### Findings **P2-1. A `look` with a prototype key as its Colour breaks the Themes window for every device of the account (reproduced).** `restore()` in `apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.ts` accepts a Colour with `colors in THEMES` (three places: `basics.colors`, `item.colors`). `THEMES` is a plain object, so `"toString"`, `"constructor"`, `"__proto__"`, `"hasOwnProperty"` all pass. The server only checks that `colors` is a non-empty string of at most 200 characters (`model.rs` `theme()`), so a client can store one in the account document, and the same `restore()` reads the first-paint cache. Evidence: `restore({... colors:"toString" ...})` returns it unchanged, and `overlayMaterial(THEMES["toString"])` throws `TypeError: undefined is not an object (evaluating 'hex.slice')`. In the browser, with `tracer.look` holding Colour `toString`, `__proto__` or `constructor`: `pageerror` TypeError twice, and the Themes window never renders its strip (`cards: 0`), while the rest of the canvas (33 windows) loads. Files: `shots/poison-*.json`, `shots/poison-*.png`. Impact is bounded: it needs a client of that account, the rest of the app survives, and picking a Colour in ⌘K rewrites the selected theme's Colour, which should heal it (I did not run that heal). Fix: `Object.hasOwn(THEMES, x)` (`core-screen.ts:246` already does this) at the three sites; also check `selected`/theme ids and `fontById`. Add a `model.test.ts` case for `"toString"` and `"__proto__"`. Optionally make the Rust side reject a `colors`/`font`/`background` value that is not a plausible id (lowercase, digits, `-`), so the server bounds the shape, not only the length. **P2-2. The contrast gate does not enforce 4.5:1 for all text. It enforces D80 as written, and D80 is lower for some text.** (Owner decision, not mine.) I ran `theme-audit.test.ts` (3/3 pass) and then measured every role in all 28 schemes (ink and paper included) with the gate's own `contrast()`: attached `measure.out` (script `/tmp/j364-measure.ts` on dev-02). - The gate holds `fg` 7, `fg2` 4.5, `fg3` 3, `accent`/`ok` 3, ANSI hues 4.5, and `fg`/`fg2` on the card surface. That matches D80. - `fg3` is below 4.5:1 on the background in **28 of 28** schemes (Paper 3.05, Ink 3.05, Latte 3.00, Tokyo 3.02, …). `fg3` is real text: placeholders (`.ui-chip-text::placeholder`), the window session label, key hints (`.ui-kv-hint`). On the floating-card surface it is under 3:1 in 12 schemes (Tokyo 2.69, Gruvbox 2.67, Dracula 2.67, Frappé 2.69, …). - `accent` as text (prompt, log source, active toggles) is under 4.5 in 8 schemes (Dawn 3.03, Everforest Light 3.05, Ayu Light 3.05, Tokyo Day 3.11, …); `ok` in 3 (Paper 3.23, Latte 3.03, Dawn 3.14). - Not gated at all: `danger`/`warn` on the card surface (4 schemes at about 4.0–4.15: Solarized Dark, Everforest Dark, Flexoki Dark, Frappé); ANSI black/white and bright black/white (bright black is 1.69 on Nord, 1.91 on Tokyo, 2.46 on Mocha; shells use it for suggestions and comments); tint/blur/gradient presets (the gate checks the card surface at one level only; the gradient test checks `fg` at 4.5 over gradient stops, `fg2` is not checked). - TASTE §2 says "Contrast is at least 4.5:1, measured over the real background", and D80 says fg3 ≥ 3. They disagree for `fg3`, `accent` and `ok`. I am not changing either. **Owner question:** is 3:1 for tertiary text, accent and `ok` intended (then TASTE needs the exception written down), or should the gate move to 4.5:1 (about 1–4 lightness steps per colour; the `repair()` already exists)? `accent-fg` on accent is under 4.5 in 8 schemes but it is only used for glyphs (tick, "+"), so 3:1 applies there. - My DOM-based text contrast probe was unreliable (CSS `oklab()` colours defeated my flattening), so I am not quoting its numbers. **P2-3. Phone touch targets in the Themes window are too small.** At 393×852 the light/dark Colour circles (`button.cl-colour-dot`) are 18×18 px, 28 of them, two per row. TASTE: 44 px targets on touch. The colour-stop pickers are 36×36. The row's name button is the big target, but choosing the *other* version (light vs dark) needs the 18 px circle. Fix with padding/`::before` hit area, keeping the 18 px visual. Source: `shots/phone-ink-measure.json`. **P3-1. Notices.** `THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md` abbreviates the MIT permission text with "..." and names Apache-2.0 (Tokyo Night Day, folke) without shipping the licence text (Apache §4(a) asks for a copy). The ten schemes that were already on dev (Rosé Pine, Nord, Dracula, Tokyo Night, Gruvbox dark, Catppuccin Latte/Mocha) are not listed, nor the eight older fonts' licences, though their OFL files sit next to them. Gruvbox light's copyright holder is "the Gruvbox authors"; its `package.json` names Pavel Pertsev (MIT confirmed there, no LICENSE file in the repo). Suggest a `LICENSES/` folder with the full MIT and Apache text and the holders. **P3-2. Critical-path headroom is nearly gone.** First-screen JS grows +5,529 B gzip / +4,771 B brotli (326,619 / 272,952 against caps 327,680 / 273,408): 1,061 B and 456 B of headroom. The budget is unchanged and passes, but J304 stacked on top and anything after it has almost nothing. **P3-3. Server-side `look` leaves ids unconstrained.** `selected` need not name an existing theme, and `font`/`colors`/`background` are any 200-character string. The client mends them (apart from P2-1), so nothing is rendered unsafely, but an 8 KiB `look` can hold about 5 KiB of arbitrary text in a 48 KiB document. Bounded, not exploitable. **P3-4.** The selected card's tick badge sits over the first glyph of the sample text ("git log", see `shots/phone-ink-1-page.png`). Desktop strip peeks a clipped third card at the window edge (intended carousel; TASTE row 149 says nothing at a window's side is clipped, so worth one owner look). **P3-5.** The existing fuzz target `canvas_layout_json` never mentions `look`. ### Checks that passed 1. **Licences.** All 14 added families and all 17 added schemes verified against the upstream (GitHub licence API plus raw files). Every family has its licence file next to its faces; OFL bodies match the canonical text; Hack ships MIT plus the Bitstream Vera licence. Internal names in all 37 added woff2 files are replaced with `IFR Web N` (checked with fontTools: family, full name and PostScript name), which satisfies the Reserved Font Name rule (Intel, Monaspace, Bitstream/Vera). `subset.sh` pins a sha256 for every archive including Inconsolata. No Commons Clause, no non-free asset. `sveltebits` is not referenced. 2. **Names.** Grepped all 3,163 added code lines: no "like X", "inspired by", "same as", "re-implemented". Product names appear only as scheme/font names, source credits and the Safari/Chrome drivers of `scripts/bench-blur-mac.mjs` (integration). `docs/` and notices are exempt. 3. **Rust validation is strict and bounded.** `shape()` whitelists keys, numbers are finite integers in range, colours are exactly `#rrggbb`, stops 2–4, themes at most 16 and unique ids, text at most 200 UTF-16 units. The server caps a request at 8 KiB and the document at 48 KiB (`canvas_store.rs`). No CSS or URL can be stored in a colour field. I ran a mutation property test (`j364_look.rs`, throwaway, not committed): 300,000 mutated looks, 6,603 accepted, every accepted one inside the ranges, with 11 keys per theme, hex colours and at most 16 themes. The 18 canvas lib tests pass (`rs2-run.log`). The client renders names with `textContent` and ids with `dataset`: no HTML injection. 4. **Fonts are lazy.** Cold canvas fetched only `maple-mono-nf/roman` (46,432 B). Opening the Themes window added Maple italic (53,444 B). Scrolling and hovering all 23 font rows fetched nothing else. Only Maple is preloaded in `index.html`. `shots/fonts-net.json`. 5. **UI against TASTE, from screenshots.** 1440×900 and 393×852 (DPR 3), ink and paper, with Tinted, Frosted and an added theme: left edges line up (headings, strip, rows at the same x), no horizontal page overflow, no page errors, flat controls, no rings on mouse use. Findings above are P2-3 and P3-4 only. ### Sizes (production build, branch vs the dev commit it merged) | | raw | gzip | brotli | |---|---|---|---| | critical JS | +12,328 | +5,529 | +4,771 | | deferred JS | +1,261 | +541 | +485 | | on-demand JS | +15,454 | +6,550 | +5,757 | | `ui.css` | +8,429 | +1,821 | +1,501 | | `clusters.css` | +9,256 | +2,360 | +2,069 | | fonts (37 new woff2, identity) | +1,180,733 B | not compressed | not compressed | The web payload is a directory next to the binary (`nix/package.nix`, `web_assets.rs` `ServeDir`), so fonts add **0 B to the binary**. The Rust change is about 180 lines of validation; I did not measure the static size delta (that is the gate's row). Fonts cost nothing on first paint for someone who does not pick them; they add about 1.13 MiB to the installed payload. ### Asset and licence table | Asset | Upstream (version) | Licence | File shipped | |---|---|---|---| | Iosevka | be5invis/Iosevka v34.9.1 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/iosevka/OFL.txt` | | Victor Mono | rubjo/victor-mono v1.5.6 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/victor-mono/OFL.txt` | | Recursive Mono | arrowtype/recursive v1.085 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/recursive-mono/OFL.txt` | | Martian Mono | evilmartians/mono v1.1.0 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/martian-mono/OFL.txt` | | Intel One Mono | intel/intel-one-mono V1.4.0 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/intel-one-mono/OFL.txt` | | Fantasque Sans Mono | belluzj/fantasque-sans v1.8.0 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/fantasque-sans-mono/OFL.txt` | | Hack | source-foundry/Hack v3.003 | MIT + Bitstream Vera | `fonts/hack/LICENSE.txt` | | Inconsolata | googlefonts/Inconsolata v3.000 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/inconsolata/OFL.txt` | | 0xProto | 0xType/0xProto 2.502 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/0xproto/OFL.txt` | | Lilex | mishamyrt/Lilex 2.630 | OFL-1.1 | `fonts/lilex/OFL.txt` | | Monaspace Argon, Xenon, Radon, Krypton | githubnext/monaspace v1.400 | OFL-1.1 | one `OFL.txt` each | | Solarized Light/Dark | altercation/solarized | MIT | notice table only | | Everforest Light/Dark | sainnhe/everforest | MIT | notice table only | | Kanagawa Lotus/Wave | rebelot/kanagawa.nvim | MIT | notice table only | | Ayu Light/Dark | ayu-theme/ayu-colors | MIT | notice table only | | GitHub Light/Dark | primer/primitives | MIT | notice table only | | Flexoki Light/Dark | kepano/flexoki | MIT | notice table only | | Gruvbox Light | morhetz/gruvbox | MIT per `package.json` (no LICENSE file) | notice table only | | Tokyo Night Day | folke/tokyonight.nvim | Apache-2.0 (AGPL-compatible) | notice table only, text not shipped (P3-1) | | Catppuccin Frappé, Macchiato | catppuccin/catppuccin | MIT | notice table only | | Light Owl, Night Owl | sdras/night-owl-vscode-theme | MIT | notice table only | Scheme names that are upstream project names (listed for the owner): Solarized, Everforest, Kanagawa, Ayu, GitHub, Flexoki, Gruvbox, Tokyo Night, Catppuccin, Night Owl / Light Owl, plus the pre-existing Rosé Pine, Nord, Dracula. All are used as plain names of bundled palettes, none as a comparison. ### Verdict REQUEST CHANGES for P2-1 (small, one-line fix plus test) and P2-3 (hit areas). P2-2 needs the owner's answer on D80 vs TASTE before anyone changes the gate. P3s can follow. Nothing here blocks reading the rest of the stack: licences, names, lazy fonts and Rust validation are sound.
desktop-ink-2-window.png
90 KiB
desktop-paper-4-added.png
91 KiB
phone-ink-1-page.png
620 KiB
phone-paper-1-page.png
600 KiB
poison-toString.png
81 KiB
poison-toString.json
256 B
fonts-net.json
586 B
measure.txt
2.6 KiB
desktop-ink-2-window.png desktop-paper-4-added.png phone-ink-1-page.png phone-paper-1-page.png poison-toString.png
kayg commented 2026-11-08 11:50:27 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 is continuing the reviewed theme stack on themes-sync-j304 from acc7eb5cf9710fe179fedd195dd81c20237a76c6, with J206 00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4 as its theme layer and owner base f6f62a8759897a47f24031dd743bdedd062334f7. The remaining review findings and D365/D366 work are tracked on linked follow-up #400; I’ve started there and will post the finished head and evidence here as well.

J304 is continuing the reviewed theme stack on `themes-sync-j304` from `acc7eb5cf9710fe179fedd195dd81c20237a76c6`, with J206 `00601975387497a0dfa4c90126f6d94b645c70e4` as its theme layer and owner base `f6f62a8759897a47f24031dd743bdedd062334f7`. The remaining review findings and D365/D366 work are tracked on linked follow-up #400; I’ve started there and will post the finished head and evidence here as well.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 12:43:09 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 resuming the themes stack at 33a5a62489, based on dev f6f62a875. I will finish the requested known-ID validation, D365 contrast pass, D366 account ui-font sync, mobile touch targets, license notices, sample badge placement and look fuzz coverage. The existing branch already contains the two earlier fixes for remote palette preservation and the TASTE UI-size line.

J304 resuming the themes stack at 33a5a6248917faf4, based on dev f6f62a875. I will finish the requested known-ID validation, D365 contrast pass, D366 account ui-font sync, mobile touch targets, license notices, sample badge placement and look fuzz coverage. The existing branch already contains the two earlier fixes for remote palette preservation and the TASTE UI-size line.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 12:49:47 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

P2-1 pushed as 5a84fb1a4. The three pre-existing scheme membership lookups already use Object.hasOwn; I also replaced both remaining model membership checks and added prototype-name model/ Themes-window regressions. Rust document validation now rejects unknown scheme, font and background ids and requires selected to exist in themes. Red/green logs are listed on #400.

P2-1 pushed as 5a84fb1a4. The three pre-existing scheme membership lookups already use Object.hasOwn; I also replaced both remaining model membership checks and added prototype-name model/ Themes-window regressions. Rust document validation now rejects unknown scheme, font and background ids and requires selected to exist in themes. Red/green logs are listed on #400.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 13:07:17 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 expanded red on dev-02 is in ~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d365-all.log: 132 failed colour/surface assertions across the 28 schemes, including fg3, status colours on cards, and ANSI black/white text slots. Palette repair values (lightness-only, darker on light themes and lighter on dark themes) are in d365-palette-values.jsonl; Ink/Paper swatches will follow after the gate passes.

D365 expanded red on dev-02 is in ~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d365-all.log: 132 failed colour/surface assertions across the 28 schemes, including fg3, status colours on cards, and ANSI black/white text slots. Palette repair values (lightness-only, darker on light themes and lighter on dark themes) are in d365-palette-values.jsonl; Ink/Paper swatches will follow after the gate passes.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 13:30:28 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 is committed and pushed on themes-sync-j304 at 72a94fa25.

  • Red: the expanded audit found 132 failing colour/surface assertions before palette repair; see ~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d365-all.log on dev-02.
  • Green: bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts reports 4 pass, 0 fail, 733 assertions; see green-d365.log on dev-02.
  • The palette generator now emits the final ANSI tables that the audit checked, and its output matches the checked-in D329 scheme declarations.
  • The attached PNG shows Ink and Paper before/after swatches and the canvas/card ratios. The full ratios are in d365-ratios.log on dev-02.
D365 is committed and pushed on `themes-sync-j304` at `72a94fa25`. - Red: the expanded audit found 132 failing colour/surface assertions before palette repair; see `~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d365-all.log` on dev-02. - Green: `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` reports 4 pass, 0 fail, 733 assertions; see `green-d365.log` on dev-02. - The palette generator now emits the final ANSI tables that the audit checked, and its output matches the checked-in D329 scheme declarations. - The attached PNG shows Ink and Paper before/after swatches and the canvas/card ratios. The full ratios are in `d365-ratios.log` on dev-02.
D365-Ink-Paper-swatches.png
191 KiB
D365-Ink-Paper-swatches.png
kayg commented 2026-11-08 14:02:03 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D366 red-first evidence on themes-sync-j304 at base 72a94fa25: the browser schema rejects uiFont: "sans", the canvas server rejects the field, and the real-server two-client spec times out waiting for the account look to carry uiFont; legacy migration also leaves it undefined. Logs: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d366-schema.log, red-d366-server.log, and red-d366-real.log. Implementing uiFont in the existing account look now; older v1 documents remain readable.

D366 red-first evidence on `themes-sync-j304` at base `72a94fa25`: the browser schema rejects `uiFont: "sans"`, the canvas server rejects the field, and the real-server two-client spec times out waiting for the account look to carry `uiFont`; legacy migration also leaves it undefined. Logs: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-d366-schema.log`, `red-d366-server.log`, and `red-d366-real.log`. Implementing `uiFont` in the existing account look now; older v1 documents remain readable.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 14:28:31 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Continuing the remaining J304 items on themes-sync-j304, base f6f62a875, current head af6a87a03. Plan: add red-first checks for 44 px Colour-circle targets and the selected-card tick/sample overlap, implement each in its own commit; ship full MIT and Apache-2.0 texts and update notices for older schemes/fonts; exercise the account look in the canvas fuzz target; measure critical JS Brotli; then run the real-server spec and verify quick on dev-02. Its build slot is occupied now; no run is queued. Estimate: 3–5 hours including the cold build and slot wait. I’ll post evidence as each slice lands.

Continuing the remaining J304 items on `themes-sync-j304`, base `f6f62a875`, current head `af6a87a03`. Plan: add red-first checks for 44 px Colour-circle targets and the selected-card tick/sample overlap, implement each in its own commit; ship full MIT and Apache-2.0 texts and update notices for older schemes/fonts; exercise the account `look` in the canvas fuzz target; measure critical JS Brotli; then run the real-server spec and `verify quick` on dev-02. Its build slot is occupied now; no run is queued. Estimate: 3–5 hours including the cold build and slot wait. I’ll post evidence as each slice lands.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 14:51:12 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding, red-first on dev-02: red-remaining-ui-notices.log records three failures against the production build. The selected theme tick intersects the rendered sample line git log --oneline -12 | head; coarse-pointer Colour buttons measure 18×18 px; and /licenses/MIT.txt returns 404. I’ll reserve space above the card for the tick, make the Colour button itself a 44×44 px hit target while retaining the small visual dot, and copy the complete notices into the production web root. Evidence: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-remaining-ui-notices.log.

J304 finding, red-first on dev-02: `red-remaining-ui-notices.log` records three failures against the production build. The selected theme tick intersects the rendered sample line `git log --oneline -12 | head`; coarse-pointer Colour buttons measure 18×18 px; and `/licenses/MIT.txt` returns 404. I’ll reserve space above the card for the tick, make the Colour button itself a 44×44 px hit target while retaining the small visual dot, and copy the complete notices into the production web root. Evidence: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-remaining-ui-notices.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 14:57:16 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Touch-target slice is committed and pushed as b03b1f77a. Green production-build browser check: 1 passed; every Colour radio on the 393×852 coarse-pointer viewport measures at least 44×44 CSS px, and each label/target centre line stays within 0.5 px. Evidence: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/green-colour-touch-targets.log on dev-02.

Touch-target slice is committed and pushed as `b03b1f77a`. Green production-build browser check: 1 passed; every Colour radio on the 393×852 coarse-pointer viewport measures at least 44×44 CSS px, and each label/target centre line stays within 0.5 px. Evidence: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/green-colour-touch-targets.log` on dev-02.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 15:07:49 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Progress on themes-sync-j304 at b03b1f77a, based on dev f6f62a875.

Finding: the build bundles a separate Nerd Symbols face for prompt glyphs, and the notices did not identify it. apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh says it is extracted from Maple Mono NF v7.9, so I am adding a notice entry pointing to the existing Maple OFL text and a production-route assertion. The dev-02 slot is occupied by another job's quick gate; no run is queued yet.

Progress on `themes-sync-j304` at `b03b1f77a`, based on dev `f6f62a875`. Finding: the build bundles a separate `Nerd Symbols` face for prompt glyphs, and the notices did not identify it. `apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh` says it is extracted from Maple Mono NF v7.9, so I am adding a notice entry pointing to the existing Maple OFL text and a production-route assertion. The dev-02 slot is occupied by another job's quick gate; no run is queued yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 15:14:26 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Progress on themes-sync-j304 at b03b1f77a.

The notices production test exposed two specific gaps. red-apache-appendix.log shows that the served Apache-2.0 text ended at “END OF TERMS AND CONDITIONS”; the standard Appendix was absent. The file now matches the complete upstream 202-line, 11,358-byte text. red-nerd-symbols-notice.log then showed Nerd Symbols missing from the shipped font notices; apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh identifies it as prompt glyphs extracted from Maple Mono NF v7.9. I have added its table entry to the Maple OFL notice. Next: green production tests, separate commits, fuzz build, real-server spec and verify quick on dev-02.

Progress on `themes-sync-j304` at `b03b1f77a`. The notices production test exposed two specific gaps. `red-apache-appendix.log` shows that the served Apache-2.0 text ended at “END OF TERMS AND CONDITIONS”; the standard Appendix was absent. The file now matches the complete upstream 202-line, 11,358-byte text. `red-nerd-symbols-notice.log` then showed `Nerd Symbols` missing from the shipped font notices; `apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh` identifies it as prompt glyphs extracted from Maple Mono NF v7.9. I have added its table entry to the Maple OFL notice. Next: green production tests, separate commits, fuzz build, real-server spec and `verify quick` on dev-02.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 15:47:57 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Resuming themes-sync-j304 from head b34bf0500, based on origin/dev at 77b1255cb. The previous production bundle evidence is ~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/final-transfer-budget.log on dev-02: critical JS measures 275,803 B Brotli / 329,656 B gzip against 273,408 B / 327,680 B caps. I’m tracing the bundler graph to identify a non-first-paint split, then I’ll run the real-server appearance spec and verify quick on dev-02. Existing swatch screenshots and the implementation commits remain on this branch.

Resuming `themes-sync-j304` from head `b34bf0500`, based on `origin/dev` at `77b1255cb`. The previous production bundle evidence is `~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/final-transfer-budget.log` on dev-02: critical JS measures 275,803 B Brotli / 329,656 B gzip against 273,408 B / 327,680 B caps. I’m tracing the bundler graph to identify a non-first-paint split, then I’ll run the real-server appearance spec and `verify quick` on dev-02. Existing swatch screenshots and the implementation commits remain on this branch.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:04:41 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Finding: a fresh production transfer-budget.ts run still fails on dev-02; ~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-settings-split-budget.log records critical JavaScript at 275,803 B Brotli / 329,656 B gzip (caps 273,408 B / 327,680 B). core-screen.ts is a critical root (chunk-classes.ts) and statically imports the Shortcuts panel, Toolbar panel and Settings overlay, which are only rendered after a Settings action. I’m moving those UI modules behind an existing .on-demand.ts boundary; the first-paint appearance and account look controller stay eager.

Finding: a fresh production `transfer-budget.ts` run still fails on dev-02; `~/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-settings-split-budget.log` records critical JavaScript at 275,803 B Brotli / 329,656 B gzip (caps 273,408 B / 327,680 B). `core-screen.ts` is a critical root (`chunk-classes.ts`) and statically imports the Shortcuts panel, Toolbar panel and Settings overlay, which are only rendered after a Settings action. I’m moving those UI modules behind an existing `.on-demand.ts` boundary; the first-paint appearance and account look controller stay eager.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:33:24 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The first dev-02 scripts/verify quick attempt stopped at the fmt step before TypeScript or package checks. The reported formatting differences are in crates/plugins/canvas/src/model.rs and fuzz/fuzz_targets/canvas_layout_json.rs; log: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/quick-settings-split.log. I’m formatting those files in a separate commit, then I’ll rerun quick.

The first dev-02 `scripts/verify quick` attempt stopped at the `fmt` step before TypeScript or package checks. The reported formatting differences are in `crates/plugins/canvas/src/model.rs` and `fuzz/fuzz_targets/canvas_layout_json.rs`; log: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/quick-settings-split.log`. I’m formatting those files in a separate commit, then I’ll rerun quick.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:39:00 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 before/after swatches (contrast against each theme background; after values pass the 4.5:1 text line).

Theme / text role Before After
Ink · fg3 #5f5f65 3.05:1 #818187 4.99:1
Ink · ANSI black #1b1c1f 1.13:1 #797b7e 4.55:1
Ink · bright ANSI black #5c5c62 2.91:1 #7a7a80 4.53:1
Paper · fg3 #8d8d92 3.05:1 #707075 4.55:1
Paper · ok #1f9d55 3.23:1 #00823c 4.56:1
Paper · ANSI white #8d8d93 3.05:1 #707076 4.55:1

The automated D365 audit also covers every scheme, ANSI foreground slot, interface status colour and floating-card surface.

D365 before/after swatches (contrast against each theme background; after values pass the 4.5:1 text line). | Theme / text role | Before | After | |---|---|---| | Ink · fg3 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#5f5f65;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#5f5f65</span> 3.05:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#818187;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#818187</span> 4.99:1 | | Ink · ANSI black | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#1b1c1f;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#1b1c1f</span> 1.13:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#797b7e;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#797b7e</span> 4.55:1 | | Ink · bright ANSI black | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#5c5c62;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#5c5c62</span> 2.91:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#7a7a80;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#7a7a80</span> 4.53:1 | | Paper · fg3 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#8d8d92;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#8d8d92</span> 3.05:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#707075;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#707075</span> 4.55:1 | | Paper · ok | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#1f9d55;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#1f9d55</span> 3.23:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#00823c;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#00823c</span> 4.56:1 | | Paper · ANSI white | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#8d8d93;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#8d8d93</span> 3.05:1 | <span style="display:inline-block;background:#707076;color:#fff;padding:2px 6px">#707076</span> 4.55:1 | The automated D365 audit also covers every scheme, ANSI foreground slot, interface status colour and floating-card surface.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:45:02 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The next dev-02 scripts/verify quick passed fmt and stopped at doc comments on diff because the remote worktree contains the preserved, unrelated untracked file scripts/.theme-d365-report.ts, which lacks D345 module/function comments. I left it untouched. I’ll rerun quick with a per-command Git exclude for only that path. Log: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/quick-settings-split-final.log.

The next dev-02 `scripts/verify quick` passed `fmt` and stopped at `doc comments on diff` because the remote worktree contains the preserved, unrelated untracked file `scripts/.theme-d365-report.ts`, which lacks D345 module/function comments. I left it untouched. I’ll rerun quick with a per-command Git exclude for only that path. Log: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/quick-settings-split-final.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:49:57 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The dev-02 quick run now reaches canvas unit tests. Two reducer fixtures fail after the new selected_theme_exists bound: the max-size fixture leaves selected=tinted after replacing its list with custom-0..custom-15, and the replacement fixture pops custom-1 after selecting it. The server is correctly refusing a look whose selected id is absent. I’m correcting those fixtures to keep the selected id in the list. Evidence: quick-settings-split-rerun.log (canvas tests: 17 passed, these 2 failed).

The dev-02 quick run now reaches canvas unit tests. Two reducer fixtures fail after the new `selected_theme_exists` bound: the max-size fixture leaves `selected=tinted` after replacing its list with `custom-0..custom-15`, and the replacement fixture pops `custom-1` after selecting it. The server is correctly refusing a look whose selected id is absent. I’m correcting those fixtures to keep the selected id in the list. Evidence: `quick-settings-split-rerun.log` (canvas tests: 17 passed, these 2 failed).
kayg commented 2026-11-08 16:58:38 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Gate coverage finding: packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts existed, but scripts/verify.d/ts.sh did not execute it. I’ve added it to the quick TypeScript suite so D365 checks every text role against every scheme on the gate path; the production notices Playwright spec will be run separately.

Gate coverage finding: `packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` existed, but `scripts/verify.d/ts.sh` did not execute it. I’ve added it to the quick TypeScript suite so D365 checks every text role against every scheme on the gate path; the production notices Playwright spec will be run separately.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:11:29 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Focused canvas tests are green after correcting the fixtures to retain their selected theme ids: cargo test --locked -p infraternal-plugin-canvas --lib → 19 passed, 0 failed. Log: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/canvas-tests-after-selection-fixture-rerun.log.

Focused canvas tests are green after correcting the fixtures to retain their selected theme ids: `cargo test --locked -p infraternal-plugin-canvas --lib` → `19 passed, 0 failed`. Log: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/canvas-tests-after-selection-fixture-rerun.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:17:46 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Continuing J304 on themes-sync-j304, started from dev f6f62a875; current pushed head is b34bf0500. The requested implementation commits are present for identifier validation, D365 contrast, D366 font sync, 44 px Colour targets, notices, badge placement, and look fuzzing. The pre-split production build measured 275,803 B Brotli against the 273,408 B critical JS cap (2,395 B over), so I am deferring the action-only Settings panels and measuring the production bundle again. The D365 audit is also being added to verify quick; two canvas fixtures are being corrected to satisfy the newly enforced selected-theme bound. The earlier compute01 real-server run was cut by the VM restart and is recorded as interrupted, not failed. I will resubmit the real-server two-client spec once in the foreground on dev-02, then run verify quick there. dev-02 currently has one unrelated active run and one queued run; no J304 run is queued or active.

Continuing J304 on `themes-sync-j304`, started from dev `f6f62a875`; current pushed head is `b34bf0500`. The requested implementation commits are present for identifier validation, D365 contrast, D366 font sync, 44 px Colour targets, notices, badge placement, and look fuzzing. The pre-split production build measured 275,803 B Brotli against the 273,408 B critical JS cap (2,395 B over), so I am deferring the action-only Settings panels and measuring the production bundle again. The D365 audit is also being added to `verify quick`; two canvas fixtures are being corrected to satisfy the newly enforced selected-theme bound. The earlier compute01 real-server run was cut by the VM restart and is recorded as interrupted, not failed. I will resubmit the real-server two-client spec once in the foreground on dev-02, then run `verify quick` there. dev-02 currently has one unrelated active run and one queued run; no J304 run is queued or active.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:20:27 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Finding: the expanded D365 audit was present in ts_verify_fast(), but scripts/verify quick uses verify_quick() from scripts/verify.d/quick.sh and only ran the tracer typecheck for TypeScript changes. I added a dedicated quick row that runs packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts after the typecheck. This keeps the 4.5:1 all-theme audit on the pre-check path as requested; the final quick run will provide the green evidence.

Finding: the expanded D365 audit was present in `ts_verify_fast()`, but `scripts/verify quick` uses `verify_quick()` from `scripts/verify.d/quick.sh` and only ran the tracer typecheck for TypeScript changes. I added a dedicated quick row that runs `packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` after the typecheck. This keeps the 4.5:1 all-theme audit on the pre-check path as requested; the final quick run will provide the green evidence.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:21:31 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Committed and pushed f92bd048f on themes-sync-j304. The two reducer fixtures now keep selected inside the look's theme list, and the validator/fuzz files pass formatting. Focused evidence: cargo test --locked -p infraternal-plugin-canvas --lib → 19 passed, 0 failed; log /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/canvas-tests-after-selection-fixture-rerun.log.

Committed and pushed `f92bd048f` on `themes-sync-j304`. The two reducer fixtures now keep `selected` inside the look's theme list, and the validator/fuzz files pass formatting. Focused evidence: `cargo test --locked -p infraternal-plugin-canvas --lib` → 19 passed, 0 failed; log `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/canvas-tests-after-selection-fixture-rerun.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:23:17 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The D365 audit wiring is committed and pushed as b4f820578. Both scripts/verify quick (when tracer files change) and verify fast now run packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts. Shell syntax and git diff --check are clean; the final quick run will verify the new row executes and passes.

The D365 audit wiring is committed and pushed as `b4f820578`. Both `scripts/verify quick` (when tracer files change) and `verify fast` now run `packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts`. Shell syntax and `git diff --check` are clean; the final quick run will verify the new row executes and passes.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:23:38 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The critical-JS budget fix is committed and pushed as 294031dda. The existing on-demand loader now owns the legacy Settings overlay and Toolbar/Shortcuts/About panel modules; first-paint code no longer statically imports them. Red evidence is the pre-change production transfer report at /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-settings-split-budget.log (275,803 B Brotli vs 273,408 B cap). I will report the post-change transfer number and Settings interaction check after the dev-02 production build.

The critical-JS budget fix is committed and pushed as `294031dda`. The existing on-demand loader now owns the legacy Settings overlay and Toolbar/Shortcuts/About panel modules; first-paint code no longer statically imports them. Red evidence is the pre-change production transfer report at `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/red-settings-split-budget.log` (275,803 B Brotli vs 273,408 B cap). I will report the post-change transfer number and Settings interaction check after the dev-02 production build.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:31:39 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Production transfer measurement after the Settings split, on dev-02: critical JavaScript is 268,115 B Brotli / 320,838 B gzip against caps 273,408 B / 327,680 B, leaving 5,293 B Brotli / 6,842 B gzip. Settings code is classified on-demand. The full transfer-budget.ts output is attached.

Production transfer measurement after the Settings split, on dev-02: critical JavaScript is 268,115 B Brotli / 320,838 B gzip against caps 273,408 B / 327,680 B, leaving 5,293 B Brotli / 6,842 B gzip. Settings code is classified on-demand. The full `transfer-budget.ts` output is attached.
settings-split-transfer-budget.log
17 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:35:40 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The one requested real-server resubmission is queued on dev-02 at position 1 behind J361; the J304 command remains foreground and has not started. Current head is 1d51ce602, which includes the latest origin/dev merge. The production transfer measurement is already green and attached above. I am keeping the real-server run in this turn until it finishes.

The one requested real-server resubmission is queued on dev-02 at position 1 behind J361; the J304 command remains foreground and has not started. Current head is `1d51ce602`, which includes the latest `origin/dev` merge. The production transfer measurement is already green and attached above. I am keeping the real-server run in this turn until it finishes.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:41:14 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Queue update: dev-02's only slot remains occupied by J361 (about 9½ minutes elapsed); the J304 real-server resubmission is still waiting at build-slot position 1 and has not started. The command is foreground and its eventual log path is /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/real-server-appearance-sync-final.log.

Queue update: dev-02's only slot remains occupied by J361 (about 9½ minutes elapsed); the J304 real-server resubmission is still waiting at build-slot position 1 and has not started. The command is foreground and its eventual log path is `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/real-server-appearance-sync-final.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:46:26 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The single real-server resubmission passed on dev-02 at head 1d51ce602. cargo build --locked -p infraternal built target/debug/infraternal; the real-server Playwright case passed 1/1. The initial canvas snapshot carried the look at 115 ms; FCP was 76 ms; separate appearance HTTP/API round trips were 0. The remote theme/font application had 26 frame samples, max 16.7 ms, and zero intervals over 20 ms. Both cameras stayed local; theme, font, and ui-font survived reload. The test log, measurement JSON, and Client B screenshot are attached.

The single real-server resubmission passed on dev-02 at head `1d51ce602`. `cargo build --locked -p infraternal` built `target/debug/infraternal`; the real-server Playwright case passed 1/1. The initial canvas snapshot carried the look at 115 ms; FCP was 76 ms; separate appearance HTTP/API round trips were 0. The remote theme/font application had 26 frame samples, max 16.7 ms, and zero intervals over 20 ms. Both cameras stayed local; theme, font, and `ui-font` survived reload. The test log, measurement JSON, and Client B screenshot are attached.
real-server-appearance-sync-final.log
12 KiB
live-sync.json
2.1 KiB
client-b-synced-look.png
93 KiB
client-b-synced-look.png
kayg commented 2026-11-08 17:49:54 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The requested dev-02 verify quick is queued at position 3 behind J287's active quick, J370, and another request. The J304 process is foreground and has not started; its log will be /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/verify-quick-final.log.

The requested dev-02 `verify quick` is queued at position 3 behind J287's active quick, J370, and another request. The J304 process is foreground and has not started; its log will be `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/verify-quick-final.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 18:00:08 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

verify quick on dev-02 at head 1d51ce602 completed with exit 0. Scope: infraternal-plugin-canvas, infraternal-server, and tracer. Canvas tests: 19 passed; server tests: 557 passed, 26 ignored; tracer typecheck passed; the D365 contrast audit passed 4 tests / 733 assertions. Scope guard, migration names, Nix vendoring, fmt, doc coverage, shape lints, diff docs, fixed waits, workspace clippy, ui literals, and all changed tests passed. The quick log is attached. This is the requested pre-check, not verify fast; the owner will run fast.

`verify quick` on dev-02 at head `1d51ce602` completed with exit 0. Scope: `infraternal-plugin-canvas`, `infraternal-server`, and tracer. Canvas tests: 19 passed; server tests: 557 passed, 26 ignored; tracer typecheck passed; the D365 contrast audit passed 4 tests / 733 assertions. Scope guard, migration names, Nix vendoring, fmt, doc coverage, shape lints, diff docs, fixed waits, workspace clippy, ui literals, and all changed tests passed. The quick log is attached. This is the requested pre-check, not `verify fast`; the owner will run fast.
verify-quick-final.log
74 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-08 18:03:27 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The first focused production-browser invocation ended before tests ran because I passed playwright.config.ts from the repo root; the config is at apps/tracer/playwright.config.ts. No test assertions executed. I am rerunning the same suite from apps/tracer and will attach its final output.

The first focused production-browser invocation ended before tests ran because I passed `playwright.config.ts` from the repo root; the config is at `apps/tracer/playwright.config.ts`. No test assertions executed. I am rerunning the same suite from `apps/tracer` and will attach its final output.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 18:18:43 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The focused production-browser regression rerun is queued at position 3 on dev-02 behind two other runs. It is held in the foreground and no test assertions have started. Branch themes-sync-j304 is at 1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9. The eventual log is /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/production-ui-regressions.log.

The focused production-browser regression rerun is queued at position 3 on dev-02 behind two other runs. It is held in the foreground and no test assertions have started. Branch `themes-sync-j304` is at `1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9`. The eventual log is `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/production-ui-regressions.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 18:27:28 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 follow-up validation at themes-sync-j304 head 1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9 (based on dev f6f62a875; includes the origin/dev merge).

The focused production-browser rerun completed on dev-02 from apps/tracer:

Running 5 tests using 1 worker
  ✓ palette: About infraternal opens Settings, About, and is found by version, build and commit
  ✓ a prototype-named saved Colour leaves the Themes window usable
  ✓ the selected theme tick does not cover preview text
  ✓ each light and dark Colour circle has a 44 px touch target
  ✓ the production build serves complete theme and font license notices

5 passed (42.0s)
PLAYWRIGHT_UI_EXIT=0

The full log is attached: /home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/production-ui-regressions.log.

The real-server two-client appearance spec and verify quick already passed at this same head; their logs and screenshots are attached in the preceding comments. The real-server run measured the initial look snapshot at 115 ms, FCP at 76 ms, zero separate appearance round trips, and a 16.7 ms maximum theme/font frame interval with zero appearance frames over 20 ms. Both cameras stayed local, and theme, font, and ui-font survived reload.

The quick result included 19 canvas tests passed, 557 server tests passed with 26 ignored, tracer typecheck, and the D365 audit (4 tests, 733 assertions). Its final gate rows were:

+---------------------------+--------------+
| Rust gate                 | Result       |
+---------------------------+--------------+
| scope guard               | PASS         |
| migration names           | PASS         |
| Nix Cargo vendoring       | PASS         |
| fmt                       | PASS         |
| doc coverage ratchet      | PASS         |
| shape lints off (D351)    | PASS         |
| doc comments on diff      | PASS         |
| fixed test waits          | PASS         |
| clippy (workspace)        | PASS         |
| unit tests (changed)      | PASS         |
| ui literals               | PASS         |
| tracer typecheck          | PASS         |
| D365 theme contrast audit | PASS         |
+---------------------------+--------------+

QUICK pre-check passed. This is not the gate: run scripts/verify fast before reporting done.
VERIFY_QUICK_EXIT=0

The production transfer measurement after the Settings split is 268,115 B Brotli / 320,838 B gzip, leaving 5,293 B / 6,842 B under the respective budgets. D365 before/after swatches for Ink and Paper are posted above. The owner will run verify fast on compute01.

J304 follow-up validation at `themes-sync-j304` head `1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9` (based on dev `f6f62a875`; includes the origin/dev merge). The focused production-browser rerun completed on dev-02 from `apps/tracer`: ```text Running 5 tests using 1 worker ✓ palette: About infraternal opens Settings, About, and is found by version, build and commit ✓ a prototype-named saved Colour leaves the Themes window usable ✓ the selected theme tick does not cover preview text ✓ each light and dark Colour circle has a 44 px touch target ✓ the production build serves complete theme and font license notices 5 passed (42.0s) PLAYWRIGHT_UI_EXIT=0 ``` The full log is attached: `/home/claude/.cache/codex-scratch/themes-sync-j304/evidence/production-ui-regressions.log`. The real-server two-client appearance spec and `verify quick` already passed at this same head; their logs and screenshots are attached in the preceding comments. The real-server run measured the initial look snapshot at 115 ms, FCP at 76 ms, zero separate appearance round trips, and a 16.7 ms maximum theme/font frame interval with zero appearance frames over 20 ms. Both cameras stayed local, and theme, font, and `ui-font` survived reload. The quick result included 19 canvas tests passed, 557 server tests passed with 26 ignored, tracer typecheck, and the D365 audit (4 tests, 733 assertions). Its final gate rows were: ```text +---------------------------+--------------+ | Rust gate | Result | +---------------------------+--------------+ | scope guard | PASS | | migration names | PASS | | Nix Cargo vendoring | PASS | | fmt | PASS | | doc coverage ratchet | PASS | | shape lints off (D351) | PASS | | doc comments on diff | PASS | | fixed test waits | PASS | | clippy (workspace) | PASS | | unit tests (changed) | PASS | | ui literals | PASS | | tracer typecheck | PASS | | D365 theme contrast audit | PASS | +---------------------------+--------------+ QUICK pre-check passed. This is not the gate: run scripts/verify fast before reporting done. VERIFY_QUICK_EXIT=0 ``` The production transfer measurement after the Settings split is 268,115 B Brotli / 320,838 B gzip, leaving 5,293 B / 6,842 B under the respective budgets. D365 before/after swatches for Ink and Paper are posted above. The owner will run `verify fast` on compute01.
production-ui-regressions.log
3.8 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-08 18:59:02 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 (final independent review) starting.

Target: themes-sync-j304 @ 1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9 (base f6f62a875). Merging origin/dev 9965911c8 into a scratch worktree (no push). Scope: account-sync correctness (look/theme/font/ui-font, concurrent edits, offline, unknown IDs, migration), D365/D366, 44 px targets, notices, budgets, gates on the merged tree, screenshots (ink, paper, 2 others; 1440x900 and 393x852).

J392 (final independent review) starting. Target: `themes-sync-j304` @ `1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9` (base f6f62a875). Merging origin/dev `9965911c8` into a scratch worktree (no push). Scope: account-sync correctness (look/theme/font/`ui-font`, concurrent edits, offline, unknown IDs, migration), D365/D366, 44 px targets, notices, budgets, gates on the merged tree, screenshots (ink, paper, 2 others; 1440x900 and 393x852).
kayg commented 2026-11-08 19:04:16 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 finding 1 (P2): the D365 gate checks only primary text over gradient backdrops. Secondary roles fall to 2.7–4.4:1 there.

apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.test.ts:107 checks fg over each gradientColours(theme). packages/ui/src/theme-audit.ts checks every role, but only on the scheme bg and the Solid card surface. D365 says "every colour used for text, including secondary, accent and ok/warn/danger on their surfaces".

Evidence (script ~/j392-gap.ts on dev-02, run against the merged tree): 1,412 role × gradient colour checks across the 28 schemes. 91 role/scheme pairs fall under 4.5:1 against the worst gradient colour, at full gradient strength, which is the same worst-case convention the existing fg test uses. Examples:

  • paper: fg2 #65656a over #ffb6a4 = 3.44; fg3 = 2.93; accent = 3.10; ok = 2.93
  • latte: fg3 over #ffa4a7 = 2.73
  • ink: fg3 over #00373e = 3.36
  • mocha: fg3 over #004c44 = 3.11
  • gruvbox: fg3 over #2a552d = 3.03
  • nord: fg3 over #4a5e38 = 2.93

At the default Tinted look (75% tint) the window surface mostly hides the gradient, so the real ratio is better. Frosted (50%) and any text drawn straight on the canvas are not protected. Either extend the audit to fg2/fg3/accent/ok over the gradient colours (and repair or lower the gradients), or write down in D365 / THEME-AUDIT.md that gradients are covered for fg only.

**J392 finding 1 (P2): the D365 gate checks only primary text over gradient backdrops. Secondary roles fall to 2.7–4.4:1 there.** `apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/model.test.ts:107` checks `fg` over each `gradientColours(theme)`. `packages/ui/src/theme-audit.ts` checks every role, but only on the scheme `bg` and the Solid card surface. D365 says "every colour used for text, including secondary, accent and ok/warn/danger on their surfaces". Evidence (script `~/j392-gap.ts` on dev-02, run against the merged tree): 1,412 role × gradient colour checks across the 28 schemes. 91 role/scheme pairs fall under 4.5:1 against the worst gradient colour, at full gradient strength, which is the same worst-case convention the existing `fg` test uses. Examples: - paper: fg2 `#65656a` over `#ffb6a4` = 3.44; fg3 = 2.93; accent = 3.10; ok = 2.93 - latte: fg3 over `#ffa4a7` = 2.73 - ink: fg3 over `#00373e` = 3.36 - mocha: fg3 over `#004c44` = 3.11 - gruvbox: fg3 over `#2a552d` = 3.03 - nord: fg3 over `#4a5e38` = 2.93 At the default Tinted look (75% tint) the window surface mostly hides the gradient, so the real ratio is better. Frosted (50%) and any text drawn straight on the canvas are not protected. Either extend the audit to fg2/fg3/accent/ok over the gradient colours (and repair or lower the gradients), or write down in D365 / THEME-AUDIT.md that gradients are covered for `fg` only.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 19:04:16 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 finding 2 (P2): the Nerd Symbols notice credits only the Maple Mono OFL, but the subset carries third-party icon sets.

apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh:76 keeps U+E0A0-E0D7 (Powerline), E5FA-E6B7 (Seti-UI), E700-E7C5 (Devicons), F000-F2E0 (Font Awesome), F300-F381 (Font Logos) and F400-F532 (Octicons). THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md:78 lists "Nerd Symbols" as SIL OFL 1.1 via fonts/maple-mono-nf/OFL.txt, which covers Maple only. A grep for Seti, Octicons, Devicons, Font Awesome, Powerline and Font Logos in THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md and in fonts/maple-mono-nf/ finds nothing. Several of these sets are MIT and need their copyright notice shipped. Add one row per source set with its licence and copyright line (the complete MIT text is already at /licenses/MIT.txt). The Apache-2.0 file does include the appendix. Every font directory has its own OFL file.

J392 finding 3 (P3): ui-font can be changed from nowhere in the product (D366 plumbing only).

Nothing outside tests dispatches tracer:ui-font (grep over apps/tracer/src and packages/ui/src finds only the listener at themes/controller.ts:325). On dev, ?ui=sans persisted the choice in localStorage; on the branch ?ui= is page-only. The synced value is therefore reachable only through the legacy migration or a synthetic event, which is how real/appearance-sync.spec.ts:319 drives it. This matches TASTE §2 ("monospace everywhere"), so it is not a blocker, but D366's "Follow the account" is currently untestable from the UI. Say so in the issue, or add the control when the owner approves one.

J392 finding 4 (P3): no drift test between the server's id lists and the client's.

crates/plugins/canvas/src/model.rs hardcodes SCHEME_IDS, FONT_IDS and BACKGROUND_IDS. I compared them against THEMES, FONTS, GRADIENT_IDS and SOLID_IDS on the merged tree and found no difference today. Nothing keeps it that way. Adding a font to fonts.ts alone makes the server reject the entire look.set. In the controller, localLookPending then stays true (cleared only by confirmed, controller.ts ~L300), so apply() returns early for every later remote look on that page until reload. Add a test that reads the three lists from both sides.

J392 finding 5 (P3): look.set replaces the whole look, so a long offline edit can erase another device's new theme.

reducer.rs replaces doc.look as a whole (the comment says the last edit to arrive wins). Device A offline changes the font while B creates theme custom-1. On reconnect, A's look.set carries a list without custom-1, and the theme is gone. This follows from the "server orders edits" model and D352, and the 16-theme limit keeps the payload bounded. No test covers an offline edit crossing a remote theme add. Accept and document, or merge by theme id.

**J392 finding 2 (P2): the Nerd Symbols notice credits only the Maple Mono OFL, but the subset carries third-party icon sets.** `apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh:76` keeps `U+E0A0-E0D7` (Powerline), `E5FA-E6B7` (Seti-UI), `E700-E7C5` (Devicons), `F000-F2E0` (Font Awesome), `F300-F381` (Font Logos) and `F400-F532` (Octicons). `THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md:78` lists "Nerd Symbols" as SIL OFL 1.1 via `fonts/maple-mono-nf/OFL.txt`, which covers Maple only. A grep for Seti, Octicons, Devicons, Font Awesome, Powerline and Font Logos in `THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md` and in `fonts/maple-mono-nf/` finds nothing. Several of these sets are MIT and need their copyright notice shipped. Add one row per source set with its licence and copyright line (the complete MIT text is already at `/licenses/MIT.txt`). The Apache-2.0 file does include the appendix. Every font directory has its own OFL file. **J392 finding 3 (P3): `ui-font` can be changed from nowhere in the product (D366 plumbing only).** Nothing outside tests dispatches `tracer:ui-font` (`grep` over `apps/tracer/src` and `packages/ui/src` finds only the listener at `themes/controller.ts:325`). On dev, `?ui=sans` persisted the choice in `localStorage`; on the branch `?ui=` is page-only. The synced value is therefore reachable only through the legacy migration or a synthetic event, which is how `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts:319` drives it. This matches TASTE §2 ("monospace everywhere"), so it is not a blocker, but D366's "Follow the account" is currently untestable from the UI. Say so in the issue, or add the control when the owner approves one. **J392 finding 4 (P3): no drift test between the server's id lists and the client's.** `crates/plugins/canvas/src/model.rs` hardcodes `SCHEME_IDS`, `FONT_IDS` and `BACKGROUND_IDS`. I compared them against `THEMES`, `FONTS`, `GRADIENT_IDS` and `SOLID_IDS` on the merged tree and found no difference today. Nothing keeps it that way. Adding a font to `fonts.ts` alone makes the server reject the entire `look.set`. In the controller, `localLookPending` then stays true (cleared only by `confirmed`, `controller.ts` ~L300), so `apply()` returns early for every later remote look on that page until reload. Add a test that reads the three lists from both sides. **J392 finding 5 (P3): `look.set` replaces the whole look, so a long offline edit can erase another device's new theme.** `reducer.rs` replaces `doc.look` as a whole (the comment says the last edit to arrive wins). Device A offline changes the font while B creates theme `custom-1`. On reconnect, A's `look.set` carries a list without `custom-1`, and the theme is gone. This follows from the "server orders edits" model and D352, and the 16-theme limit keeps the payload bounded. No test covers an offline edit crossing a remote theme add. Accept and document, or merge by theme id.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 19:46:26 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 finding 6 (P2): the custom-background editor's controls are under 44 px on a phone (TASTE §2, "touch follows iOS: 44 px targets").

apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/editor.on-demand.ts is new on this branch. I measured the controls in the Themes window at 393×852 (touch emulation, production build, merged tree; script apps/tracer/test/j392-shots.spec.ts, log ~/j392-evidence/themes-specs.log on dev-02): "Solid" 63×38, "Gradient" 87×38, "Add a colour" 30×30, "Remove the last colour" 30×30. The existing spec at themes.spec.ts:235 covers only the Colour circles. The breadcrumb pill ("Themes, Appearance", 93×36) is also under 44 px; I did not check whether it predates this branch. Add a pointer: coarse rule or a spec.

J392 progress (merged tree = branch 1d51ce602 + origin/dev 9965911c8, plus the docs-only 8e664e6b7; no conflicts)

  • Production build and transfer-budget.ts pass. Critical JS 320,842 B gzip / 268,110 B brotli (caps 327,680 / 273,408; headroom 6,838 / 5,298 B). Deferred 57,388 / 51,038 B (caps 61,440 / 55,296). No cap constant changed: the diff only adds font-family entries. Log: ~/j392-evidence/budget.log.
  • test/themes.spec.ts: 32 passed on a production build (themes-specs.log).
  • real/appearance-sync.spec.ts against a real aarch64 server built from the merged tree: 6 passed (real-appearance.log).
  • Screenshots of ink, paper, nord and solarized-light at 1440×900 and 393×852 are in ~/j392-evidence/shots/ on dev-02. Ink at 1440 and paper at 393 look fine: the selection tick sits on the card corner without covering preview text, and the Colour circles line up.
  • verify fast on compute01 is queued (slot position 9).
**J392 finding 6 (P2): the custom-background editor's controls are under 44 px on a phone (TASTE §2, "touch follows iOS: 44 px targets").** `apps/tracer/src/canvas/themes/editor.on-demand.ts` is new on this branch. I measured the controls in the Themes window at 393×852 (touch emulation, production build, merged tree; script `apps/tracer/test/j392-shots.spec.ts`, log `~/j392-evidence/themes-specs.log` on dev-02): "Solid" 63×38, "Gradient" 87×38, "Add a colour" 30×30, "Remove the last colour" 30×30. The existing spec at `themes.spec.ts:235` covers only the Colour circles. The breadcrumb pill ("Themes, Appearance", 93×36) is also under 44 px; I did not check whether it predates this branch. Add a `pointer: coarse` rule or a spec. **J392 progress (merged tree = branch 1d51ce602 + origin/dev 9965911c8, plus the docs-only 8e664e6b7; no conflicts)** - Production build and `transfer-budget.ts` pass. Critical JS 320,842 B gzip / 268,110 B brotli (caps 327,680 / 273,408; headroom 6,838 / 5,298 B). Deferred 57,388 / 51,038 B (caps 61,440 / 55,296). No cap constant changed: the diff only adds font-family entries. Log: `~/j392-evidence/budget.log`. - `test/themes.spec.ts`: 32 passed on a production build (`themes-specs.log`). - `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts` against a real aarch64 server built from the merged tree: 6 passed (`real-appearance.log`). - Screenshots of ink, paper, nord and solarized-light at 1440×900 and 393×852 are in `~/j392-evidence/shots/` on dev-02. Ink at 1440 and paper at 393 look fine: the selection tick sits on the card corner without covering preview text, and the Colour circles line up. - `verify fast` on compute01 is queued (slot position 9).
kayg commented 2026-11-08 20:58:13 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 progress: verify fast is running on compute01 for the merged tree and has reached the "static builds" row. Every row before it has passed so far, including the Rust test suites. verify quick is still queued on dev-02 (position 7). The browser and real-server runs on the merged tree are already done and green (see my previous comment). The full gate output will be quoted when it exits.

J392 progress: `verify fast` is running on compute01 for the merged tree and has reached the "static builds" row. Every row before it has passed so far, including the Rust test suites. `verify quick` is still queued on dev-02 (position 7). The browser and real-server runs on the merged tree are already done and green (see my previous comment). The full gate output will be quoted when it exits.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 21:27:09 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 final review: REQUEST CHANGES (two P2 findings, the rest P3)

Reviewed SHA: themes-sync-j304 @ 1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9.
Merged tree: that head + origin/dev 9965911c8 (scratch merge 29d5dd70e) + the docs-only 8e664e6b7 (scratch merge 3b898e26f). Nothing was pushed.

Merge conflicts: none. The author had already merged most of dev. Only DECISIONS.md and crates/plugins/ssh/tests/common/mod.rs changed in my merge. sideEffects: false is present in packages/ui. Nothing broke.

Findings (details in the earlier comments)

  • P2-1: the D365 gate checks only fg over gradient backdrops. fg2/fg3/accent/ok fall to 2.7–4.4:1 over gradient colours in 91 role/scheme pairs at full gradient strength (script ~/j392-gap.ts, dev-02).
  • P2-2: the Nerd Symbols notice credits only the Maple OFL. The subset carries Powerline, Seti, Devicons, Font Awesome, Font Logos and Octicons ranges, and none is credited.
  • P2-3: the custom-background editor controls are under 44 px on a phone: Solid 63×38, Gradient 87×38, Add/Remove colour 30×30.
  • P3: no UI path sets ui-font (D366 plumbing only; TASTE says mono everywhere).
  • P3: no drift test between the server's id lists and the client's. They match today.
  • P3: look.set replaces the whole look, so an offline edit can erase another device's new theme. No test covers it.
  • Findings 3 and 5 come from reading the code. I did not reproduce them.
  • The look.set rejection path I described under finding 4 also comes from reading the code, not from running it.

Checked and fine

  • D365 audit test and look/theme unit tests: 27 pass.
  • MIT and Apache-2.0 texts are shipped (Apache with its appendix), and every font directory has its OFL file.
  • Unknown ids are rejected by the server: 7 pointers in the reducer test.
  • Appearance sync adds no round trip on load (the look rides in the canvas snapshot).

Budgets (bun run transfer-budget.ts, merged tree, aarch64 build; ~/j392-evidence/budget.log on dev-02)

  • Critical JS: 320,842 B gzip / 268,110 B brotli. Caps are 327,680 / 273,408, so 6,838 / 5,298 B remain.
  • Deferred JS: 57,388 / 51,038 B (caps 61,440 / 55,296).
  • No cap constant changed. The diff only adds font-family entries.
  • I did not build dev for a before/after comparison.

Gates

  • verify fast, compute01, merged tree: VERIFY_FAST_EXIT=0 (log ~/j392-evidence/verify-fast.log on compute01). Every row PASS except privileged integration, which is SKIP. Rows: Nix Cargo vendoring, fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, shape lints off (D351), doc comments on diff, fixed test waits, probe release exclusion, nightly fuzz reporter, static builds. Tail: Ran 50 tests across 13 files / VERIFY_FAST_EXIT=0.
  • verify quick, dev-02: not completed. The first run stopped at "doc comments on diff" because of my own scratch capture spec (~/j392-evidence/verify-quick-scratch-fail.log). I deleted it and requeued, but the dev-02 queue was at position 12, so I cancelled the run. Rows that passed before the stop: scope guard, migration names, Nix Cargo vendoring, fmt, doc coverage ratchet, shape lints, fixed test waits. The fast gate covers clippy, tests and the doc rows, and the dev-02 build ran bun run check (tracer typecheck).
  • Production-build test/themes.spec.ts: 32 passed (themes-specs.log).
  • Real-server real/appearance-sync.spec.ts, aarch64 server built from the merged tree: 6 passed (real-appearance.log).
  • I could not measure first paint: the spec asserts the frame budget on this tree, but I did not read its numbers. The author's 115 ms snapshot / 76 ms FCP / 16.7 ms frame claims are theirs, not re-measured.

Screenshots: ink, paper, nord and solarized-light at 1440×900 and 393×852, in ~/j392-evidence/shots/ on dev-02. I looked at ink 1440 and paper 393. I did not view the other six individually.

Scratch worktree and targets on both VMs are cleaned. The scratch spec was never committed.

**J392 final review: REQUEST CHANGES** (two P2 findings, the rest P3) Reviewed SHA: `themes-sync-j304` @ `1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9`. Merged tree: that head + origin/dev `9965911c8` (scratch merge `29d5dd70e`) + the docs-only `8e664e6b7` (scratch merge `3b898e26f`). Nothing was pushed. **Merge conflicts:** none. The author had already merged most of dev. Only `DECISIONS.md` and `crates/plugins/ssh/tests/common/mod.rs` changed in my merge. `sideEffects: false` is present in `packages/ui`. Nothing broke. **Findings** (details in the earlier comments) - P2-1: the D365 gate checks only `fg` over gradient backdrops. fg2/fg3/accent/ok fall to 2.7–4.4:1 over gradient colours in 91 role/scheme pairs at full gradient strength (script `~/j392-gap.ts`, dev-02). - P2-2: the Nerd Symbols notice credits only the Maple OFL. The subset carries Powerline, Seti, Devicons, Font Awesome, Font Logos and Octicons ranges, and none is credited. - P2-3: the custom-background editor controls are under 44 px on a phone: Solid 63×38, Gradient 87×38, Add/Remove colour 30×30. - P3: no UI path sets `ui-font` (D366 plumbing only; TASTE says mono everywhere). - P3: no drift test between the server's id lists and the client's. They match today. - P3: `look.set` replaces the whole look, so an offline edit can erase another device's new theme. No test covers it. - Findings 3 and 5 come from reading the code. I did not reproduce them. - The `look.set` rejection path I described under finding 4 also comes from reading the code, not from running it. **Checked and fine** - D365 audit test and look/theme unit tests: 27 pass. - MIT and Apache-2.0 texts are shipped (Apache with its appendix), and every font directory has its OFL file. - Unknown ids are rejected by the server: 7 pointers in the reducer test. - Appearance sync adds no round trip on load (the look rides in the canvas snapshot). **Budgets** (`bun run transfer-budget.ts`, merged tree, aarch64 build; `~/j392-evidence/budget.log` on dev-02) - Critical JS: 320,842 B gzip / 268,110 B brotli. Caps are 327,680 / 273,408, so 6,838 / 5,298 B remain. - Deferred JS: 57,388 / 51,038 B (caps 61,440 / 55,296). - No cap constant changed. The diff only adds font-family entries. - I did not build dev for a before/after comparison. **Gates** - `verify fast`, compute01, merged tree: **VERIFY_FAST_EXIT=0** (log `~/j392-evidence/verify-fast.log` on compute01). Every row PASS except `privileged integration`, which is SKIP. Rows: Nix Cargo vendoring, fmt, migration names, migration tooling tests, VT native fmt, CLI plugin compile-out, clippy, SSH runtime test helper, real-binary fixture paths, Traefik component manifest, release component publication, test, SSH inode reuse fixture, shim process-per-user, cargo-deny, gate architecture, doc coverage ratchet, shape lints off (D351), doc comments on diff, fixed test waits, probe release exclusion, nightly fuzz reporter, static builds. Tail: `Ran 50 tests across 13 files` / `VERIFY_FAST_EXIT=0`. - `verify quick`, dev-02: **not completed.** The first run stopped at "doc comments on diff" because of my own scratch capture spec (`~/j392-evidence/verify-quick-scratch-fail.log`). I deleted it and requeued, but the dev-02 queue was at position 12, so I cancelled the run. Rows that passed before the stop: scope guard, migration names, Nix Cargo vendoring, fmt, doc coverage ratchet, shape lints, fixed test waits. The fast gate covers clippy, tests and the doc rows, and the dev-02 build ran `bun run check` (tracer typecheck). - Production-build `test/themes.spec.ts`: 32 passed (`themes-specs.log`). - Real-server `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts`, aarch64 server built from the merged tree: 6 passed (`real-appearance.log`). - I could not measure first paint: the spec asserts the frame budget on this tree, but I did not read its numbers. The author's 115 ms snapshot / 76 ms FCP / 16.7 ms frame claims are theirs, not re-measured. **Screenshots:** ink, paper, nord and solarized-light at 1440×900 and 393×852, in `~/j392-evidence/shots/` on dev-02. I looked at ink 1440 and paper 393. I did not view the other six individually. Scratch worktree and targets on both VMs are cleaned. The scratch spec was never committed.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 21:34:46 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 final-review follow-up starts on themes-sync-j304 at 1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9 (base f6f62a875). I fetched origin/dev at 0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587; it contains the requested minimum 0a5432d2c. No source edits have been made yet. I will merge this origin/dev before coding.

Plan: red-first atomic commits for the D365 gradient audit/repairs, Nerd Symbols credits/licences, coarse-pointer editor targets, an account-synced interface-font control, separate stale-offline-edit and rejected-write recovery regressions, and client/server ID-list drift coverage. Then run the requested theme/D365 and real-server specs, transfer-budget measurement, verify quick on dev-02 and verify fast on compute01, capture 393x852 editor screenshots, and report the head and outputs here. Estimate: about 3–4 hours plus build-slot queue time. I will not merge.

J304 final-review follow-up starts on `themes-sync-j304` at `1d51ce6021febc20a529d8d66c41d3320abcb8a9` (base `f6f62a875`). I fetched `origin/dev` at `0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587`; it contains the requested minimum `0a5432d2c`. No source edits have been made yet. I will merge this `origin/dev` before coding. Plan: red-first atomic commits for the D365 gradient audit/repairs, Nerd Symbols credits/licences, coarse-pointer editor targets, an account-synced interface-font control, separate stale-offline-edit and rejected-write recovery regressions, and client/server ID-list drift coverage. Then run the requested theme/D365 and real-server specs, transfer-budget measurement, `verify quick` on dev-02 and `verify fast` on compute01, capture 393x852 editor screenshots, and report the head and outputs here. Estimate: about 3–4 hours plus build-slot queue time. I will not merge.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 21:55:15 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 finding confirmed in the merged tree: theme-audit.ts checks text roles on the scheme background and card surface, while the gradient test in model.test.ts checks only fg. J392 measured 91 role/scheme failures across 1,412 gradient-color checks; Paper fg3 reaches 2.93:1 on #ffb6a4. I added a role-by-gradient regression test and queued its red run on dev-02; next I will repair gradient values while preserving each scheme palette hue.

D365 finding confirmed in the merged tree: theme-audit.ts checks text roles on the scheme background and card surface, while the gradient test in model.test.ts checks only fg. J392 measured 91 role/scheme failures across 1,412 gradient-color checks; Paper fg3 reaches 2.93:1 on #ffb6a4. I added a role-by-gradient regression test and queued its red run on dev-02; next I will repair gradient values while preserving each scheme palette hue.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 22:09:37 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 resume: fetched and merged origin/dev at 0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587; current head is 2193641e8f78ef25cbf3e31c56254f0d44f7a60b. The D365 regression test is copied to the dev-02 worktree. Its red run is queued through build-slot as PID 518843 (queue position 10 at the last status check); no assertion has run yet. I am holding the red-first checkpoint and continuing code review while it waits. No production changes yet.

J304 resume: fetched and merged `origin/dev` at `0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587`; current head is `2193641e8f78ef25cbf3e31c56254f0d44f7a60b`. The D365 regression test is copied to the dev-02 worktree. Its red run is queued through `build-slot` as PID 518843 (queue position 10 at the last status check); no assertion has run yet. I am holding the red-first checkpoint and continuing code review while it waits. No production changes yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 22:24:33 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 source checks for the remaining final-review findings:

  1. Nerd Symbols notices: apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh subsets U+E000–E00A, E0A0–E0D7, E5FA–E6B7, E700–E7C5, F000–F2E0, F300–F381 and F400–F532. The Nerd Fonts glyph-source table maps these to Pomicons, Powerline / Powerline Extra, Seti, Devicons, Font Awesome, Font Logos and Octicons. I am checking each upstream license and will ship its full terms with the source range and attribution; the resulting font remains a separately licensed asset alongside the AGPL-3.0-only application.
  2. Phone targets: J392's production measurements are Solid 63×38, Gradient 87×38 and Add/Remove colour 30×30 at 393×852. I will add a coarse-pointer geometry assertion for each control.
  3. D366 control: themes/controller.ts accepts tracer:ui-font, but the only product trigger is synthetic in a test. I will add a Settings › Appearance control using the shared choiceBlock and test that it edits the account look.
  4. Offline look edit: look.set replaces the complete look in reducer.rs, while canvas_store.rs accepts any base revision up through the current revision. I will add a stale-revision CAS regression so an offline whole-look edit cannot delete a newer remote theme.
  5. Rejected-write recovery: controller.ts preserves a pending local look in apply() and confirmed() returns when the settled canonical look differs; I will add a red regression that proves subsequent canonical remote looks apply after the rejected write settles.
  6. ID drift: Rust SCHEME_IDS, FONT_IDS and BACKGROUND_IDS are separate from the client lists with no cross-check. I will add a test comparing all three lists.

The D365 gradient regression is already queued on dev-02; no production changes have been made yet.

J304 source checks for the remaining final-review findings: 1. **Nerd Symbols notices:** `apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh` subsets U+E000–E00A, E0A0–E0D7, E5FA–E6B7, E700–E7C5, F000–F2E0, F300–F381 and F400–F532. The Nerd Fonts glyph-source table maps these to Pomicons, Powerline / Powerline Extra, Seti, Devicons, Font Awesome, Font Logos and Octicons. I am checking each upstream license and will ship its full terms with the source range and attribution; the resulting font remains a separately licensed asset alongside the AGPL-3.0-only application. 2. **Phone targets:** J392's production measurements are Solid 63×38, Gradient 87×38 and Add/Remove colour 30×30 at 393×852. I will add a coarse-pointer geometry assertion for each control. 3. **D366 control:** `themes/controller.ts` accepts `tracer:ui-font`, but the only product trigger is synthetic in a test. I will add a Settings › Appearance control using the shared `choiceBlock` and test that it edits the account look. 4. **Offline look edit:** `look.set` replaces the complete look in `reducer.rs`, while `canvas_store.rs` accepts any base revision up through the current revision. I will add a stale-revision CAS regression so an offline whole-look edit cannot delete a newer remote theme. 5. **Rejected-write recovery:** `controller.ts` preserves a pending local look in `apply()` and `confirmed()` returns when the settled canonical look differs; I will add a red regression that proves subsequent canonical remote looks apply after the rejected write settles. 6. **ID drift:** Rust `SCHEME_IDS`, `FONT_IDS` and `BACKGROUND_IDS` are separate from the client lists with no cross-check. I will add a test comparing all three lists. The D365 gradient regression is already queued on dev-02; no production changes have been made yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:09:55 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 final-review implementation is active again on themes-sync-j304 at 2193641e8f78ef25cbf3e31c56254f0d44f7a60b, with origin/dev 0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587 merged. The D365 regression is still in its original dev-02 build-slot queue (PID 518843); I am keeping it in place and will not duplicate it. Next I am completing the red-first fixes, then the requested real-server, budget, quick and fast evidence. No production changes yet.

J304 final-review implementation is active again on `themes-sync-j304` at `2193641e8f78ef25cbf3e31c56254f0d44f7a60b`, with `origin/dev` `0a5432d2c1347c57bf1a6c57e368877599d57587` merged. The D365 regression is still in its original dev-02 build-slot queue (PID 518843); I am keeping it in place and will not duplicate it. Next I am completing the red-first fixes, then the requested real-server, budget, quick and fast evidence. No production changes yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:46 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: D366 sync already carries ui-font in the account look, but Settings › Appearance has no control. I’ll reuse the existing shared choice component and cover the selection in the real-server two-client spec.

J304 finding update: D366 sync already carries `ui-font` in the account look, but Settings › Appearance has no control. I’ll reuse the existing shared choice component and cover the selection in the real-server two-client spec.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: Nerd Symbols currently has one Maple Mono OFL credit, while its codepoint subset includes multiple upstream ranges. I’m checking the subset map and source licences, then will include each required notice text and a notice test for the full carried ranges.

J304 finding update: Nerd Symbols currently has one Maple Mono OFL credit, while its codepoint subset includes multiple upstream ranges. I’m checking the subset map and source licences, then will include each required notice text and a notice test for the full carried ranges.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update (round 3), branch themes-sync-j304, based on merged origin/dev 0a5432d2c. J392's D365 probe found contrast failures over gradient mixtures; the queued regression currently enumerates foreground roles but needs sampling the actual gradient composites. I’m extending it to check each text role at the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient, then I’ll repair the theme/gradient tokens and post Ink/Paper swatches with ratios.

J304 finding update (round 3), branch `themes-sync-j304`, based on merged `origin/dev` `0a5432d2c`. J392's D365 probe found contrast failures over gradient mixtures; the queued regression currently enumerates foreground roles but needs sampling the actual gradient composites. I’m extending it to check each text role at the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient, then I’ll repair the theme/gradient tokens and post Ink/Paper swatches with ratios.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: custom background controls have 38 px height and 30 px add/remove targets. I’ll add coarse-pointer hit areas of at least 44 px and a 393×852 geometry assertion.

J304 finding update: custom background controls have 38 px height and 30 px add/remove targets. I’ll add coarse-pointer hit areas of at least 44 px and a 393×852 geometry assertion.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: Rust has fixed scheme/font id arrays separate from the client definitions. I’ll add a drift test and make the comparison fail if either list changes without the matching server list.

J304 finding update: Rust has fixed scheme/font id arrays separate from the client definitions. I’ll add a drift test and make the comparison fail if either list changes without the matching server list.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: look.set replaces the entire look, and the server accepts stale base revisions, so an offline full-look write can overwrite newer account fields. I’m adding a red stale-revision regression before changing this to revision-aware per-field semantics.

J304 finding update: `look.set` replaces the entire look, and the server accepts stale base revisions, so an offline full-look write can overwrite newer account fields. I’m adding a red stale-revision regression before changing this to revision-aware per-field semantics.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:26:48 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304 finding update: a refused look.set can leave the controller's local-look protection latched. I’ll add a rejection-and-recovery regression before changing the journal/controller handoff.

J304 finding update: a refused `look.set` can leave the controller's local-look protection latched. I’ll add a rejection-and-recovery regression before changing the journal/controller handoff.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:38:02 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The orchestrator intentionally terminated the earlier dev-02 waiter (PID 518843); I am treating it as a queue reset, not a test failure. I resubmitted the same D365 red test once in the foreground through the fixed launcher. At 23:34 IST it reported all 3 slots busy and queued at position 4; the foreground run remains active. No code test has failed yet.

The orchestrator intentionally terminated the earlier dev-02 waiter (PID 518843); I am treating it as a queue reset, not a test failure. I resubmitted the same D365 red test once in the foreground through the fixed launcher. At 23:34 IST it reported all 3 slots busy and queued at position 4; the foreground run remains active. No code test has failed yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:47:38 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 red evidence (dev-02, Bun 1.4.4): bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts exited 1 with 4 pass / 1 fail / 734 assertions. The new gradient assertion reported 4,125 failures; for example Paper fg3 is 3.88:1 and accent 4.11:1 against #cce8ff. This first probe compared all roles against gradient tone stops, which is broader than rendered-point sampling; I’m replacing it with an audit of the composite field per built-in gradient before adjusting tokens.

D365 red evidence (dev-02, Bun 1.4.4): `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` exited 1 with 4 pass / 1 fail / 734 assertions. The new gradient assertion reported 4,125 failures; for example Paper fg3 is 3.88:1 and accent 4.11:1 against `#cce8ff`. This first probe compared all roles against gradient tone stops, which is broader than rendered-point sampling; I’m replacing it with an audit of the composite field per built-in gradient before adjusting tokens.
kayg commented 2026-11-08 23:57:11 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Progress: the revised composite-gradient D365 red run is still queued in the foreground on dev-02. Its latest status showed all 3 slots busy with 5 earlier waiters, placing it sixth; it has not produced a test result. The intentional old PID 518843 stop remains recorded as a queue reset. I’m preserving the new run and preparing the independent stale-look refusal regression.

Progress: the revised composite-gradient D365 red run is still queued in the foreground on dev-02. Its latest status showed all 3 slots busy with 5 earlier waiters, placing it sixth; it has not produced a test result. The intentional old PID 518843 stop remains recorded as a queue reset. I’m preserving the new run and preparing the independent stale-look refusal regression.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:03:23 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The earlier dev-02 waiter (PID 518843, bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts) was stopped by the orchestrator; exit 143 is not a test failure. I resubmitted the same command once in the foreground as PID 670592. Current dev-02 status has 3 occupied slots and 5 queued jobs; this run is queued third. I will report its output when it starts and finishes.

The earlier dev-02 waiter (PID 518843, bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts) was stopped by the orchestrator; exit 143 is not a test failure. I resubmitted the same command once in the foreground as PID 670592. Current dev-02 status has 3 occupied slots and 5 queued jobs; this run is queued third. I will report its output when it starts and finishes.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:10:23 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Queue update: the replacement audit run PID 670592 is still waiting behind PID 662935; all 3 dev-02 slots remain occupied. The command has not run yet, and I have not submitted a duplicate. The earlier PID 518843 stop remains excluded as a test failure.

Queue update: the replacement audit run PID 670592 is still waiting behind PID 662935; all 3 dev-02 slots remain occupied. The command has not run yet, and I have not submitted a duplicate. The earlier PID 518843 stop remains excluded as a test failure.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:18:14 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The replacement foreground run completed on dev-02: bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts reported 4 pass, 2 fail, 736 assertions. The D365 regression is real: 3,832 role/gradient pairs fail; Paper/Aurora examples include fg3 #707075 at 3.30:1 and accent #3d63dd at 3.49:1 over #fdbfff. The other failure exposed a stale sampler fixture (#cce8ff; generated endpoint is #aedaff); I am correcting that fixture and will rerun to leave the contrast failure as the red baseline. The orchestrator-stopped PID 518843 remains excluded as a test failure.

The replacement foreground run completed on dev-02: `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` reported 4 pass, 2 fail, 736 assertions. The D365 regression is real: 3,832 role/gradient pairs fail; Paper/Aurora examples include fg3 #707075 at 3.30:1 and accent #3d63dd at 3.49:1 over #fdbfff. The other failure exposed a stale sampler fixture (`#cce8ff`; generated endpoint is `#aedaff`); I am correcting that fixture and will rerun to leave the contrast failure as the red baseline. The orchestrator-stopped PID 518843 remains excluded as a test failure.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:20:17 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

After correcting the stale sampler endpoint expectation, I resubmitted bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts once in the foreground on dev-02 (PID/SSH session 88083). The fixed three-slot launcher accepted it at queue position 4 with all slots busy. No palette production code has changed; I will use this isolated red baseline before adjusting tokens.

After correcting the stale sampler endpoint expectation, I resubmitted `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` once in the foreground on dev-02 (PID/SSH session 88083). The fixed three-slot launcher accepted it at queue position 4 with all slots busy. No palette production code has changed; I will use this isolated red baseline before adjusting tokens.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:28:02 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

The corrected foreground red run completed on dev-02. Output: build-slot: [00:23:10] got slot 2/3; bun test v1.4.4; 5 pass; 1 fail; 738 expect() calls; Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [2.22s]. The sampler endpoint checks now pass. The remaining failure is the D365 all-role gradient audit: 3,832 role/gradient pairs; first examples are Paper/Aurora fg2 #65656a 3.88:1, fg3 #707075 3.30:1, and accent #3d63dd 3.49:1 over #fdbfff. This is the red baseline for the palette/gradient fix.

The corrected foreground red run completed on dev-02. Output: `build-slot: [00:23:10] got slot 2/3`; `bun test v1.4.4`; `5 pass`; `1 fail`; `738 expect() calls`; `Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [2.22s]`. The sampler endpoint checks now pass. The remaining failure is the D365 all-role gradient audit: 3,832 role/gradient pairs; first examples are Paper/Aurora fg2 #65656a 3.88:1, fg3 #707075 3.30:1, and accent #3d63dd 3.49:1 over #fdbfff. This is the red baseline for the palette/gradient fix.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:38:09 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 green evidence: foreground dev-02 run bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts reported 6 pass, 0 fail, 738 expect() calls, 2.38s. The gate now checks all roles over every sampled built-in gradient. The gradient stops are clamped channelwise to the readable side of each scheme background, so intermediate alpha blends cannot reduce contrast. Measured worst ratios after the fix: Paper 4.547:1 (ANSI white #707076 on #f6f6f4) and Ink 4.527:1 (bright black #7a7a80 on #0d0e10). Gradient-center swatches: Paper #aedaff -> #f6ffff; Ink #13226a -> #050010. The initial red evidence remains the 3,832 failures documented above.

D365 green evidence: foreground dev-02 run `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` reported 6 pass, 0 fail, 738 expect() calls, 2.38s. The gate now checks all roles over every sampled built-in gradient. The gradient stops are clamped channelwise to the readable side of each scheme background, so intermediate alpha blends cannot reduce contrast. Measured worst ratios after the fix: Paper 4.547:1 (ANSI white `#707076` on `#f6f6f4`) and Ink 4.527:1 (bright black `#7a7a80` on `#0d0e10`). Gradient-center swatches: Paper `#aedaff` -> `#f6ffff`; Ink `#13226a` -> `#050010`. The initial red evidence remains the 3,832 failures documented above.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 00:58:34 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Foreground rerun of bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts on dev-02. The orchestrator-stopped waiter remains recorded as cut, not as a test failure. An initial replacement acquired a slot but exited before test startup because bun was not on the launcher PATH; rerunning through nix develop /home/claude/worktrees/themes-sync-j304 -c bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts passed: 6 pass, 0 fail, 738 expect() calls, Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s].

Foreground rerun of `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` on dev-02. The orchestrator-stopped waiter remains recorded as cut, not as a test failure. An initial replacement acquired a slot but exited before test startup because `bun` was not on the launcher PATH; rerunning through `nix develop /home/claude/worktrees/themes-sync-j304 -c bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` passed: `6 pass`, `0 fail`, `738 expect() calls`, `Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s]`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 01:04:29 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 gradient contrast finding: the previous solid-surface audit missed 3,832 role/scheme/gradient failures. Paper/Aurora fg3 (#707075) fell to 3.30:1 and accent (#3d63dd) to 3.49:1 over #fdbfff.

The expanded audit composites every built-in gradient in CSS paint order and checks every text role at each whole-percent sample. The foreground dev-02 rerun passed: 6 pass, 0 fail, 738 expect() calls, Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s]. The weakest sampled results are Paper 4.547:1 and Ink 4.527:1.

Swatches are ordered left-to-right before/after, Paper on top and Ink below: Paper #aedaff → #f6ffff; Ink #13226a → #050010. The document keeps the earlier D80 repair log and records this D365 gradient extension.

D365 Ink and Paper gradient swatches

D365 Ink and Paper gradient swatches

D365 gradient contrast finding: the previous solid-surface audit missed 3,832 role/scheme/gradient failures. Paper/Aurora `fg3` (`#707075`) fell to 3.30:1 and accent (`#3d63dd`) to 3.49:1 over `#fdbfff`. The expanded audit composites every built-in gradient in CSS paint order and checks every text role at each whole-percent sample. The foreground dev-02 rerun passed: `6 pass`, `0 fail`, `738 expect() calls`, `Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s]`. The weakest sampled results are Paper `4.547:1` and Ink `4.527:1`. Swatches are ordered left-to-right before/after, Paper on top and Ink below: Paper `#aedaff` → `#f6ffff`; Ink `#13226a` → `#050010`. The document keeps the earlier D80 repair log and records this D365 gradient extension. ![D365 Ink and Paper gradient swatches](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/60446a71-9501-4b7b-bb07-4cadc3459e85) ![D365 Ink and Paper gradient swatches](https://git.kayg.org/attachments/24edda23-cc01-4378-9145-2331891ce000)
theme-gradient-swatches.png
1.6 KiB
kayg commented 2026-11-09 01:05:07 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 gradient contrast is implemented and pushed as aaa93e4a4. The focused dev-02 audit passed: 6 pass, 0 fail, 738 expect() calls, Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s]. The before/after Ink and Paper swatches and the weakest contrast results are attached in the preceding comment.

D365 gradient contrast is implemented and pushed as `aaa93e4a4`. The focused dev-02 audit passed: `6 pass`, `0 fail`, `738 expect() calls`, `Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.84s]`. The before/after Ink and Paper swatches and the weakest contrast results are attached in the preceding comment.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 01:08:59 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Starting J392's Nerd Symbols notice finding. The existing notice attributes the entire subset to Maple Mono OFL, while the shipped glyph ranges include seven upstream sources. I added a production notice assertion for every range and the full licence texts; its red baseline is queued on dev-02 behind active browser/gate work (queue position 4). No notice or licence implementation has been changed yet.

Starting J392's Nerd Symbols notice finding. The existing notice attributes the entire subset to Maple Mono OFL, while the shipped glyph ranges include seven upstream sources. I added a production notice assertion for every range and the full licence texts; its red baseline is queued on dev-02 behind active browser/gate work (queue position 4). No notice or licence implementation has been changed yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 01:22:50 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Red-first evidence from one foreground production browser run on dev-02 (bun x playwright test --grep "Nerd Symbols subset|interface font can be changed|44 px touch targets"):

  • Nerd Symbols notice: failed on missing Pomicons U+E000–E00A attribution before the remaining expected source-range/licence assertions.
  • D366 Settings control: failed because section[data-kind="ui-font"] is absent.
  • Coarse-pointer custom background: failed because the Solid tab is 38 px high, below 44 px. The spec also checks Gradient and Add/Remove.

The production build and browser launched successfully; all three regressions failed on the missing behavior/content. No implementation changes for these findings have been made yet.

Red-first evidence from one foreground production browser run on dev-02 (`bun x playwright test --grep "Nerd Symbols subset|interface font can be changed|44 px touch targets"`): - Nerd Symbols notice: failed on missing `Pomicons U+E000–E00A` attribution before the remaining expected source-range/licence assertions. - D366 Settings control: failed because `section[data-kind="ui-font"]` is absent. - Coarse-pointer custom background: failed because the Solid tab is 38 px high, below 44 px. The spec also checks Gradient and Add/Remove. The production build and browser launched successfully; all three regressions failed on the missing behavior/content. No implementation changes for these findings have been made yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 01:54:07 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Branch update: merged current origin/dev 6b60f1fb7 cleanly at 55c1f33cf and pushed themes-sync-j304. The canceled PID 518843 remains excluded as a test failure. I resubmitted bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts once through the corrected dev-02 launcher; remote PID 1065992 has advanced to queue position 1. Latest build-slot --status shows 3/3 active slots and this run first in the queue, with 82G free. No assertion has run yet.

Branch update: merged current origin/dev 6b60f1fb7 cleanly at 55c1f33cf and pushed themes-sync-j304. The canceled PID 518843 remains excluded as a test failure. I resubmitted bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts once through the corrected dev-02 launcher; remote PID 1065992 has advanced to queue position 1. Latest build-slot --status shows 3/3 active slots and this run first in the queue, with 82G free. No assertion has run yet.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:03:26 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Nerd Symbols licence check: apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh records the seven shipped ranges; Nerd Fonts upstream glyph metadata identifies Pomicons as OFL, Powerline/Seti/Devicons/Octicons as MIT, Font Awesome as CC BY 4.0, and Font Logos as Unlicense (https://github.com/ryanoasis/nerd-fonts/blob/master/src/glyphs/README.md and https://github.com/ryanoasis/nerd-fonts/blob/master/license-audit.md). These terms allow the font asset to ship beside the AGPL-3.0-only app while retaining its separate licences. The notice and full texts are now drafted; the production notice spec is pending dev-02.

Nerd Symbols licence check: apps/tracer/fonts/subset.sh records the seven shipped ranges; Nerd Fonts upstream glyph metadata identifies Pomicons as OFL, Powerline/Seti/Devicons/Octicons as MIT, Font Awesome as CC BY 4.0, and Font Logos as Unlicense (https://github.com/ryanoasis/nerd-fonts/blob/master/src/glyphs/README.md and https://github.com/ryanoasis/nerd-fonts/blob/master/license-audit.md). These terms allow the font asset to ship beside the AGPL-3.0-only app while retaining its separate licences. The notice and full texts are now drafted; the production notice spec is pending dev-02.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:19:01 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 audit rerun on dev-02 (themes-sync-j304 @ 55c1f33cf): 19 pass, 0 fail, 3,667 assertions. This includes the worst-sampled-point audit for every text role over every built-in gradient. The first build-slot wrapper remained queued with all three slots busy; I cancelled it before the test started, then ran the same one-file Bun test directly in the Nix shell, as allowed for a quick unit test. That cancellation was not a test failure.

Captured output: /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-audit-direct-rerun-20261109.log.

D365 audit rerun on dev-02 (`themes-sync-j304` @ `55c1f33cf`): **19 pass, 0 fail, 3,667 assertions**. This includes the worst-sampled-point audit for every text role over every built-in gradient. The first build-slot wrapper remained queued with all three slots busy; I cancelled it before the test started, then ran the same one-file Bun test directly in the Nix shell, as allowed for a quick unit test. That cancellation was not a test failure. Captured output: `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-audit-direct-rerun-20261109.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:31:22 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

ID-list drift regression: dev-02 Bun run passed: 1 pass, 0 fail, 4 assertions. It compares the client's selectable theme/font IDs with the server's bounded allowlists, including duplicate rejection, so a new choice cannot silently become unsavable.

Output: /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-id-contract.log.

ID-list drift regression: dev-02 Bun run passed: **1 pass, 0 fail, 4 assertions**. It compares the client's selectable theme/font IDs with the server's bounded allowlists, including duplicate rejection, so a new choice cannot silently become unsavable. Output: `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-id-contract.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:38:39 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Offline look conflict red evidence (dev-02): cargo test -p infraternal-server appearance_edits_are_persisted_for_only_the_authorized_account -- --nocapture compiled and reached the intended new assertion. It failed because a look.set based on revision 2 was accepted after the account document had advanced to revision 3 (an offline look cannot overwrite a newer account revision). This isolates the stale whole-look replacement gap; ordinary layout intents still use the existing stale-revision merge rules.

Output: /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-red.log.

Offline look conflict red evidence (dev-02): `cargo test -p infraternal-server appearance_edits_are_persisted_for_only_the_authorized_account -- --nocapture` compiled and reached the intended new assertion. It failed because a `look.set` based on revision 2 was accepted after the account document had advanced to revision 3 (`an offline look cannot overwrite a newer account revision`). This isolates the stale whole-look replacement gap; ordinary layout intents still use the existing stale-revision merge rules. Output: `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-red.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:54:43 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Progress: the green look.set compare-and-set rerun is first in dev-02's build-slot queue and has waited about 15 minutes; all three slots are still occupied. The real-server recovery and production UI browser runs are queued behind it. No result is being counted from a queued run. I will keep the foreground sessions active and continue after each starts.

Progress: the green `look.set` compare-and-set rerun is first in dev-02's build-slot queue and has waited about 15 minutes; all three slots are still occupied. The real-server recovery and production UI browser runs are queued behind it. No result is being counted from a queued run. I will keep the foreground sessions active and continue after each starts.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:57:57 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365/J392 offline-look CAS is green on dev-02: appearance_edits_are_persisted_for_only_the_authorized_account passed after the server began requiring the exact current revision for look.set. It preserves the revision-3 account look and rejects the stale revision-2 replacement. The focused red and green outputs are saved at:

  • /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-red.log
  • /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-green.log
D365/J392 offline-look CAS is green on dev-02: `appearance_edits_are_persisted_for_only_the_authorized_account` passed after the server began requiring the exact current revision for `look.set`. It preserves the revision-3 account look and rejects the stale revision-2 replacement. The focused red and green outputs are saved at: - `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-red.log` - `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/theme-look-cas-green.log`
kayg commented 2026-11-09 02:57:57 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Focused production browser checks on dev-02 passed: interface font can be selected in Appearance and saved with the account look; Solid, Gradient, Add and Remove controls reach 44 px on a coarse pointer; and the Nerd Symbols notice serves all mapped source ranges and full license texts. Result: 3 passed (41.6s).

Output: /home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/themes-production-focused-20261109.log.

Focused production browser checks on dev-02 passed: interface font can be selected in Appearance and saved with the account look; Solid, Gradient, Add and Remove controls reach 44 px on a coarse pointer; and the Nerd Symbols notice serves all mapped source ranges and full license texts. Result: **3 passed (41.6s)**. Output: `/home/kayg/.cache/codex-scratch/j304/evidence/themes-production-focused-20261109.log`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 03:17:11 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Resuming J304 on themes-sync-j304 at 22a981116. The current origin/dev is 966c52e070b2476aa0e17e9f8413d23a451c38d1; I am merging it before the remaining fixes.

The orchestrator intentionally stopped dev-02 waiter PID 518843; that was not a test failure. I reran bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts in the foreground on dev-02 through build-slot inside the repo Nix shell:

6 pass
0 fail
738 expect() calls
Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.93s]

The offline-look real-server spec has two regressions. The stale-look CAS case passes after the server compare-and-set fix. The recovery case is still red: after client A changes the account look to tinted, client B stays frosted because a refused look.set leaves the bridge's local-pending guard set. I am fixing the refusal notification and snapshot recovery path next.

Resuming J304 on `themes-sync-j304` at `22a981116`. The current `origin/dev` is `966c52e070b2476aa0e17e9f8413d23a451c38d1`; I am merging it before the remaining fixes. The orchestrator intentionally stopped dev-02 waiter PID `518843`; that was not a test failure. I reran `bun test packages/ui/src/theme-audit.test.ts` in the foreground on dev-02 through `build-slot` inside the repo Nix shell: ``` 6 pass 0 fail 738 expect() calls Ran 6 tests across 1 file. [1.93s] ``` The offline-look real-server spec has two regressions. The stale-look CAS case passes after the server compare-and-set fix. The recovery case is still red: after client A changes the account look to `tinted`, client B stays `frosted` because a refused `look.set` leaves the bridge's local-pending guard set. I am fixing the refusal notification and snapshot recovery path next.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 03:33:31 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J392 offline-look recovery finding, red evidence on dev-02 after the required origin/dev merge:

bun test apps/tracer/src/canvas/model/server-store.test.ts -t "a refused look requests a fresh snapshot"
Expected: 1 resync
Received: 0
0 pass, 1 fail; 3 assertions reached

This confirms the root cause: the server store drops a definitively refused look.set without requesting a fresh canvas snapshot. The page's localLookPending guard then keeps later remote looks from applying. The separate real-server regression had the same symptom: after client A changed the account look to tinted, client B stayed frosted.

A build-slot waiter for this one-file quick unit test sat behind older jobs for 9m32s; I stopped that exact queued PID before execution, then ran the same test directly in the dev-02 Nix shell as permitted for a single quick unit test. The direct run above is the actual red result; the queued waiter's exit is not a test result.

J392 offline-look recovery finding, red evidence on dev-02 after the required `origin/dev` merge: ``` bun test apps/tracer/src/canvas/model/server-store.test.ts -t "a refused look requests a fresh snapshot" Expected: 1 resync Received: 0 0 pass, 1 fail; 3 assertions reached ``` This confirms the root cause: the server store drops a definitively refused `look.set` without requesting a fresh canvas snapshot. The page's `localLookPending` guard then keeps later remote looks from applying. The separate real-server regression had the same symptom: after client A changed the account look to `tinted`, client B stayed `frosted`. A build-slot waiter for this one-file quick unit test sat behind older jobs for 9m32s; I stopped that exact queued PID before execution, then ran the same test directly in the dev-02 Nix shell as permitted for a single quick unit test. The direct run above is the actual red result; the queued waiter's exit is not a test result.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 03:46:23 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

D365 before/after swatches for the two named schemes, from docs/design/THEME-AUDIT.md:

Scheme Text role Before After
Paper fg3 #8d8d92 #707075
Paper ok #1f9d55 #00823c
Paper ANSI white text #8d8d93 #707076
Ink fg3 #5f5f65 #818187
Ink ANSI black text #1b1c1f #797b7e
Ink bright ANSI black text #5c5c62 #7a7a80

The SVG attached to this comment shows each before and after sample on its scheme surface. The current worst sampled gradient ratios in the D365 audit are Paper 4.547:1 and Ink 4.527:1.

D365 before/after swatches for the two named schemes, from `docs/design/THEME-AUDIT.md`: | Scheme | Text role | Before | After | |---|---|---|---| | Paper | fg3 | `#8d8d92` | `#707075` | | Paper | ok | `#1f9d55` | `#00823c` | | Paper | ANSI white text | `#8d8d93` | `#707076` | | Ink | fg3 | `#5f5f65` | `#818187` | | Ink | ANSI black text | `#1b1c1f` | `#797b7e` | | Ink | bright ANSI black text | `#5c5c62` | `#7a7a80` | The SVG attached to this comment shows each before and after sample on its scheme surface. The current worst sampled gradient ratios in the D365 audit are Paper `4.547:1` and Ink `4.527:1`.
j304-ink-paper-d365.svg
3.6 KiB
j304-ink-paper-d365.svg
kayg commented 2026-11-09 05:04:54 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c resumed on themes-sync-j304 (continuing from 5cb6aef2a, which already contains origin/dev 966c52e07). J304 left uncommitted work on dev-02 (refused look.set recovery plus server compare-and-set). I recovered it and pushed it as two atomic commits; branch head is now 848799f7f.

  • fix(server): require the exact current revision for look.set
  • fix(tracer): a refused look.set requests a fresh snapshot

Focused unit run on dev-02 (log ~/j304c-ev/unit.log on dev-02): theme audit, id-contract drift test, server-store and themes model tests: 48 pass, 0 fail, 1791 expect() calls.

Queued: production build + transfer-budget.ts, theme and notice specs, verify quick on dev-02; verify fast on compute01 (log ~/j304c-ev/fast.log). Real-server two-client spec and the 393×852 editor screenshots come next.

J304c resumed on `themes-sync-j304` (continuing from 5cb6aef2a, which already contains origin/dev 966c52e07). J304 left uncommitted work on dev-02 (refused `look.set` recovery plus server compare-and-set). I recovered it and pushed it as two atomic commits; branch head is now `848799f7f`. - `fix(server): require the exact current revision for look.set` - `fix(tracer): a refused look.set requests a fresh snapshot` Focused unit run on dev-02 (log `~/j304c-ev/unit.log` on dev-02): theme audit, id-contract drift test, server-store and themes model tests: **48 pass, 0 fail, 1791 expect() calls**. Queued: production build + `transfer-budget.ts`, theme and notice specs, `verify quick` on dev-02; `verify fast` on compute01 (log `~/j304c-ev/fast.log`). Real-server two-client spec and the 393×852 editor screenshots come next.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 05:29:19 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

Finding (J304c): the compare-and-set J304 left uncommitted was too coarse, so I changed it.

Evidence: with look.set required to carry the exact current document revision, real/appearance-sync.spec.ts on dev-02 went 3 failed / 5 passed (log ~/j304c-ev/run2.log on dev-02): "theme and font changes reach the same account live..." (camera jumped), and both migration specs (look undefined). Cause: the client fixes base_revision when it queues an edit, so a look queued behind the tab's own layout edits or migration is refused.

Fix (head 3f608f46f): the server refuses a look.set only if another non-noop look.set landed after its base, or the retained operation tail no longer covers every revision after the base (it refuses and the client resyncs). Layout edits in between do not conflict. The client rebases unsent looks queued behind its own accepted look. Rejected: a per-field look intent (new wire op plus merge rules), and a stored look revision in the document (schema/fuzz/migration change). Also fixed on this branch: the Themes window spec's section list now includes the new "Interface font" section; verify quick doc-comment rows.

The earlier themes.spec.ts + third-party-notices.spec.ts run on dev-02 (including the 393×852 captures) passed except that stale section list; rerun pending. Proof run is queued: ~/j304c-ev/run3.log on dev-02.

Finding (J304c): the compare-and-set J304 left uncommitted was too coarse, so I changed it. Evidence: with `look.set` required to carry the exact current document revision, `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts` on dev-02 went **3 failed / 5 passed** (log `~/j304c-ev/run2.log` on dev-02): "theme and font changes reach the same account live..." (camera jumped), and both migration specs (`look` undefined). Cause: the client fixes `base_revision` when it queues an edit, so a look queued behind the tab's own layout edits or migration is refused. Fix (head `3f608f46f`): the server refuses a `look.set` only if another non-noop `look.set` landed after its base, or the retained operation tail no longer covers every revision after the base (it refuses and the client resyncs). Layout edits in between do not conflict. The client rebases unsent looks queued behind its own accepted look. Rejected: a per-field look intent (new wire op plus merge rules), and a stored look revision in the document (schema/fuzz/migration change). Also fixed on this branch: the Themes window spec's section list now includes the new "Interface font" section; `verify quick` doc-comment rows. The earlier `themes.spec.ts` + `third-party-notices.spec.ts` run on dev-02 (including the 393×852 captures) passed except that stale section list; rerun pending. Proof run is queued: `~/j304c-ev/run3.log` on dev-02.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 06:51:56 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c progress, head c990d57c1 (pushed; git ls-remote confirms).

Done and proven on dev-02 (logs ~/j304c-ev/run3.log, run4.log, run5.log, run6.log; copies in ~/.cache/codex-scratch/j304c/evidence/):

  • D365 gradient audit: verify quick runs it, PASS (every text role over the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient).
  • Theme + notice specs: 28 passed (production build), including the interface-font control, Nerd Symbols ranges/licence texts, and the 44 px Solid/Gradient/Add/Remove targets on a coarse pointer at 393×852.
  • Real-server two-client spec real/appearance-sync.spec.ts: 8 passed, including the stale offline look and the refused-look recovery.
  • bun run transfer-budget.ts: exit 0, no cap raised. Gzip: critical 320,909 B (cap 327,680), deferred 57,522 B (61,440), largest on-demand chunk 17,444 B (20,480). Only new per-font family entries were added.
  • verify quick at a1c1d45b7: all rows PASS (fmt, clippy, unit tests, doc comments, typecheck, D365 audit).

Also fixed this round: the first verify fast on compute01 failed only because the audit test hit bun's 5 s default timeout (12 s under load); it now has a 60 s limit. All other fast rows were PASS, including static builds. verify fast is re-queued on compute01 (position 12 of the queue, log ~/j304c-ev/fast2.log).

Screenshot at 393×852, custom-background editor open with Add/Remove: ~/.cache/codex-scratch/j304c/evidence/shots/phone-393x852-custom-background-editor.png.

J304c progress, head `c990d57c1` (pushed; `git ls-remote` confirms). Done and proven on dev-02 (logs `~/j304c-ev/run3.log`, `run4.log`, `run5.log`, `run6.log`; copies in `~/.cache/codex-scratch/j304c/evidence/`): - D365 gradient audit: `verify quick` runs it, **PASS** (every text role over the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient). - Theme + notice specs: **28 passed** (production build), including the interface-font control, Nerd Symbols ranges/licence texts, and the 44 px Solid/Gradient/Add/Remove targets on a coarse pointer at 393×852. - Real-server two-client spec `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts`: **8 passed**, including the stale offline look and the refused-look recovery. - `bun run transfer-budget.ts`: exit 0, no cap raised. Gzip: critical 320,909 B (cap 327,680), deferred 57,522 B (61,440), largest on-demand chunk 17,444 B (20,480). Only new per-font family entries were added. - `verify quick` at `a1c1d45b7`: all rows **PASS** (fmt, clippy, unit tests, doc comments, typecheck, D365 audit). Also fixed this round: the first `verify fast` on compute01 failed only because the audit test hit bun's 5 s default timeout (12 s under load); it now has a 60 s limit. All other fast rows were PASS, including static builds. `verify fast` is re-queued on compute01 (position 12 of the queue, log `~/j304c-ev/fast2.log`). Screenshot at 393×852, custom-background editor open with Add/Remove: `~/.cache/codex-scratch/j304c/evidence/shots/phone-393x852-custom-background-editor.png`.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 08:12:36 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c: verify fast on compute01 at c990d57c1 (log ~/j304c-ev/fast2.log) failed one row, test (exit 101): real_binary_rootless_cleanup_survives_sender_disconnect_before_readiness, a terminal/agent test with resource_unavailable while the machine was loaded. This branch does not touch it; it passed in the earlier fast run (fast.log) and 3 of 3 isolated reruns on compute01. All other rows were PASS in that run's table, including the previous head's static builds. Re-running fast once more (fast3.log); I will report its result.

J304c: `verify fast` on compute01 at `c990d57c1` (log `~/j304c-ev/fast2.log`) failed one row, `test` (exit 101): `real_binary_rootless_cleanup_survives_sender_disconnect_before_readiness`, a terminal/agent test with `resource_unavailable` while the machine was loaded. This branch does not touch it; it passed in the earlier fast run (`fast.log`) and 3 of 3 isolated reruns on compute01. All other rows were PASS in that run's table, including the previous head's static builds. Re-running fast once more (`fast3.log`); I will report its result.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 09:52:36 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c finish. Branch themes-sync-j304, head c990d57c1 (git ls-remote origin themes-sync-j304 confirms). Not merged.

Findings closed

  • P2 D365 gradient gap: audit covers every text role over the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient; verify quick D365 row PASS.
  • P2 Nerd Symbols notice: every source range credited with licence texts; notice spec passes.
  • P2 phone touch targets: Solid/Gradient/Add/Remove ≥ 44 px on a coarse pointer, spec passes at 393×852; screenshot attached to the earlier comment.
  • P3 interface-font control in Settings › Appearance (packages/ui); P3 server/client theme and font id drift test.
  • P3 look.set conflict handling. J304's whole-document revision compare-and-set broke 3 real-server specs (migration, unmoved cameras), so it is now: refuse only if another look landed after the base, or the retained tail no longer covers the base (client resyncs). A refused look no longer blocks later remote looks.

Proof

  • Real-server two-client spec: 8 passed (run4.log). Theme + notice specs: 28 passed.
  • transfer-budget.ts: exit 0, no cap raised. Gzip critical 320,909 B / 327,680; deferred 57,522 / 61,440; largest on-demand chunk 17,444 / 20,480.
  • verify quick at a1c1d45b7: all rows PASS (run5.log).

verify fast on compute01: NOT green. Table rows all PASS except test (FAIL 101) in each of the two full runs at head c990d57c1, with a different unrelated test each time and static builds PASS:

  • fast2.log: real_binary_rootless_cleanup_survives_sender_disconnect_before_readiness (resource_unavailable).
  • fast3.log: login_binary::tests::cleanup_preserves_running_images_for_fallback_adoption ("Text file busy").
    Both are terminal/agent tests this branch does not touch; each passed 3 of 3 isolated reruns on compute01. The first run at an earlier head had passed the test row, and its only failure was the audit timeout, now fixed. I did not run origin/dev to prove the flakes there. A clean gate needs a rerun on a quieter compute01.

Question for the orchestrator (not the owner): whether to accept these two load flakes or rerun fast.

J304c finish. Branch `themes-sync-j304`, head `c990d57c1` (`git ls-remote origin themes-sync-j304` confirms). Not merged. **Findings closed** - P2 D365 gradient gap: audit covers every text role over the worst sampled point of every built-in gradient; `verify quick` D365 row PASS. - P2 Nerd Symbols notice: every source range credited with licence texts; notice spec passes. - P2 phone touch targets: Solid/Gradient/Add/Remove ≥ 44 px on a coarse pointer, spec passes at 393×852; screenshot attached to the earlier comment. - P3 interface-font control in Settings › Appearance (packages/ui); P3 server/client theme and font id drift test. - P3 `look.set` conflict handling. J304's whole-document revision compare-and-set broke 3 real-server specs (migration, unmoved cameras), so it is now: refuse only if another look landed after the base, or the retained tail no longer covers the base (client resyncs). A refused look no longer blocks later remote looks. **Proof** - Real-server two-client spec: 8 passed (`run4.log`). Theme + notice specs: 28 passed. - `transfer-budget.ts`: exit 0, no cap raised. Gzip critical 320,909 B / 327,680; deferred 57,522 / 61,440; largest on-demand chunk 17,444 / 20,480. - `verify quick` at `a1c1d45b7`: all rows PASS (`run5.log`). **`verify fast` on compute01: NOT green.** Table rows all PASS except `test` (FAIL 101) in each of the two full runs at head `c990d57c1`, with a different unrelated test each time and static builds PASS: - `fast2.log`: `real_binary_rootless_cleanup_survives_sender_disconnect_before_readiness` (`resource_unavailable`). - `fast3.log`: `login_binary::tests::cleanup_preserves_running_images_for_fallback_adoption` ("Text file busy"). Both are terminal/agent tests this branch does not touch; each passed 3 of 3 isolated reruns on compute01. The first run at an earlier head had passed the `test` row, and its only failure was the audit timeout, now fixed. I did not run origin/dev to prove the flakes there. A clean gate needs a rerun on a quieter compute01. Question for the orchestrator (not the owner): whether to accept these two load flakes or rerun fast.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 12:45:39 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c round 3: J425's P2 (second look.set in flight is refused, latest pick lost) is fixed. Head 8a324254b, pushed.

Fix (journal.ts): next() no longer sends a look.set while another look of this tab is sent but unacknowledged; the existing rebase on the receipt gives it the right base. Looks that have not left yet coalesce into the latest one. Unit tests in journal-confirmation.test.ts (hold, release with rebased base, coalescing); bun test src/canvas/model passes.

Red first (real server, dev-02, ~/j304c-ev/red-final*.log):

  • Frosted, wait 900 ms, Solid at 1 s one-way latency: Expected "solid", Received "frosted" on the pre-fix journal.
  • Three picks (Frosted, +900 ms Tinted, +300 ms Solid, 500 ms one-way = 1 s round trip): pre-fix ended Received "tinted" (1 of 2 runs red). Evenly spaced picks recover without the fix, so the third pick lands 300 ms after the second.

Green: whole real/appearance-sync.spec.ts with the fix: 10 passed (green7.log). The two new specs also passed 2/2 in green6.log. The two migration specs now wait for the seeded look (J425's P3 flake); I did not touch the drift-test or TASTE P3 items.

Test notes: the 1 s-latency setup is slow and was flaky on a loaded dev-02 (the first window sometimes did not appear in 150 s, also with the pre-fix journal), so the setup waits are 150 s and the three-pick spec uses 500 ms one-way. I ran these against the reviewer's release binary of c990d57c1 (server code unchanged here) because dev-02 was under its free-disk floor for a cargo build; the browser runs were direct, not through build-slot. verify quick is queued on compute01 for 8a324254b (~/j304c-ev/quick3.log).

J304c round 3: J425's P2 (second `look.set` in flight is refused, latest pick lost) is fixed. Head `8a324254b`, pushed. **Fix** (`journal.ts`): `next()` no longer sends a `look.set` while another look of this tab is sent but unacknowledged; the existing rebase on the receipt gives it the right base. Looks that have not left yet coalesce into the latest one. Unit tests in `journal-confirmation.test.ts` (hold, release with rebased base, coalescing); `bun test src/canvas/model` passes. **Red first** (real server, dev-02, `~/j304c-ev/red-final*.log`): - Frosted, wait 900 ms, Solid at 1 s one-way latency: `Expected "solid", Received "frosted"` on the pre-fix journal. - Three picks (Frosted, +900 ms Tinted, +300 ms Solid, 500 ms one-way = 1 s round trip): pre-fix ended `Received "tinted"` (1 of 2 runs red). Evenly spaced picks recover without the fix, so the third pick lands 300 ms after the second. **Green:** whole `real/appearance-sync.spec.ts` with the fix: **10 passed** (`green7.log`). The two new specs also passed 2/2 in `green6.log`. The two migration specs now wait for the seeded look (J425's P3 flake); I did not touch the drift-test or TASTE P3 items. Test notes: the 1 s-latency setup is slow and was flaky on a loaded dev-02 (the first window sometimes did not appear in 150 s, also with the pre-fix journal), so the setup waits are 150 s and the three-pick spec uses 500 ms one-way. I ran these against the reviewer's release binary of `c990d57c1` (server code unchanged here) because dev-02 was under its free-disk floor for a cargo build; the browser runs were direct, not through build-slot. `verify quick` is queued on compute01 for `8a324254b` (`~/j304c-ev/quick3.log`).
kayg commented 2026-11-09 13:12:54 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c round 3 final: head 12ab8be53 (pushed, git ls-remote confirms). verify quick on dev-02 at that head: QUICK_EXIT=0, all rows PASS (~/j304c-ev/quick4.log). Fix, red/green evidence and notes are in my previous comment. A doc-comment row flagged LayoutJournal.capture; documented in the last commit. verify fast is J425's to report; I did not rerun it.

J304c round 3 final: head `12ab8be53` (pushed, `git ls-remote` confirms). `verify quick` on dev-02 at that head: **QUICK_EXIT=0**, all rows PASS (`~/j304c-ev/quick4.log`). Fix, red/green evidence and notes are in my previous comment. A doc-comment row flagged `LayoutJournal.capture`; documented in the last commit. `verify fast` is J425's to report; I did not rerun it.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 15:52:15 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c round 4: J425's latent hole is fixed. Head c2680b9e4 (pushed, git ls-remote confirms).

Hole: when the server's operation event for our own look.set reaches the tab before the call response, accept() retires the look, the hold lifts and acknowledge() never runs, so the look queued behind keeps the old base and is refused.

Red first (journal-confirmation.test.ts, dev-02): a look queued behind our own look is rebased when that look's event arrives before its receipt failed with Expected: 2, Received: 1 (9 pass, 1 fail). Fix: accept() rebases unsent looks to the event's revision only when the event retires one of our own looks (shared #rebaseLooks helper with acknowledge()). A second test pins that another device's look does not rebase ours. Green: bun test src/canvas/model: 107 pass, 0 fail. verify quick on dev-02 at c2680b9e4: QUICK_EXIT=0, all rows PASS (~/j304c-ev/quick5.log). The delta is TypeScript only, so the real-server specs from round 3 were not rerun. The verify fast failures and the other P3 items are left as J425 said.

J304c round 4: J425's latent hole is fixed. Head `c2680b9e4` (pushed, `git ls-remote` confirms). **Hole:** when the server's operation event for our own `look.set` reaches the tab before the call response, `accept()` retires the look, the hold lifts and `acknowledge()` never runs, so the look queued behind keeps the old base and is refused. **Red first** (`journal-confirmation.test.ts`, dev-02): `a look queued behind our own look is rebased when that look's event arrives before its receipt` failed with `Expected: 2, Received: 1` (9 pass, 1 fail). **Fix:** `accept()` rebases unsent looks to the event's revision only when the event retires one of our own looks (shared `#rebaseLooks` helper with `acknowledge()`). A second test pins that another device's look does not rebase ours. **Green:** `bun test src/canvas/model`: 107 pass, 0 fail. `verify quick` on dev-02 at `c2680b9e4`: QUICK_EXIT=0, all rows PASS (`~/j304c-ev/quick5.log`). The delta is TypeScript only, so the real-server specs from round 3 were not rerun. The `verify fast` failures and the other P3 items are left as J425 said.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 17:03:31 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c: the two infraternal-server tests from J425's gate evidence, run 20 times each on the branch (c2680b9e4 build) and, for comparison, on origin/dev 5eb968744. dev-02, 4 copies of each test at once, 5 rounds, 8 busy loops running. Logs: ~/j304c-ev/flake2.log (branch) and flake3.log (dev) on dev-02.

Test branch origin/dev
remote_runtime::tests::standby::liveness_doubt::one_missed_primary_reply_shows_reconnecting_and_only_a_second_retires_the_link 20/20 20/20
bootstrap_runtime::remote_backend::tests::breakit2_concurrent_same_destination_issues_only_one_invitation 13/20 16/20

So the second test does not pass 20/20, and it does not on origin/dev either. The failure is the one in J425's gate run, reproduced on dev's own binary: assertion left == right failed: concurrent batches reserved the same destination and issued distinct host identities, left: 2 right: 1 (bootstrap_remote.rs:3277). Alone and idle it passed 20/20 on the branch. The test starts 8 batches for one destination and expects exactly one to win; under CPU load a second batch sometimes gets its identity issued. That is a timing race in the bootstrap code or its test, not in canvas code: canvas_store.rs is the branch's only change in that crate and neither test touches it. I have not looked for the root cause in bootstrap_remote.rs; that is outside this branch, and it needs its own issue.

Note: earlier in this job my first loop ran with the wrong filter (the tests only exist with the remote feature, which cargo test --workspace turns on) and reported 0 tests; those counts are discarded, the ones above are from the corrected run with --features remote. origin/dev has moved to 5eb968744; this branch is not rebased on it.

J304c: the two `infraternal-server` tests from J425's gate evidence, run 20 times each on the branch (`c2680b9e4` build) and, for comparison, on origin/dev `5eb968744`. dev-02, 4 copies of each test at once, 5 rounds, 8 busy loops running. Logs: `~/j304c-ev/flake2.log` (branch) and `flake3.log` (dev) on dev-02. | Test | branch | origin/dev | |---|---|---| | `remote_runtime::tests::standby::liveness_doubt::one_missed_primary_reply_shows_reconnecting_and_only_a_second_retires_the_link` | **20/20** | **20/20** | | `bootstrap_runtime::remote_backend::tests::breakit2_concurrent_same_destination_issues_only_one_invitation` | **13/20** | **16/20** | So the second test does **not** pass 20/20, and it does not on origin/dev either. The failure is the one in J425's gate run, reproduced on dev's own binary: `assertion left == right failed: concurrent batches reserved the same destination and issued distinct host identities, left: 2 right: 1` (`bootstrap_remote.rs:3277`). Alone and idle it passed 20/20 on the branch. The test starts 8 batches for one destination and expects exactly one to win; under CPU load a second batch sometimes gets its identity issued. That is a timing race in the bootstrap code or its test, not in canvas code: `canvas_store.rs` is the branch's only change in that crate and neither test touches it. I have not looked for the root cause in `bootstrap_remote.rs`; that is outside this branch, and it needs its own issue. Note: earlier in this job my first loop ran with the wrong filter (the tests only exist with the `remote` feature, which `cargo test --workspace` turns on) and reported 0 tests; those counts are discarded, the ones above are from the corrected run with `--features remote`. origin/dev has moved to `5eb968744`; this branch is not rebased on it.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 17:17:26 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c final: head 17da857fd (pushed, git ls-remote confirms). Added since the approved c2680b9e4: BACKGROUND_IDS in the server drift test (passes); 44 px gradient colour stops on a coarse pointer, measured by the phone spec at 393×852 (passes; Reset already reaches 44 px through its ::before hit area); TASTE row superseded; THEME-AUDIT note that custom looks are not audited. verify quick on dev-02 at 17da857fd: QUICK_EXIT=0, 13 of 13 rows PASS (~/j304c-ev/quick6.log). Flake counts are in the previous comment (one test 20/20, the other 13/20 on the branch and 16/20 on origin/dev). Targets deleted.

J304c final: head `17da857fd` (pushed, `git ls-remote` confirms). Added since the approved `c2680b9e4`: BACKGROUND_IDS in the server drift test (passes); 44 px gradient colour stops on a coarse pointer, measured by the phone spec at 393×852 (passes; Reset already reaches 44 px through its ::before hit area); TASTE row superseded; THEME-AUDIT note that custom looks are not audited. `verify quick` on dev-02 at `17da857fd`: QUICK_EXIT=0, 13 of 13 rows PASS (`~/j304c-ev/quick6.log`). Flake counts are in the previous comment (one test 20/20, the other 13/20 on the branch and 16/20 on origin/dev). Targets deleted.
kayg commented 2026-11-09 19:11:05 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy link

J304c: merged origin/dev bd551e549 into themes-sync-j304. Head b045c174b (pushed, git ls-remote confirms).

Conflicts: core-screen.ts kept this branch's lazily loaded Settings overlay and request guard, and uses #427's overlay API (it reads the input source itself); the palette is not closed by a remote look swap. main.ts: #442's sessionGeneration guard and the look sync merged together. settings-body and toast-stack took dev's wording and motionSettled.

Two fixes the merge needed: (1) setPalette(false, source) in the Themes palette row no longer type-checked after #427; (2) #442's sign-out spec found tracer.look.legacy-owner (an account id) left in localStorage; clearAccountStorage now removes it when it names the signed-out account.

On a production build, dev-02, head b045c174b (~/j304c-ev/merge3.log): verify quick QUICK_EXIT=0; sign-out, themes and keyboard-instant specs 68 passed; real-server appearance-sync.spec.ts 10 passed. Earlier run on the merge commit (merge2.log): themes, notices, keyboard-sweep, keyboard-instant, toast-stack 98 passed, and the only failure was the sign-out one fixed above. Keyboard-sweep was not rerun after the last two small commits.

J304c: merged origin/dev `bd551e549` into `themes-sync-j304`. Head `b045c174b` (pushed, `git ls-remote` confirms). **Conflicts:** core-screen.ts kept this branch's lazily loaded Settings overlay and request guard, and uses #427's overlay API (it reads the input source itself); the palette is not closed by a remote look swap. main.ts: #442's `sessionGeneration` guard and the look sync merged together. settings-body and toast-stack took dev's wording and `motionSettled`. **Two fixes the merge needed:** (1) `setPalette(false, source)` in the Themes palette row no longer type-checked after #427; (2) #442's sign-out spec found `tracer.look.legacy-owner` (an account id) left in localStorage; `clearAccountStorage` now removes it when it names the signed-out account. **On a production build, dev-02, head `b045c174b` (`~/j304c-ev/merge3.log`):** `verify quick` QUICK_EXIT=0; sign-out, themes and keyboard-instant specs 68 passed; real-server `appearance-sync.spec.ts` 10 passed. Earlier run on the merge commit (`merge2.log`): themes, notices, keyboard-sweep, keyboard-instant, toast-stack 98 passed, and the only failure was the sign-out one fixed above. Keyboard-sweep was not rerun after the last two small commits.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag specified
Branches Tags
main
j470b-server-mesh-rejoin
mesh-compat-382
j444b-d381-key-wins-flood
j461b-macos-utun-reader-thread
j475b-remove-host-motion
fix-reconnect-new-link
j481-d380
dev
j479-mesh-soak
fix/j476-host-facts
j475-motion-pill-split
j470-mac-node-join
root-upgrade-d376
j474-review-merge
latency-targets-120hz
nightly-suite-shards
gotatun-pin-j469
macos-utun-reader-thread
fix-flood-echo-stall
wip/j416
motion-fast-ease-out
mesh-addhost-j259
takeover-close-terminals-d368
kbd-instant-followups
fix-trust-key-double-click
nightly-suite-partial-report
appwin-icons-j207
rusqlite-slice1
swipe-content-first-d374
mesh-mtu-381
addhost-instant-open
glass-contrast-d365-mock
glass-contrast-d365
signout-followups-442
fix-startup-toast-red
research-gotatun-matrix-j317
themes-sync-j304
fix-load-flakes
fix-nix-zig-patch
fix-compute01-browser-baseline
ratchet-size-baseline-419
predict-auto-d130
revoke-coverage-d367
nightly-suite-queue-timeout
nightly-browser-suite
fix-rustsec-2026-0459
fonts-ioskeley-obel
log-retention-d375
fix-kbd-no-anim-427
fix-dev-red-specs-2
takeover-proof-305-j205
wip/j410-server-pump
ui-consistency-d372
fix-osc52-clipboard
libghostty-vt-1.0
forget-retired-host-d369
j404-merge-426
fix-setup-lock-race
fix-touch-select-426
revoke-access-report-ui
fix-predictive-echo-specs
fix-selinux-agent-exec
wip/j395-checkpoint2
wip/j395
j391-review-scratch
ui-consistency-j195-deferred-rebased
fix-rustc-paths-421
decisions-wording-341
fix-install-suite-red
fix-dev-rtt-specs
fix-pending-removal-align
fix-privileged-skip
fix-install-suite-404
review-j368
mesh-dns-j254
revoke-access-report-d356b
revoke-privilege-round5
fix-removal-confirm
review-j360
gotatun-rotation-367
deps-refresh-340
review-j354
review-J351
review-j350
addhost-takeover-d359
revoke-report-items-347
revoke-end-sessions-d362
review-j348
size-mesh-ssh-346
size-trim-337
revoke-access-diff-d356
j259-pre-rebase-b06c5a6
j305-ended-at-start-spec
addhost-sudo-consent
fix-layout-real-specs-411
fix-shell-open-411
fix-console-hosts-373
fix-shell-exit
fuzz-host-name-353
fix-host-details-410
macos-filter-j197
research-gotatun-tricks
revoke-p3-j216l
stale-state-pill
revoke-followups-j216k
revoke-progress-j216e
backup/macos01-20261106/lume/j197
backup/macos01-20261106/lume/appwin-icons-j207-stash0
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/stash-0
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/stash-1
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80-macos-s1
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80-slice1-20261102
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J16b-appwin-on-dev
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/appwin-launch-idle-146
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80-s1-run
wip/j259
trust-285-p3c
runtime-lock-j216f
mesh-ssh-p3-j175
tun-proof-p3b
trust-285-p3
terminal-polish-j271
tun-proof-p3
ssh-install-flakes-j216i
fuzz-fixes-j264
trust-285-a
trust-285-b
restart-oversized-fixture-j198
backup/macos01-20261106/lume/appwin-icons-j207
restart-bound-j216h
up-preflight-p3-j198
backup/macos01-20261106/lume/j251
up-preflight-j198
wip/up-preflight-j198-j245-p2
wip/up-preflight-j198-j245-p1
agent-fsync-offloop-j196
wip/up-preflight-j198-j245
settings-offscreen-j231
wip/up-preflight-j198-j226-inspection
wip/j103f
themes-j206
wip/up-preflight-j198-j226
flakes-j216c
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/j197
flakes-j216b
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/j197-red
wip/up-preflight-j198-review
flakes-j216
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/appwin-icons-j207
engineering-j208b
appwin-mock-j209
toast-stack-j165
engineering-j208
decisions-d351
decisions-d350
decisions-d349
appearance-presets-mock-j129
decisions-d348
docs-audit-spec
doc-coverage-baseline-raise
decisions-d347
decisions-d346b
decisions-d346
j88h-profile
ui-consistency-j195-deferred
ui-consistency-j195
engineering-practices-j194
preferred-login-ui-j166
signin-pools-263-j174
macos-node-265-s1
decisions-d345
decisions-d344
proxy-cgroup-j164
verify-quick-fuzz-329
proxy-start-io-j168
timing-flakes-j163
up-263-s1
mcp-events-j147
verify-quick-fuzz-j158
proxy-p3-j159
agent-resource-j157-detect
wip/j103d-final
remote-cancel-hang-j155
proxy-traefik-281-j62d
j149-verify-quick
proxy-traefik-281-j62b
j150-drop-unnamed
wip/j79d-red-r4
wip/j103d-d332
rootless-toast-j142
wip/j103d-head
wip/j103d
j125c-mcp
macos-build-j136
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/j136
wip/j79d-red-cli
wip/j79d-red-server
j121-link-liveness
j118c-tracer-failures
wip/j79c-head
release-desktop-j131
j124c-signed-macos
wip/j79c-red-p3
wip/j79c-red-p23
wip/j79c-red-p22
merge-j128-check
perf-deferred-j128
sidebar-toggle-260
j127-shortcut-changed-dot
j125-mcp
j118-tracer-failures
j126-account-summary
settings-sections-mock-j92
j120-pinch-lock
sidebar-292
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/j120
taste-2026-11-03
row-actions-242-215
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/stash-0-untracked
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80-265-s1-run
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/J80-macos-s1-20261102
j112-canvas-commands
ui-no-overshoot-scroll
fix-recovery-restart
backup/macos01-20261106/claude/stash-1-untracked
taste-2026-11-02
size-baseline-ratchet
machine-cards-structure-j108
j109-boot-copy-mockups
fix-dev-red
wip/up-263-s1
j95b-settings-rows
proxy-traefik-281
j95-option-rows
docs-human-j91
docs-keys-palette
fix-flood-1013-270-j38d
mesh-ssh-s1
mesh-ssh-s0
addhost-d291-tunnel
test-stability-load
mesh-relay-220
repro-296
shim-thp-off-24
mesh-pins-258-v2
mesh-dns
signin-d311-merged
docs-pages
ui-size-283
fix-ui-batch-specs
wip/j12b-edge-update
gate-on-arm
fix-rename-sync-293
trust-285-j60b
fix-focus-ring-clip
integ-ui-1101
edge-update-v2
signin-d311
taste-2026-11-01
layout-per-tab-250
ui-approved-splitopt-224
ui-approved-splitopt-224-on-dev
icon-text-centre-282
ui-approved-189-212-216
research-reverse-proxy
transfer-budget-320
review-mesh-pins-258-r2
sidebar-pill-259
review-mesh-relay-220
wip/j12-edge-update-v2
nix-package
status-crash-loop-237
fix-dev-test-failures
fix-fixture-socket-path
wip/mesh-relay-220-pre-dev-advance-rebase
fix-canvas-side-clip
research-head-to-head
frosted-real-256
review-mesh-pins-258
wip/mesh-relay-220-pre-final-rebase
review-layout-per-tab-250-r2
broad-suite-triage
nix-devshell
review-status-crash-loop-237-r3
wip/nix-devshell-pre-p3
taste-frosted-real
wip/code-serve-demo-2026-10-30
wip/code-serve-glass-2026-10-30
wip/code-serve-clusters-2026-10-30
wip/code-merge-release94-dev-2026-10-30
wip/rproxy-delta-scratch-2026-10-30
wip/stale-note-257-staged-2026-10-30
wip/d241-size-staged-2026-10-30
review-broad-suite-207
wip/mesh-pins-258-pre-split
wip/mesh-relay-220-pre-rebase
mesh-measure-220
plan-211-update
review-edge-autoupdate-r3
perf24-reconnect
review-stale-note-r2
release-prod-live
d241-shell-marker
review-mesh-pins-server-258
review-revocation-r3
review-setup-token-r2
review-sync-journal-r3
wip/review-mesh-pins-258-prune-review-1995fee46
frosted-scroll-256
sync-journal-r3
revocation-per-account-wip
review-tokio-asyncfd-0386
review-sync-p3s
wip/stash-8by64-stash0-2026-10-30
mesh-drag-r2
setup-token-data-wip
release-9-4
auth-busy-1013
mesh-view-overlap
sync-p3s
review-auth-busy-wake
review-readd-r8-wip
mesh-drag-bounds
audit-auth-93
app-windows-stream-start
review-authority-cap-r3
app-windows-r7-measure
readd-minimal-r6
readd-minimal-r5
app-windows-r7-soak
readd-minimal-r4
app-windows-r7
app-windows-r6
readd-minimal-r3
readd-minimal-r2
readd-minimal
merge-release8-dev
review-busy-page-liveness-r2
review-busy-page-liveness
mesh-view-trim
review-authority-read-retry-r2
review-remove-uninstall-r2
release-retry-reattach
release-retry
review-remove-uninstall
review-authority-read-retry
app-windows-ship
mesh-autoswitch-p2
mesh-ssh
mesh-relay
mesh-macos-node
screen-and-control
session-labels
review-real-logins-r5
review-real-logins-r4
review-real-logins-r3
shim-memory-r2
review-real-logins-r2
shim-memory
shadow-addhost-instant
shadow-real-logins
shadow-same-session-flood
shadow-prod-perf-fix
hosts-from-server
app-windows-real
app-windows-transport
release-prod-6w
mesh-policy-verify
quiet-close-toast
dev-merge-r4
review-mesh-agent-transport
review-app-windows-transport
settings-roundtrip
review-release-pipeline-r4
mesh-agent-transport
ended-strip-fix
review-audit-ca-update-d244
settings-rows
phone-width
signout-clear
fix-restart-tests
dev-merge-rp
signer-hardening
review-audit-ca-update
terminal-fidelity
review-audit-ca-update-wip
mesh-integrate
review-mesh-agent-transport-515d3712
review-mesh-dataplane-feec1988
mesh-dataplane
signout
research-canvas-node
wip/review-renderer-cost
wip/review-terminal-fidelity
padlock-glyph
review-release-pipeline-2e95b689
phone-polish
sidebar-polish
inbox-generic
review-mesh-dataplane-378d4055
prod-batch
ui-inbox
ui-ca-unlock
ui-machine-sections
review-mesh-dataplane-a5f744fb
tls-session-prod
session-bounds-prod
fix-dead-session
session-bounds
tls-session
palette-polish
shortcuts-d222
research-appmeta
phone-gutter
ui-centre-button
wip/ui-centre-button
wip/tls-session
review-addhost-breakit
ui-platform
renderer-cost
remote-agents
mesh-api
ssh-bootstrap
prod-hotfix2
prod-fixes
review-remote-agents
review-mesh-dataplane
session-life
research-browser
review-mesh-api
research-capture
review-mesh-api-round3
review-mesh-api-round1
gate-stability
review-gate-stability
review-relay-direct
review-mesh-api-findings
proto-sessions
font-picker
proto-addhost
proto-windows
mesh-core
latency-gate
research-bsd
research-discovery
keytray-mods
mock-core
ui-tweaks
fix-motion-sel
fix-motion
integrate2
fix-robust
t-web
t-server
vt-ghostty
fix-snap-echo
t-web-auth
review-vt2
t-agent
lane-protocol
lane-shim
lane-auth
s1-base
s1-contracts
s1-workspace
No results found.
Labels
Clear labels   
launch-qa
Findings from launch QA.

No labels
launch-qa
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
kayg/infraternal#323
No description provided.